My Xr was a revelation with its original os release. You were very sensible staying on it.
I just can’t resist the os updates even though you should never go one more then then one generation after the ios version that you device shipped with.
By the time it had iOS 16, its battery life was awful (admittedly it had gone down to early 80s battery capacity %age, but still).
My other phones?:
3GS - used to die mid afternoon if I went out for a day and took a few photos and texted a little etc.
4s - actually I remember this one being kinda ok. It wasn’t great but it was ok.
5s - had to carry a battery pack around with me as the battery life was appalling from the start. The 4g model simply drew too much power and it needed a bigger battery.
7 - was ok, but it always felt that the thinness was prioritised over battery life, which fell off a cliff with iOS 11.
Xr - have discussed
13 - terrible battery life from the start. The 5g modem ripped through the battery. There’s a theme here.
And now currently on the 16e, which is great. And I can see why apple has moved to their own 5g modem.
I was tempted by the 16 plus I have to say, but I want to wait until the ‘iPhone 17 air’ gets its next iteration as I want a phone that’s a little thinner, smaller and lighter than that. Glad it is working out for you. It’s a really nice phone.
A 6.5 screen would be the sweet spot for me, but hey 6.7 is fine if they keep on shrinking those bezels and chassis down.
Yeah, I always stay behind. As you can probably imagine by what I mentioned, I keep my iPhones (and iPads!) for a long time. I am not a frequent upgrader. Since I never update and upgrade very infrequently, that means that iOS compatibility on my older iPhones is very feeble, so I can’t go to a different iPhone if I am unsatisfied and I can’t downgrade either. If I am going to keep an iPhone or iPad for years on end, I have to stay behind if I want quality. I figure stuff out with compatibility. I grab different devices. I use my Mac if Safari fails, I do what I can with what I have to stay behind. I need my devices to be good and sadly, this is the only way and it has been from day one. I can’t use an iPhone for 5.5 years as my main iPhone if it’s going to collapse by year 2.5.
Interestingly, a friend also got an iPhone Xʀ on iOS 12 (a little before I got mine), but they loved to update everything and we discussed this a lot. The Xʀ changed their mind. By iOS 15, the phone was reaching the end of the day, but barely. Ending it with 5% when compared to the 40-50% it ended up with on iOS 12. By iOS 16, it was obliterated. They upgraded to their current 13… which remains on iOS 15 after I recommended never updating for years on end.
I used a 5s (which I bought late and therefore always had iOS 8.2 on it) and battery life with Wi-Fi was usable. Like you said, enable LTE and battery life collapsed, giving me about 3 hours of SOT which is simply unusable. The only “victim” I ever had, I dropped a power bank on it which destroyed the tempered glass and the screen underneath. The phone is in a drawer, broken, still on iOS 8.2.
I used a 6s on iOS 9 and on LTE it was infinitely better than the 5s. It matched a friend’s iPhone 7 on iOS 10, so I think they were similar. iOS 11 destroyed both, but I didn’t update after Apple forced it out of iOS 9 into iOS 13 four years later and I already had the Xʀ.
The 16e seems pretty similar to the 16 Plus, so it should be as amazing as mine. It’s incredible what they did, really. A regular-sized iPhone with the battery life of a Plus model. Almost like the 1st-gen SE! That one, on iOS 9, almost matched the 6s Plus. It wasn’t quiiiiite there, but it was very, very close. Screenshots shared by Forum users showed about 9-10 hours of light SOT, a smidge above the 7-8 of the regular 6s and a little below the 11-12 of the 6s Plus (which I can confirm because I got that on my iPhone 7 Plus on iOS 10).
I think that, relative to size, the 1st-gen SE and the 16e are the best iPhones ever in terms of battery life. The 16e may be due to the modem and the battery size relative to device size. I think the little SE was due to the absurd efficiency of the A9 on iOS 9. I think that the only combo to be better than that is the A12 on iOS 12, which was praised on every device, including the third-gen (and first full-screen design) A12X iPad Pro. Sadly, I don’t think many third-gen iPad Pros remain on iOS 12. I have NEVER seen one mentioned.
Hopefully the Air has a good battery life. It seems it’s the sweet spot for you and I hope Apple delivers.
Frankly, the 16 Plus is uncomfortable to use with one hand. I was fine with the Xʀ, but the Plus is definitely the absolute limit. I can barely take pictures with one hand, so it’s not truly one-handed. I knew that when buying, and I actually considered the regular 16, but since the 7 Plus I mentioned was broken (I couldn’t exchange it on time and it had a broken camera… sad, because I wanted to try Portrait mode and it didn’t work. The main camera was blurry, too), I wanted to give the Plus a fair try.