Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you install Windows 8 with an EFI card (with bootcamp or USB drive methods), it will enable EFI.
When you format your hard drive under advanced mode, a GPT will be used. (check for a partition called "Reserved MSR")
If you preformatted your drive with MBR, windows will refuse to install and force you to format again.
Then, if you switch for an non-EFI GPU, you get a black screen (+blinking cursor on top left of screen). This is because no EFI is present in the GPU ROM

So let‘s say I want to convert my old Mac Pro into a Windows gaming PC without having OS X installed, I could just simply add empty hard drives and the Mac Pro would boot up in BIOS mode?
 
So let‘s say I want to convert my old Mac Pro into a Windows gaming PC without having OS X installed, I could just simply add empty hard drives and the Mac Pro would boot up in BIOS mode?

Technically yes. I did install Windows quite a few times on my cMP without bootcamp (only boot from the DVD and then run through the installation). So, OSX should be totally irrelevant in this matter (even though my OSX boot disk still there).
 
If you boot Windows 8 with a install DVD (without bootcamp), Mac HD unplugged, with a Non-EFI GPU, MacPro will switch to CSM and you will get display. If you format your Windows drive it will be an MBR partition table.
You can proceed to win install and install drivers.
I installed from USB drive. Should I still try to boot with USB drive plugged in with Mac HD unplugged?
 
Technically yes. I did install Windows quite a few times on my cMP without bootcamp (only boot from the DVD and then run through the installation). So, OSX should be totally irrelevant in this matter (even though my OSX boot disk still there).

I thought Pigsyn mentioned that it will only switch to BIOS mode (or CSM) when there is no USB drive and no OS X partition in the system...
 
I could not get display with usb drive and non-efi gtx970 only.
Only from windows 8 DVD.
I could double check this W-E, but I have to remove the gtx970 from my pc, remove watercooling block mount back stock cooler... DO NOT WANT !§
 
I thought Pigsyn mentioned that it will only switch to BIOS mode (or CSM) when there is no USB drive and no OS X partition in the system...

I am not sure about this, because I was not start from scratch. I installed Windows quite a few times with bootcamp. But then I realise that I can just boot from the disk and install windows (including format the drive to NTFS). My card is an EFI card, so I always have screen to work with.

I almost know nothing about those CMS, MBR, GPT... stuff. May be my HDD is already in the correct mode because I did run bootcamp long time ago. So that I can install Windows straight away.
 
Update:

got an extra mini 6 pin power cable for the ATI 5770 and so I have both gtx 970 and 5770 running at the same time. Booted into windows with the 5770 and installed the nvidia driver. Now the 970 is working on windows side. Finally...

Thanks for all the help!

will attempt to boot with the 970 to see if it works without the 5770.
 
I received my mac pro 5.1 this weekend, it came with a 5870 that has been replaced by a GTX680. I made the flash process following the guides found here and everything went well. My question is simple:
- If I install the nVidia driver will have some performance gain or run with OS X native driver is okay?
 
It depends (software, OSX version, driver version, etc), but seems at this moment using the Nvidia web driver is a better choice. If that is not working well on your 5,1. You can always fallback to native OSX driver by few clicks. So, it's an advantage that you can choose between drivers.
 
It depends (software, OSX version, driver version, etc), but seems at this moment using the Nvidia web driver is a better choice. If that is not working well on your 5,1. You can always fallback to native OSX driver by few clicks. So, it's an advantage that you can choose between drivers.
I have seen no benchmark or other evidence to demonstrate that the nVidia web drivers offer any advantage for GTX680 nor have I personally noticed any difference in use,
 
I have seen no benchmark or other evidence to demonstrate that the nVidia web drivers offer any advantage for GTX680 nor have I personally noticed any difference in use,

Thanks for your sharing, I didn't own the 680 and my reply based on the Nvidia website.

http://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/2015/08/31/mac-driver/

I believe the 680 is one of the Kepler card, so it can benefit from the performance boost (in some applications). But surely your personal experience is a better reference then my Google search.
 
It depends (software, OSX version, driver version, etc), but seems at this moment using the Nvidia web driver is a better choice. If that is not working well on your 5,1. You can always fallback to native OSX driver by few clicks. So, it's an advantage that you can choose between drivers.

I have seen no benchmark or other evidence to demonstrate that the nVidia web drivers offer any advantage for GTX680 nor have I personally noticed any difference in use,

Mac Pro 5.1
24GB Ram
2x2.93ghz
El Capitan 10.11.3
I don't know where can I check the version of the native driver, but I believe it is the latest available. My main use is with Adobe CC. I will test this week with the native driver and the next with the nVidia.
 
Mac Pro 5.1
24GB Ram
2x2.93ghz
El Capitan 10.11.3
I don't know where can I check the version of the native driver, but I believe it is the latest available. My main use is with Adobe CC. I will test this week with the native driver and the next with the nVidia.
What do you do with 24 gigabytes of RAM?
 
Those benchmarks do not test the native drivers. There is a comparison between two different versions of the nVidia web driver used on the GTX980 Ti GTX980 & GTX680

The old web drivers were comparable to the native drivers in many/most cases. The new ones are significantly faster. What more do you want? Yes, they could've included stock drivers for the GTX 680 but if they're basically identical to the old web drivers why bother?
 
What do you do with 24 gigabytes of RAM?
This machine is fully dedicated to my work: images and video at high resolutions.

The old web drivers were comparable to the native drivers in many/most cases. The new ones are significantly faster. What more do you want? Yes, they could've included stock drivers for the GTX 680 but if they're basically identical to the old web drivers why bother?
I'll do some tests during the next days and see which one works best in my work environment.

Thanks to all.
 
Last edited:
There has been a fair amount of confusion about the NVIDIA PC card support since it was last enabled in the 10.7.3 web driver. I'm going to use the term PC card to describe a stock card with no EFI, that is, any old NVIDIA graphics card that you can buy online or from your local computer store.

First of all a huge thanks you. This is the most interesting post about the topic I've found in days. I have a Mac Pro 5.1 and I'm exploring the idea of updgrading my default 5770 and, even being kind of an expert in the Mac area I TOTALLY missed the fact I could aim for regular PC cards. Thanks again, you opened a world to me.

Now the hard stuff :)

Having used Mac for 20 years and always with their default hardware, I am completely out of the scenes if we talk about the millions of GPU and brands and options available...and for this reason my post will most probably appear as a classical newbie thing.

So...let's say I want a better video card, mainly for gaming, with a non crazy budget, something around 200 GBP; a card which I can supply easily, let's say from Amazon...where should I look into? You suggest EVGA brand, and there's many options on Amazon...but no specs present, for example, about the power requirements (6 or 8 pins, etc.)

If someone has time, I'd strongly appreciate some real suggestions :)

Thanks in advance

Tampano
 
What do you do with 24 gigabytes of RAM?

I don't know how about him, but my machine constantly use up 24G of RAM (or more, the rest are all used as cache). I have 32G of RAM, and I simply use my Mac for Safari, HandBrake (almost running 24/7), FCPX (light editing, nothing close to professional), Chrome, Mail... these kind of "normal stuff".
Screen Shot 2016-02-16 at 02.15.57-1.jpg

I did think about run the RAM in 3x8 config for best speed. However, I end up still use 4x8G, and make sure I won't run out of RAM (however, my machine still occasionally need to use Swap).
 
Last edited:
So...let's say I want a better video card, mainly for gaming, with a non crazy budget, something around 200 GBP; a card which I can supply easily, let's say from Amazon...where should I look into? You suggest EVGA brand, and there's many options on Amazon...but no specs present, for example, about the power requirements (6 or 8 pins, etc.)

MacVidCards now has a UK partner set up. That may well be your best option. Here's a link.
 
The old web drivers were comparable to the native drivers in many/most cases. The new ones are significantly faster. What more do you want? Yes, they could've included stock drivers for the GTX 680 but if they're basically identical to the old web drivers why bother?
There is no benchmark evidence & in real life use I see no difference. The new web drivers may well be faster on the GTX980 which cannot use the native drivers but we don't have any evidence that this is true of the GTX680.
 
First of all a huge thanks you. This is the most interesting post about the topic I've found in days. I have a Mac Pro 5.1 and I'm exploring the idea of updgrading my default 5770 and, even being kind of an expert in the Mac area I TOTALLY missed the fact I could aim for regular PC cards. Thanks again, you opened a world to me.
Now the hard stuff :)
Having used Mac for 20 years and always with their default hardware, I am completely out of the scenes if we talk about the millions of GPU and brands and options available...and for this reason my post will most probably appear as a classical newbie thing.
So...let's say I want a better video card, mainly for gaming, with a non crazy budget, something around 200 GBP; a card which I can supply easily, let's say from Amazon...where should I look into? You suggest EVGA brand, and there's many options on Amazon...but no specs present, for example, about the power requirements (6 or 8 pins, etc.)
If someone has time, I'd strongly appreciate some real suggestions :)
Thanks in advance
Tampano
I chose the gtx 680 because I was looking for a GPU with a good performance and an attractive price, it may be a good alternative for you too. But if you're looking for an alternative plug and play with bootscreen without surprises, look at macvidcards.com, I have never traded with him, but based on what I read about him, surely he will be able to help you.

I don't know how about him, but my machine constantly use up 24G of RAM (or more, the rest are all used as cache). I have 32G of RAM, and I simply use my Mac for Safari, HandBrake (almost running 24/7), FCPX (light editing, nothing close to professional), Chrome, Mail... these kind of "normal stuff".
View attachment 616675
I did think about run the RAM in 3x8 config for best speed. However, I end up still use 4x8G, and make sure I won't running out of RAM (however, my machine still occasionally need to use Swap).
I don't use 3x8 as you imagined, but 6x4, the idea is upgrade to 64gb soon.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.