HobeSoundDarryl
macrumors G5
My first guess is something wrong with Google Fi data only this morning when you tested. I'm using T-Mobile for YEARS now with no such issues: 5G most of the time, 5GUW some of the time and occasionally in a place that falls back to LTE. I've had no trouble taking/making calls and I've had some instances where I've received spontaneous feedback about the quality of the sound- like it's better than typical.
Since you are in a simple testing mode, why don't you turn off cellular and test a call over your wifi? This will rule out/in Google Fi and/or perhaps the iPad itself. Wifi should absolutely work fine. I do it very often myself. That will let you hear the call quality and get your test contact on the other end to tell you how well you sound to them.
If that works fine, maybe retry the cellular option again tomorrow. Perhaps today just had some glitches? Or maybe Google Fi doesn't like Google Voice (though that seems unlikely for obvious reasons). I know the T-mobile network is just fine on latency for me but I also know that T-mobile network varies widely by geography (as can AT&T and Verizon too).
Earlier, was it you who claimed you regularly use about 50GB per month? Are you north of 15GB by now? Because I looked it up and see this...
Could any of that be in play and affecting your data and/or latency? If so, perhaps give it fresh test on Sep 1 when potential throttling "slowing down speeds significantly" are not in play.
As to the no-SIM 911 concern, do many people carry cellular devices around with no SIM? Again, that $25 option on iPad mini provides year-round continuous connection to cellular, so if I need E911, I'll be able to use it at any time. I have no particular need to not be connected though- admittedly- I do let the it expire and just use wifi for short stretches until I definitely need cellular again (sometimes that's a few weeks). If I was really worried about 911 availability, I wouldn't do that and thus always have E911 active.
I have to believe that just about anyone who subs this in for iPhone so that it is doubling as their phone would be very likely to maintain a continuous cell service connection and thus always have a SIM/E-SIM in play (and thus E911 always available).
There are a number of reasons this is not as good as iPhone. I shared a pretty good bulleted list back in post #7. So anyone who wants to talk themselves out of it, can easily do so for any of those reasons and likely some left out. However, for those motivated, there can be a good list of reasons to see telephony as just another app... like making an iDevice also be a flashlight, tape measure, iPod, guitar tuner, map, etc.
Again, Mac can stand in as a phone too for anyone who would always have their Mac with them and can carry some kind of cellular option for when they are outside of free wifi zones. I've done that too in the distant past. It works well too. The same device would make iPod Touch double as a phone as well. All any computing tech needs is a fairly good internet connection and a VOIP app.
Since you are in a simple testing mode, why don't you turn off cellular and test a call over your wifi? This will rule out/in Google Fi and/or perhaps the iPad itself. Wifi should absolutely work fine. I do it very often myself. That will let you hear the call quality and get your test contact on the other end to tell you how well you sound to them.
If that works fine, maybe retry the cellular option again tomorrow. Perhaps today just had some glitches? Or maybe Google Fi doesn't like Google Voice (though that seems unlikely for obvious reasons). I know the T-mobile network is just fine on latency for me but I also know that T-mobile network varies widely by geography (as can AT&T and Verizon too).
Earlier, was it you who claimed you regularly use about 50GB per month? Are you north of 15GB by now? Because I looked it up and see this...
Could any of that be in play and affecting your data and/or latency? If so, perhaps give it fresh test on Sep 1 when potential throttling "slowing down speeds significantly" are not in play.
As to the no-SIM 911 concern, do many people carry cellular devices around with no SIM? Again, that $25 option on iPad mini provides year-round continuous connection to cellular, so if I need E911, I'll be able to use it at any time. I have no particular need to not be connected though- admittedly- I do let the it expire and just use wifi for short stretches until I definitely need cellular again (sometimes that's a few weeks). If I was really worried about 911 availability, I wouldn't do that and thus always have E911 active.
I have to believe that just about anyone who subs this in for iPhone so that it is doubling as their phone would be very likely to maintain a continuous cell service connection and thus always have a SIM/E-SIM in play (and thus E911 always available).
There are a number of reasons this is not as good as iPhone. I shared a pretty good bulleted list back in post #7. So anyone who wants to talk themselves out of it, can easily do so for any of those reasons and likely some left out. However, for those motivated, there can be a good list of reasons to see telephony as just another app... like making an iDevice also be a flashlight, tape measure, iPod, guitar tuner, map, etc.
Again, Mac can stand in as a phone too for anyone who would always have their Mac with them and can carry some kind of cellular option for when they are outside of free wifi zones. I've done that too in the distant past. It works well too. The same device would make iPod Touch double as a phone as well. All any computing tech needs is a fairly good internet connection and a VOIP app.
Last edited:
