Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
A few cases were discussed in this thread. I'm no longer sure which one works and which doesn't. I want the one in photos shown on post #7 and #13. Any one know of where to get one, if it works?

that's mine and it doesn't work. unless you modify it by placing a strip of thin conductive metal on the inside back to counter the magnet when it is folded over.
 
supersdchargers, That youtube video doesn't look anything like the ones in your picture. Notice hwo tight the video camera hole is in the pictures you posted. If you could PM me the actual link to where you found those pics that would be great. I couldn't easily find them on their what seems to be official site.

Update: Found the link.

I really like the look of that case. If they make a different color I will probably get one.
 
Last edited:
Well it certainly looks nice.
A couple of questions:

What's the material like, does it feel like the original Apple cover? That rubbery micro fibery kind of thing.

How is the fit, everything align up to the properly?

How long from the time you ordered it to the time you received it.

Was it shipped from Asia or the US?

How's the cover working? Does it turn on and off properly like a smart cover.

Does the cover stay closed when closed or does it flop open, I.e. does it have magnets that keep the front lid in the closed position?

When the cover is turned completely around, folded over, does it trigger the sleep wake function, which apparently happened on earlier versions of some cases. You'll have to test that, fold over the cover and sit it down on a table....

How would you rate the overall quality?

Appreciate your sharing your experience with us!


Come across this thread, haven't found any answer for this, what's next?
 
Come across this thread, haven't found any answer for this, what's next?

I requested the OP to respond but they never really answered the questions.

I gather it is an asian based company, therefore the shipping time will be long, returns could be problematic, personally, I have not been able to contact them and get a response to these questions, so after that I decided to not pursue this particular company.

Most of these knock offs have the hibernation problem, and even if you ask a vendor that sells something similar, they usually say it has the sleep.wake function and no matter how many different ways you ask about the cover activating the hibernation function when folded over, they respond that their case does not do this.

My experience has thus far every one of them does have the issue and I have since given up. Now I just place a small piece of conductive metal on the inside cover to prevent this from happening. Simple, straightforward and fixes the problem.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
I actually like the look of that case. You can tell from the felt that it is really nice. I just worry that it wouldn't magnetically attach to the front so I fear that the cover would flap back and forth while carrying it.

I've checked this cover, it looks like the smart cover, is it real leather?
 
I've checked this cover, it looks like the smart cover, is it real leather?
Going by the Melkco site it seems all their cases are hand made using leather. I am very interested to see if the Slimme case has magnets to keep the cover closed and if they don't then how well the cover stays closed on it's own. I am also interested in how flat it folds back flat against the ipad and how it feels and works when carrying it. For example does the cover flap about or move when in a briefcase or bag which might turning the ipad on/off wasting battery power.

I went ahead and ordered one through amazon (Vintage black leather) to answer my own questions but if anyone knows then speak up.

This probably should be moved to a thread just for that case though. This would probably be a good thread:
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1153091/

hwchouse, Can you give us an overview of your experience with it... even if you are associated with Melkco in some form or another. For some reason going by your comment I just have a feeling you are.

EDIT: It looks like hwchouse's post has been removed. I guess that means he/she was pushing his/her own product? Regardless it looks like a very nice quality case.

EDIT2: Yup... hwchouse has been banned.
 
Last edited:
Tucano Magico!

Tucano made a freaking awesome cover for IPad2...on their website in USA I got the light blue one...it's exactly the same Apple cover color...only for 30 bucks! They told me they did all Apple colors and it will all available by June...can't wait!!!! I GOT IT AT www.tucano.com
 

Attachments

  • ipdma-z_a.jpg
    ipdma-z_a.jpg
    60.6 KB · Views: 89
  • ipdma-z_b.jpg
    ipdma-z_b.jpg
    45 KB · Views: 79
  • ipdma-z_d.jpg
    ipdma-z_d.jpg
    115.3 KB · Views: 88
I've been using the Acase and I think it's a pretty good alternative minus the little kinks it has here and there.

klDw9U
 
Polyurethane. Same as the Smart Cover.

Does it has the sleep wake function? When the cover is turned completely around, folded over, does it trigger the sleep wake function, which apparently happened on earlier versions of some cases. Have you tested it? Sorry I really need one, so I need some detail from you, thanks.
 
