Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

spiderman0616

Suspended
Aug 1, 2010
5,670
7,499
I take off my watch when using my 16" (except when it's connected to an external display and keyboard).
I always wonder if people commonly do that. The rivets on the watch bands must do a number on people's palm rests. This is one of those situations where I'm glad I took "Keyboarding" in high school. Our teacher was such a stickler about never resting your hands on the keyboard while typing that I just got in the habit early of not doing that. I've tried and it literally feels uncomfortable to me. ? My MacBooks always have pristine palm rests when I get rid of them!
 

prospervic

macrumors 65816
Aug 2, 2007
1,154
1,433
NYC
I always wonder if people commonly do that. The rivets on the watch bands must do a number on people's palm rests. This is one of those situations where I'm glad I took "Keyboarding" in high school. Our teacher was such a stickler about never resting your hands on the keyboard while typing that I just got in the habit early of not doing that. I've tried and it literally feels uncomfortable to me. ? My MacBooks always have pristine palm rests when I get rid of them!
I was taught this same thing in my piano lessons. Probably be good to bring that technique over to my typing!
 

petvas

macrumors 603
Jul 20, 2006
5,479
1,808
Munich, Germany
For me this is a simple answer. If you use the MacBook Pro as your only computer, and you are not very often mobile, then keep the 16". If you already have a desktop computer or a big display to connect your MBP and you like something more compact and mobile, then keep the 14".
I have the 14" and I love it. I also have a Mac Studio though with the Studio Display..
 
  • Like
Reactions: kikote

jav6454

macrumors Core
Nov 14, 2007
22,303
6,264
1 Geostationary Tower Plaza
Going with the 16... despite preferring the size of the 14, everything else on the 16 wins (fans, screen size, temp of the case itself, battery)... too hard to pass it up. I'll deal with the size.
I would have stated go with the one that has better battery life and better heat dissipation. Which depending on the workload could go either way. But glad you sorted it out.
 

0228662

Cancelled
Apr 17, 2022
19
25
I do love my 16" MacBook Pro M1, but if there were an 18" or do I dare say a 20", I would opt for one of them. I am one of those that pretty much carries my MacBook Pro with me just about everywhere.
 

0228662

Cancelled
Apr 17, 2022
19
25
Darn, me personally, I wouldn't be hauling anything bigger than 14".
well for some reason it hasn't felt bulky or noticeably heavy to me. Also, I just like having this screen. I did have the 14" for about a week. it was great, just needed more space in front of me for spreadsheets and what not.
 

cababah

macrumors 68000
Jun 11, 2009
1,891
504
SF Bay Area, CA
I got a 14" base and with the $500 saved from the step to the 16" I got a 32" 4k LG monitor to pair with it. I like the setup, best of both worlds (screen real estate while docked + portability).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 0228662

stoobysnax

macrumors member
Original poster
Jan 27, 2020
42
39
Just getting home from my first trip with the 16”. So glad I kept it. The lack of overheating (the 14 got warm faaaaast) the battery life, the no fan noise, and the screen, all hugely outweigh an extra little bit of weight/size. Amazing machine.
 

0228662

Cancelled
Apr 17, 2022
19
25
Just getting home from my first trip with the 16”. So glad I kept it. The lack of overheating (the 14 got warm faaaaast) the battery life, the no fan noise, and the screen, all hugely outweigh an extra little bit of weight/size. Amazing machine.
I am not even sure I've even heard my fans run! I have my MacBook Pro on my lap now, for about 2 hours, and the bottom case is still cold. Not doing much on the MacBook Pro but hanging out on MacRumors and watching a movie.
 

spiderman0616

Suspended
Aug 1, 2010
5,670
7,499
I am not even sure I've even heard my fans run! I have my MacBook Pro on my lap now, for about 2 hours, and the bottom case is still cold. Not doing much on the MacBook Pro but hanging out on MacRumors and watching a movie.
I've made the fans come on one time on the 14" model--but it was when I had it in clamshell mode connected to a 4K monitor playing Civ VI at completely maxed out settings. That doesn't sound very impressive, I know, but that game is a CPU/GPU hog, especially in the later turns when an entire globe has to process every time you hit the return key.
 

spiderman0616

Suspended
Aug 1, 2010
5,670
7,499
the 14 is smol, 16 feels so much immersive
During the workday I'm on the 16", and I typically use it with 3 or 4 Spaces open. Lately I've been having to do a lot of work in Office, and it is such a great machine to run those applications in split screen side by side or even just have one giant document open. Just makes everything so much more efficient.

My personal machine though--I'm coming from a MacBook Air, so the 14" definitely doesn't feel small to me. I like having a smaller model to carry around anyway.
 

doboy

macrumors 68040
Jul 6, 2007
3,777
2,958
Just getting home from my first trip with the 16”. So glad I kept it. The lack of overheating (the 14 got warm faaaaast) the battery life, the no fan noise, and the screen, all hugely outweigh an extra little bit of weight/size. Amazing machine.
Warm doesn't equal overheating. With your logic I guess iPhones overheats every time it's charged.
 

UltimateSyn

macrumors 601
Mar 3, 2008
4,970
9,207
Massachusetts
I'll go back to the 16" size when it trims down a bit. I find the size of the 14" to be absolutely perfect, and I can hook it up to an external monitor when I need the absolute largest screen possible. Speakers and battery life are indeed better on the 16", but it's diminishing returns at that point IMO. The screen is huuuuuuuge, and that's awesome, but so is the laptop (in comparison to the 14"). Just weighs too much, I think. 4lbs was the sweet spot.

Here's to hoping for a 15" goldilocks model ;)

I've never really had my 14" get warm, but I use it primarily for media consumption and web browsing.
 

planteater

Cancelled
Feb 11, 2020
892
1,681
Put me down in the 16 inch category. It’s the perfect size running at max resolution for the way I work.

I couldn’t see myself getting the 14 even if I transported it daily. I just couldn’t give up the screen real estate. I’ve hauled heavier machines to work in the past and never felt the size or weight was significant enough to go to a smaller machine.
 

Parisi

macrumors regular
Mar 10, 2004
105
50
I had the 14" initially, then I went to the 16" but didn't really like the screen, refresh rate seemed even slower than the 14". I returned/sold both couple of months ago and recently bought a 14" again.

I think 14" is a good compromise if you need something lighter to carry around and have the option of docking to a external monitor.

If you strictly rely on the larger screen state, and don't mind the added weight and size and are using the MacBook as a desktop replacement, the 16" is a solid choice. I just can't imagine bringing 16" everywhere in my backpack with me, it's quite a bit larger and heavier, with that said you do get used to it pretty quick the more you use it.

Also the 16" slower screen refresh rate was a deal breaker in my case.
 

spiderman0616

Suspended
Aug 1, 2010
5,670
7,499
I'll go back to the 16" size when it trims down a bit. I find the size of the 14" to be absolutely perfect, and I can hook it up to an external monitor when I need the absolute largest screen possible. Speakers and battery life are indeed better on the 16", but it's diminishing returns at that point IMO. The screen is huuuuuuuge, and that's awesome, but so is the laptop (in comparison to the 14"). Just weighs too much, I think. 4lbs was the sweet spot.

Here's to hoping for a 15" goldilocks model ;)

I've never really had my 14" get warm, but I use it primarily for media consumption and web browsing.
Couldn't agree more. This has been a bit of a reset for what Apple can do with thermals, so I'm sure these larger models will get thinner and lighter again over the years. Pretty exciting to think about what M chips are going to be able to do down the road from now. As long as they never ever ever try to resurrect those butterfly switches, I'm a happy camper.
 

flapflapflap

macrumors 6502a
Dec 13, 2013
768
439
Put me down in the 16 inch category. It’s the perfect size running at max resolution for the way I work.

I couldn’t see myself getting the 14 even if I transported it daily. I just couldn’t give up the screen real estate. I’ve hauled heavier machines to work in the past and never felt the size or weight was significant enough to go to a smaller machine.
Agree, but everyone is different. My niece who is 5’5”, probably weighs under 120 surprised me by getting the 16 over the 14. If you can handle the extra heft and footprint, 16 is the clear winner
 

VanVanWang

macrumors newbie
Apr 30, 2022
28
17
If you need 64GB RAM (means more power of CPU and GPU performance), go for MBP16,
else,
MBP14 is good enough.

If you only want a big screen, waiting for the rumored M2 MBA15:D
 

flapflapflap

macrumors 6502a
Dec 13, 2013
768
439
I had the 14" initially, then I went to the 16" but didn't really like the screen, refresh rate seemed even slower than the 14". I returned/sold both couple of months ago and recently bought a 14" again.

I think 14" is a good compromise if you need something lighter to carry around and have the option of docking to a external monitor.

If you strictly rely on the larger screen state, and don't mind the added weight and size and are using the MacBook as a desktop replacement, the 16" is a solid choice. I just can't imagine bringing 16" everywhere in my backpack with me, it's quite a bit larger and heavier, with that said you do get used to it pretty quick the more you use it.

Also the 16" slower screen refresh rate was a deal breaker in my case.
Valid points. As someone who also has the 13 M1 the move up to 14 was not warranted
 

james948

macrumors 6502a
Nov 17, 2004
517
149
I love my 14"
If i need a bigger screen I can use sidecar and my iPad or an external display. Nothing beats the small profile.
Also you can charge either of these very very quickly with the MagSafe. Hope that helps.
 

BigMcGuire

Cancelled
Jan 10, 2012
9,832
14,032
I always wonder if people commonly do that. The rivets on the watch bands must do a number on people's palm rests. This is one of those situations where I'm glad I took "Keyboarding" in high school. Our teacher was such a stickler about never resting your hands on the keyboard while typing that I just got in the habit early of not doing that. I've tried and it literally feels uncomfortable to me. ? My MacBooks always have pristine palm rests when I get rid of them!
I had to switch to sports loops because of this. While a lot of my typing is not done resting my wrists - I do rest my wrists when I'm not typing and that caused damage when using the band that came with the watch (that silver button on the bottom). Sports loops solved that for me completely.
 

BigMcGuire

Cancelled
Jan 10, 2012
9,832
14,032
I tried the 14' MBP earlier this year and having had 13' MBPs for years, I found it to be almost identical. What I did notice was that it did get warm to the touch with what I was using it for. I decided that I would instead go 16' MBP. The screen was just too amazing to pass up on and I noticed that for the same tasks, the 16' was cooler and ran the fans less for what I was doing.

For me personally I decided to sell my iPad Pro 11 and justify the higher cost of the 16' MBP because of the screen. A month down and I don't regret it. This thing is a keeper and I absolutely love it. Yes, the larger laptop is noticeably heavier and larger to carry around but it has much better thermals and the screen makes it worth every penny for me.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.