Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Which has a better UI?

  • iOS

    Votes: 57 55.3%
  • Windows Phone

    Votes: 46 44.7%

  • Total voters
    103

dojoman

macrumors 68000
Apr 8, 2010
1,936
1,094
Yes it's boring because it's simple to use. Why fix something when it's not broken? Sure Apple could go Android route with animated background picture and all kinds of widgets and what not but that's not the way. Complicated home screen can get boring overtime too.
 

thatappleguytoday

macrumors 601
Feb 9, 2006
4,099
8,842
Jacksonville, FL
iOS can change without losing the wall of icons. Just look at whats being done with jailbroken iPhones. Notification center is being used to its full potential. The swipe left search page is being used to it's potential. There are ways to freshen up iOS without doing a complete overhaul.

I dont this the operating system needs to be changed much, but give it a little freedom.

For example, I STILL can't place icons anywhere on the homescreen, but they gotta stay in order. What if I want just a left side of icons only? Iconoclasm JB style I'm referring too.

iOS just needs a few tweaks...we all should appreciate it's security and ease of use.

Lets see what Ivey brings to the table for the next big iOS update
 

Dave.UK

macrumors 65816
Sep 24, 2012
1,290
482
Kent, UK
Yes it's boring because it's simple to use. Why fix something when it's not broken? Sure Apple could go Android route with animated background picture and all kinds of widgets and what not but that's not the way. Complicated home screen can get boring overtime too.

Complicated? Dropping widgets onto the home screen? No wonder ios didnt get copy and paste for some time!

Seriously, your implying that iphone users are stupid and need things left easy for them.
 

Dr McKay

macrumors 68040
Aug 11, 2010
3,529
258
Kirkland
There are simple things Apple could take from Android still, let the user change the default apps, let apps speak to each other. When I hit "share" I want to see every app that can do that, not just the built in ones.
 

Technarchy

macrumors 604
May 21, 2012
6,753
4,927
I like Windows Phone and iOS for very different reasons.

I choose to make iOS my mobile OS of choice because I think Windows Phone still needs work.
 

Renzatic

Suspended
The basics of iOS are fine as is. What I'd like to see though is a better multitasking scheme. Right now, it's so much smoother to switch between apps on Windows and Android devices. iOS? I can either hit the home button to go to the springboard then launch the app from there, drag three fingers up then select my app, double click the home button, or drag four fingers left and right.

It's slooooowwwww. Just jumping from Safari to the mail app feels like a small chore in comparison to the other OSes.
 

Rogifan

macrumors Penryn
Nov 14, 2011
24,735
32,200
Send an email to Jony Ive with your suggestions on how to improve iOS. :)
 

dalbir4444

macrumors 6502a
Oct 30, 2012
572
0
If windows phone is anything like Windows 8 on PC I'd stay clear of it.

iOS may be boring for some but I like it and its simplicity is great.

What's wrong with Windows 8. It's better than Windows 7 in ever way. The whole controversy revolves around the Metro Start menu, which IMO is actually better. And if you don't like it, just install Start8.

If you disagree, please post some actual concerns that you have with Windows 8.
 

cynics

macrumors G4
Jan 8, 2012
11,959
2,156
Yeah it's perfect. :rolleyes: I can't even move an app to a different spot on the screen that isn't next. Forget about using a different icon for the apps.

Oh wait that's way too confusing.
 
Last edited:

Rogifan

macrumors Penryn
Nov 14, 2011
24,735
32,200
The basics of iOS are fine as is. What I'd like to see though is a better multitasking scheme. Right now, it's so much smoother to switch between apps on Windows and Android devices. iOS? I can either hit the home button to go to the springboard then launch the app from there, drag three fingers up then select my app, double click the home button, or drag four fingers left and right.

It's slooooowwwww. Just jumping from Safari to the mail app feels like a small chore in comparison to the other OSes.

Double tapping on the home button to switch between apps is a chore?
 

dalbir4444

macrumors 6502a
Oct 30, 2012
572
0
When was the last time you were standing and clapping really hard while watching the introduction of the next iOS? Mine was iOS 4.

iOS is boring. Why is it boring? Because the UI looks the same. An average complainer would say demand a major UI redesign.

But why does it look the same? Because there is no way to change it. The only way I'd change iOS's home screen would be replacing it to look like Windows Phone. But Apple would never do that.

Think about it. If you we're to change the home screen, how will you do it? If you think of anything that isn't a grid of icons, it would be hard to use.

Apple's UI is already the perfect UI. And sadly, this might be the only UI we'll be seeing in a few hundred years.

Nothing is perfect. Does this really need to be said? Are you telling me that you can't think of anything to change in the UI that would make it better for you personally.

----------

No wonder why there are so many divorces.

You found the perfect woman.

Then 2 years later, you find her boring because she hasn't change much from being the woman you fell in love with.

I thought car comparisons were ridiculous but you just took it to another level.
 

sineplex

macrumors 6502
Aug 24, 2010
342
0
who cares about the UI it's just an app launcher anyway. :rolleyes:
i'm so bored of the buttons and icons oh no....

its equivilant wanting to change your tv because silver bezel is out of fashion.
it's unnecessary. the movies are the same and so are the apps.
 

dalbir4444

macrumors 6502a
Oct 30, 2012
572
0
who cares about the UI it's just an app launcher anyway. :rolleyes:
i'm so bored of the buttons and icons oh no....

its equivilant wanting to change your tv because silver bezel is out of fashion.
it's unnecessary. the movies are the same and so are the apps.

That's the thing. On iOS, the home screen is just an app launcher, but on Windows Phone and Android, it can be much more.
 

smallnshort247

macrumors 6502a
Oct 23, 2010
531
8
iOS feels a bit stale at times but I like how simple and quick it is for me to access the things I want. I also like the nice app selection to choose from.
 

cynics

macrumors G4
Jan 8, 2012
11,959
2,156
who cares about the UI it's just an app launcher anyway. :rolleyes:
i'm so bored of the buttons and icons oh no....

its equivilant wanting to change your tv because silver bezel is out of fashion.
it's unnecessary. the movies are the same and so are the apps.

That's why it's stale.

Don't you think this is dumb?

emysaryt.jpg


It's always 73 and sunny! Yay!
 

MonkeySee....

macrumors 68040
Sep 24, 2010
3,858
437
UK
What's wrong with Windows 8. It's better than Windows 7 in ever way. The whole controversy revolves around the Metro Start menu, which IMO is actually better. And if you don't like it, just install Start8.

If you disagree, please post some actual concerns that you have with Windows 8.

This isn't a windows 8 thread.
 

ReanimationN

macrumors 6502a
Sep 7, 2011
724
0
Australia
When was the last time you were standing and clapping really hard while watching the introduction of the next iOS? Mine was iOS 4.

iOS is boring. Why is it boring? Because the UI looks the same. An average complainer would demand a major UI redesign.

But why does it look the same? Because there is no way to change it. The only way I'd change iOS's home screen would be replacing it to look like Windows Phone. But Apple would never do that.

Think about it. If you we're to change the home screen, how will you do it? If you think of anything that isn't a grid of icons, it would be hard to use.

Apple's UI is already the perfect UI. And sadly, this might be the only UI we'll be seeing in a few hundred years.

The UI, perfect? What about still not having toggles for wifi, aeroplane mode etc. in the notification centre? The inventiveness of the jailbreak community, as others have said, show that there's plenty that can be done with iOS.

I agree with your point though, Apple have backed themselves into a corner with iOS. If they add the ability to change the appearance of an icon, based on the information within the app, they'll be accused of, and shouted down for, copying Windows Phone. If they add widgets, they'll be accused of copying Android. So where do they go from here? That's what will be interesting to find out. Apple have shown that they're not averse to copying, as seen with iOS 5's notification centre. Maybe, thanks to their patent sharing agreement with MS, we'll be seeing live icons on iOS in the future.
 

zhenya

macrumors 604
Jan 6, 2005
6,931
3,681
Considering how slow it is, yeah.

Well, chore might not be the best word for it. I'd say it's more of a drag.

What device?

On both my iPhone 4 and ipad 4 app switching is extremely quick unless the app has dropped out of ram - uncommon on the newer devices.

I agree that I'd like to see a bit more power brought to the OS though. Better multitasking like you say (ie some way to have two apps share a screen) and I agree that the icons need t be able to live update.
 

cynics

macrumors G4
Jan 8, 2012
11,959
2,156
What device?

On both my iPhone 4 and ipad 4 app switching is extremely quick unless the app has dropped out of ram - uncommon on the newer devices.

I agree that I'd like to see a bit more power brought to the OS though. Better multitasking like you say (ie some way to have two apps share a screen) and I agree that the icons need t be able to live update.

Probably means the task of double clicking a physical button vs a tap of a dedicated software button. While its not really time consuming by comparison it is...

Software wise its very quick, or at least it is on my 4S....

----------

The UI, perfect? What about still not having toggles for wifi, aeroplane mode etc. in the notification centre? The inventiveness of the jailbreak community, as others have said, show that there's plenty that can be done with iOS.

I agree with your point though, Apple have backed themselves into a corner with iOS. If they add the ability to change the appearance of an icon, based on the information within the app, they'll be accused of, and shouted down for, copying Windows Phone. If they add widgets, they'll be accused of copying Android. So where do they go from here? That's what will be interesting to find out. Apple have shown that they're not averse to copying, as seen with iOS 5's notification centre. Maybe, thanks to their patent sharing agreement with MS, we'll be seeing live icons on iOS in the future.

Let em copy. I don't care if it improves my user experience....

I'd be curious if Apple could come up with something even better. Just because you and I or anyone else can't think of a better way doesn't mean one doesn't exist. I'd love to be blown away with innovation on any device but especially my iPhone....
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.