Does it has the sleep wake function? When the cover is turned completely around, folded over, does it trigger the sleep wake function, which apparently happened on earlier versions of some cases. Have you tested it? Sorry I really need one, so I need some detail from you, thanks.

Yes it does and no, it will not trigger the sleep mode when it's flipped back.
 
I've been using the Acase and I think it's a pretty good alternative minus the little kinks it has here and there.

Image

Baloney!

The Acase is a lousy cheaply made case. I had one and sent it right back.

This case while advertised to be something similar to the original ipad case is in fact nothing like it!

The material is a cheap facsimile of the original and has so many blatantly obvious magnets littering the cases cover that they are visible all along the seam!

Case feels like nothing I have ever encountered and not that nice smooth feel of the polyurethane Apple case. This is rough and somewhat abrasive.

The worst part of the case I had is simple, it covered both the light sensor and half the HOME button once securely inside the case.

This is clear even in the picture the moron manufacturer put up on Amazon to sell the product, how stupid do they think Ipad owners are?

I mean really Acase, get the dimensions and cut outs right and remix your rubber batter boys, because this case is nothing but an epic failed attempt to do something that could be quite successful if done properly.
 
Baloney!

The Acase is a lousy cheaply made case. I had one and sent it right back.

This case while advertised to be something similar to the original ipad case is in fact nothing like it!

The material is a cheap facsimile of the original and has so many blatantly obvious magnets littering the cases cover that they are visible all along the seam!

Case feels like nothing I have ever encountered and not that nice smooth feel of the polyurethane Apple case. This is rough and somewhat abrasive.

The worst part of the case I had is simple, it covered both the light sensor and half the HOME button once securely inside the case.

This is clear even in the picture the moron manufacturer put up on Amazon to sell the product, how stupid do they think Ipad owners are?

I mean really Acase, get the dimensions and cut outs right and remix your rubber batter boys, because this case is nothing but an epic failed attempt to do something that could be quite successful if done properly.

I guess you haven't read my review :)
 
A compare of all the smart cover talked is this thread

No. 1, post by alphadog111, name: Ipad 2 Case with Smart Cover Tech - Looks and fits like Original Apple ipad 1 Case, where to find: not mentioned, image:
attachment.php
attachment.php


No. 2, post by sotie, name: ipad 2 smart cover yellow, where to find: http://www.case2case.net/ipad-2-smart-cover-yellow.html image:
file_170_13.jpg
file_171_13.jpg


No. 3, post by 3goldens, name: knock off ipad 2 smart cover, where to find: http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...#ht_500wt_1156
image:
attachment.php
attachment.php



No. 4, post by RocknRose, name: Tucano cover for IPad2, where to find: www.tucano.com
image:
attachment.php

attachment.php



No. 5, post by SchneiderMan, name: Acase, where to find: now mentioned, image:
klDw9U



Now, it is much more easy to compare them, just give your review, give us good advice for us to decide which to buy.
 
I guess you haven't read my review :)

Actually, I did read your puff piece on this sorry excuse for a case. It feels nothing like the original, mine had sleep/wake issues on the rear when folded over as well as seams that were just not held together properly, terrible construction, cheaply made very bad quality. A company that can not line up the covers ports, make that very straightforward part of the design coincide with the Ipads ports is not worth being in a discussion about quality.

This Acase is not a facsimile or even a close alternative to the former first gen Apple case, and I for one certainly would't be going around recommending it.

I'd even go as far as saying I wouldn't recommend any case made by Acase, I have had two that were complete bombshells! Two strikes in my game and their out!
 
I would have to agree Acase is of very poor quality. At Least from my experience with them. I also have a friend who bought one for his Xoom and it was crap
 
My two review samples were fine except for the cutouts. I think Acase just doesn't have consistent quality.
I might have received improved versions. I call it like it is.
 
Thanks, 3goldens, I decide to buy NO. 2 at last. First, it is cheaper, only $34.99, the case you recommend is $44.95, it seems a leather one, while I'd like to buy a case like apple ipad 2 smart cover, waiting for its arrival.



I don't think that gum drop case is leather though, it's probaly a little better quality poly than your getting, like original apple case.

Good luck with it, enjoy it!

Cheers....
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.