Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Fallacy: "If you don't like Apple, don't buy" - Fallacy of escaping the walled-garden

phrehdd said:
Linux/Unix - still using archaic command line (based on early limited ascii)
Click to expand...

We've had this thing called X11 (or Quartz Extreme if your Unix comes from that fruit vendor) since ... well.. the 90s or 80s even. And the Command line, at least on all the Unix systems I use, are UTF-8 with support for UTF-16 if I wish. ASCII ? Heck, haven't heard of plain old 7 bit ASCII in almost 25 years, we've had Extended ASCII for quite a while...

What an uninformed post.
 
This post makes no sense.

There is nothing forcing you to stay within Apple's walled garden and buy their products. No one is pointing a gun at your head and telling you to buy an iPhone 5 over a Samsung Galaxy S3. The choice is 100% yours.

If the walled garden is a massive deal to you on, say, a tablet, you have competitors to choose from. Go buy a Nexus 7 or a Microsoft Surface, no one's stopping you.
 
0dev said:
This post makes no sense.

There is nothing forcing you to stay within Apple's walled garden and buy their products. No one is pointing a gun at your head and telling you to buy an iPhone 5 over a Samsung Galaxy S3. The choice is 100% yours.

If the walled garden is a massive deal to you on, say, a tablet, you have competitors to choose from. Go buy a Nexus 7 or a Microsoft Surface, no one's stopping you.
Click to expand...

The problem would be for people that are invested in the Apple ecosystem. People that bought peripherals that implemented Apple only technology or stored media/files in a format exclusive to Apple, using proprietary technology that isn't freely implementable elsewhere.

An OS should be just an OS, your pick of formats should always be the most open possible and the devices you use should be standards compliant at all times to prevent yourself from being locked-into a single vendor for your future needs.
 
KnightWRX said:
We've had this thing called X11 (or Quartz Extreme if your Unix comes from that fruit vendor) since ... well.. the 90s or 80s even. And the Command line, at least on all the Unix systems I use, are UTF-8 with support for UTF-16 if I wish. ASCII ? Heck, haven't heard of plain old 7 bit ASCII in almost 25 years, we've had Extended ASCII for quite a while...

What an uninformed post.
Click to expand...

Unix/Linux command line remains based on the limited amount of ascii when Unix first came about. Now be a good little boy and do your history and see how much larger ascii set is these days and then you just might understand what I am talking about. Yawn at flaming on line. - So passe'
 
KnightWRX said:
The problem would be for people that are invested in the Apple ecosystem. People that bought peripherals that implemented Apple only technology or stored media/files in a format exclusive to Apple, using proprietary technology that isn't freely implementable elsewhere.
Click to expand...

For me it is a lot more than just having been caught investing too much in Apple apps and hardware.

Dare I admit it, but it comes down to a singular preference to use OSX rather than Windows. Sure, Windows (7) has been much better, and don't get me started about Windows 8. I far prefer OSX.

I value beauty of design. I was at the computer store today, and from my perspective all the PC notebook computers look disgustingly ugly. It's as if PC designers have a knack for making computers look like supermarket plastic packaging containers.

So, when people say no one is holding a gun to my head, I would say there are intangibles that cause me to want to use OSX.
 
KnightWRX said:
The problem would be for people that are invested in the Apple ecosystem. People that bought peripherals that implemented Apple only technology or stored media/files in a format exclusive to Apple, using proprietary technology that isn't freely implementable elsewhere.

An OS should be just an OS, your pick of formats should always be the most open possible and the devices you use should be standards compliant at all times to prevent yourself from being locked-into a single vendor for your future needs.
Click to expand...

That's your fault for buying all your content from Apple then. In regards to apps it can't really be helped, but for media content it can.
 
phrehdd said:
Unix/Linux command line remains based on the limited amount of ascii when Unix first came about. Now be a good little boy and do your history and see how much larger ascii set is these days and then you just might understand what I am talking about. Yawn at flaming on line. - So passe'
Click to expand...

