Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The "separated from its owner" point is interesting. How does the tag report that it's not with its owner? Is this part of the protocol?

I was always curious about this. If two people are travelling on a bus together, one with an AirTag, the other with this detection feature, does the tag say "Yes, I'm still with my owner, don't worry." ...?
 
Ah, let the false alerts come.
Exactly where will they draw the line for what bluetooth items the will warn you of?
In my nightmare, alerts for all kinds of bluetooth devices will pop up and ruin your day.

This doesn't detect Bluetooth signals of any kinds. The devices must be speaking a certain "language" over Bluetooth. A "Tracking Tag" language. And the alert only gets raised after a while of tracking tags traveling with you "for a while". They will not pop up immediately in the presence of a tag.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kitKAC and 1129846
The "separated from its owner" point is interesting. How does the tag report that it's not with its owner? Is this part of the protocol?

I was always curious about this. If two people are travelling on a bus together, one with an AirTag, the other with this detection feature, does the tag say "Yes, I'm still with my owner, don't worry." ...?
That’s correct. It doesn’t alert those nearby if it’s traveling with its owner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cheesehead Dave
How common is stalking with AirTags? There have been so many articles about AirTag stalking, but I never heard of a case of someone who was stalked using an AirTag.
 

“Google's New Anti-Stalking Measure Will Direct You To A Page Where You Can Delete All Google Apps In One Click.”​


I don’t need this, ‘cause I refuse to use Google, but I’m sure it’ll come in handy for some.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: gusmula
How common is stalking with AirTags? There have been so many articles about AirTag stalking, but I never heard of a case of someone who was stalked using an AirTag.

As in all things, a few bad apples. I'm confident that these have been used for some stalking. Because of how they work, they could easily be used that way by anyone wanting to do so. And they are much cheaper than hiring "Eddie and the boys" to "follow 'em" and "stake out where they go at all hours."

A search of news stories will likely find some examples (1, 2, 3, and that was with only the quickest, quick search). I've seen a few stories that have typically been one spouse tracking another and catching them in lies/cheating.

My guess is a tiny fraction of all trackers in use are used for stalking... like guns or poisons or bombs or knives: a tiny few are used for crime, much larger numbers are not.

Since there is little to no newsworthy stories about intended use, the odd uses get the press... and lead to "solutions" like this. Today in lunch prep, I used 3 sharp knives to prepare the meal. Nobody wrote a story. My use of knives won't make the news. Someone somewhere will stab someone else with one knife and it may make national news. Ban all knives everywhere because they hurting or killing people!!! Knives are no good!

A couple of weeks ago- as it is EVERY year- there were several stories of shark bites from around the world. Exterminate all sharks! Don't go in any water that may have sharks in it! We simply forget all the other days where there are no reported shark bites. Kill all sharks!

Plane crash. Ban all planes. They kill dozens to hundreds of people at a time. But we forget all the days there is no news about planes successfully arriving and all the passengers getting to their destinations just fine. Ban all planes!
 
Last edited:
It’s more intended for clumsy people like me anyway. One time I was out with my dog and realized my keys were not in my jacket. I had no idea where I could have lost them but was thankfully able to find them in the middle of a park.

Another time (also walking the dog), I realized I didn’t have my car keys anymore just as I was back by the car, I found them on the map and chased back to get them. You won’t believe what happens next, I am on my way back to the car again and realized I also dropped my wallet! Went back AGAIN and found my wallet. I somehow had the idea to put an AirTag in my wallet the day prior. Thank god I did
You might need to stop walking your dog. 😉
 
Tile has a tracker approx size/thickness of biz card. Battery is not replaceable but find your wallet one it’s paid for itself.
 
Ironic that someone who uses a devices that tracks everything they do and sells it to the highest bidder can't find a small white & silver device attached to them. Unless a business or school requires me to use google I stay as far away from that company as possible. It reminds me of the cigerette industry.. 9/10 doctors recommend ...
 

Attachments

  • unknown.jpg
    unknown.jpg
    97.4 KB · Views: 61
  • Disagree
Reactions: gusmula
So are AirTags completely useless in tracking your stolen items? Seems like thieves immediately know the bike or camera bag they stole has a tracker in it, make it beep, and then toss it, right?
You bought the wrong product. It was never intended nor advertised to recover/track stolen items.
 
And yet that has been a major use. E.g. "New York Police Department Encourages Car Owners to Use AirTags to Deter Theft, 500 Free AirTags Available." So my question then stands, are Air Tags no longer good for this very real (yet unintended) use?
They never good at tracking stolen items. NYPD needs to spend more time reducing the theft/crime, instead of giving devices which aren’t meant for tracking stolen items.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gusmula
Yes, the irony: a tool presumably intended to foil one kind of bad guy (stalkers) will assist another type of bad guy (thieves) in maximizing their criminal opportunity.

I don't have the stats but I would guess that towards 9X% of tracker buyers are not buying for stalking purposes. So a few bad apples spoil the whole bunch. But of course, that's nothing new at all.

The CEO of Google is simply scared his wife finds out that he is cheating. That is all.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: gleepskip
This doesn't detect Bluetooth signals of any kinds. The devices must be speaking a certain "language" over Bluetooth. A "Tracking Tag" language. And the alert only gets raised after a while of tracking tags traveling with you "for a while". They will not pop up immediately in the presence of a tag.
... in a perfect world.
Imagine super-cheap BT-tracker-emulators being hidden on buses, trains, planes, everywhere there's transport.
If the "language" is to be availble for many different brands of devices, you can be sure there will be instructions for making a BT-tracker-emulator using super-cheap chips like ESP8266 (which is WiFi only, but you get my point).
 
And yet that has been a major use. E.g. "New York Police Department Encourages Car Owners to Use AirTags to Deter Theft, 500 Free AirTags Available." So my question then stands, are Air Tags no longer good for this very real (yet unintended) use?
They were never good for tracking stolen stuff. There are much better trackers on the market for tracking your car.
 
It’s more intended for clumsy people like me anyway. One time I was out with my dog and realized my keys were not in my jacket. I had no idea where I could have lost them but was thankfully able to find them in the middle of a park.

Another time (also walking the dog), I realized I didn’t have my car keys anymore just as I was back by the car, I found them on the map and chased back to get them. You won’t believe what happens next, I am on my way back to the car again and realized I also dropped my wallet! Went back AGAIN and found my wallet. I somehow had the idea to put an AirTag in my wallet the day prior. Thank god I did
Hi...are you me? Because this sounds exactly like a usual day for me LOL
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.