Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacBH928

macrumors G3
May 17, 2008
8,738
3,895
What would you recommend as a file manager for Finder replacement? I personaly LOVE Total Commander when I am managing file tasks in Windows but still have not tried anything to replace Finder on Mac.

 

Darth.Titan

macrumors 68030
Oct 31, 2007
2,906
753
Austin, TX
I was googling about multiple selection of files in Finder and this thread came high in the results.

First the facts that most of us Finder users already know:

My files are beeing shown as LIST in Finder (CMD+2)

CMD+mouse-click: Used to select multiple individual files that are not continuous.
SHIFT+mouse-click: Used to select ONE block of multiple files that are continuous like this: Click the first one and SHIFT+click the last one.

But what about the combination of these 2 methods? Why Finder does not let us use both methods together as it is done in Windows? You can CMD+click so many individual files you want, but you cannot select multiple blocks like in Windows, when you try this in Finder you lost your selection.

Look at this example:

Code:
File 1
File 2
File 3
File 4
File 5
File 6
File 7
File 8

I want to select Files 1,2,3 and files 6,7,8

In Windows:
I can click File 1, then SHIFT+CLICK File 3, then CTRL+CLICK File 6 and CTRL+SHIFT+CLICK File 8. Both selection blocks are preserved.

In OSX:
I can click File 1, then SHIFT+CLICK File 3, then CMD+CLICK File 6 BUT when you want to use SHIFT for the 2nd. time (CMD+SHIFT+CLICK) your hole previous selection gets screwed up.

How can we achieve this with Finder?

IMO this is pretty basic file managing and should be offered by Finder. The basics are already there. It is like the silly copy-paste drama that lasted years. I remember Apple and many fanboys defending the NO-IMPLEMENTATION of copy-paste in the form that it was implemented in Windows, and at the end Apple implemented it in Finder because IT MADE SENSE.
Works fine for me. Click file 1, then shift-click file 3.
Command-click file 6, then shift-click (no command key) file 8
Both selections are maintained.

 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.