It seems you tried to insult knightwrx in some way, but you don't actually make any sense at all. Did you vote it up yourself?
 
phrehdd said:
Unix/Linux command line remains based on the limited amount of ascii when Unix first came about. Now be a good little boy and do your history and see how much larger ascii set is these days and then you just might understand what I am talking about. Yawn at flaming on line. - So passe'
Click to expand...

I know exactly what you're talking here.

Its called total ****.
 
tekno said:
It's $120 billion. Makes you sick, doesn't it?!
Click to expand...

Why would it make you sick? It makes me more jealous than anything else. But hey, Apple earned it by making products people wanted to buy and were willing to pay a premium for.
 
phrehdd said:
Linux/Unix - still using archaic command line (based on early limited ascii)
Click to expand...

Really? I'm typing this in Firefox for Linux, running on my iMac in a Virtualbox VM, Linux Mint w/KDE, a fully-developed GUI. With full Unicode support. True, there are still things that are easier to do from the CLI, but have you never opened the Terminal in OS X? The differences have become pretty small.
 
phrehdd said:
Unix/Linux command line remains based on the limited amount of ascii when Unix first came about. Now be a good little boy and do your history and see how much larger ascii set is these days and then you just might understand what I am talking about. Yawn at flaming on line. - So passe'
Click to expand...

Again, uh ?

Code: 
$ env | grep LANG
LANG=en_CA.UTF-8

That we don't use anything but characters available in the ASCII set doesn't mean it is so limited. You should really educate yourself about modern Linux/Unix systems.

And my point was that Linux/Unix is not limited to a command line to begin with either.

----------
katewes said:
Dare I admit it, but it comes down to a singular preference to use OSX rather than Windows.
Click to expand...

Then you're not locked in. If the hardware doesn't fill your needs and you keep using it, based on some preference the problem is not the ecosystem. The problem is putting your preferences before your needs.

----------
MacCruiskeen said:
Really? I'm typing this in Firefox for Linux, running on my iMac in a Virtualbox VM, Linux Mint w/KDE, a fully-developed GUI. With full Unicode support. True, there are still things that are easier to do from the CLI, but have you never opened the Terminal in OS X? The differences have become pretty small.
Click to expand...

It's especially funny considering OS X is a Unix system. He said OS X was archaic and only used a command line limited to the 7 bit ASCII table.
 
KnightWRX said:
The problem would be for people that are invested in the Apple ecosystem. People that bought peripherals that implemented Apple only technology or stored media/files in a format exclusive to Apple, using proprietary technology that isn't freely implementable elsewhere.

An OS should be just an OS, your pick of formats should always be the most open possible and the devices you use should be standards compliant at all times to prevent yourself from being locked-into a single vendor for your future needs.
Click to expand...

The fact is that you as a consumer made a conscious choice to buy an Apple product.

And your idea that an OS should be just an OS sounds great on paper. But frankly, it's a terrible business model. At the end of the day, if you can't make money, you won't be in business for very long.
 
vvswarup said:
The fact is that you as a consumer made a conscious choice to buy an Apple product.

And your idea that an OS should be just an OS sounds great on paper. But frankly, it's a terrible business model. At the end of the day, if you can't make money, you won't be in business for very long.
Click to expand...

Boy that MS I just don't know how they've been in business for almost 40 years. That Linux adoption rate for big companies is pretty pathetic too :rolleyes:
 
vvswarup said:
The fact is that you as a consumer made a conscious choice to buy an Apple product.

And your idea that an OS should be just an OS sounds great on paper. But frankly, it's a terrible business model. At the end of the day, if you can't make money, you won't be in business for very long.
Click to expand...

My idea has worked fine for me for years. OS X supports pretty much every standard and open format, so I can use Apple hardware and their OS and not be locked to Apple's ecosystem. I don't think you understood what I meant or you just don't know enough about what's out there.
 
I hear you, katewes, but I'm not feeling it as much as you, perhaps.

For example, I have a 30" Apple Cinema Display with the matte screen, and will run it until it dies, when I will buy a Dell matte screen or some other. I also have a PC, Android phone and iPhone, and I use Google and Adobe products on both Apple and non-Apple devices.

I just don't feel trapped at all at the moment. Also, Windows 7 is awesome, as much as I do like OS X... Snow Leopard, at least. :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back