I would like to update that I have since stopped using a case a few days after my last post in this thread. What I did instead is buy and install an ArmorSuit screen protector. It was a little fiddly to install, but now it's on the watch and looks great. Unless you know what you're looking for, it's almost invisible. I don't get into situations where my watch's case will get roughed up and was mainly worried about the screen.
Thanks to @staggerlee41, who mentioned ArmorSuit in a post and gave me the idea to check it out.
Thanks to @staggerlee41, who mentioned ArmorSuit in a post and gave me the idea to check it out.