Received my Caudabe Sheath in celestial blue for my 17 Pro yesterday.
Order date was September 9th (Canada).
I sent a complaint on October 9th about the major delay and requested a free set of replacement buttons in shade "Sand" as compensation. They honored this request.
The contrast of the Sand buttons against the celestial blue case looks very nice.
I've used the Sheath since the iPhone X and am happy to say the quality/fit is on par to previous generations. As already reported, both the stock case buttons and replacement buttons rattle. The rattling is far beyond acceptable tolerances. I have already requested replacement buttons from Caudabe after they implement the fix.
I was using the Ringke Onyx as a placeholder while waiting. TBH, the Ringke is an amazing case. At 1/3 the cost, I would say the quality/feel/cut outs are on par. The only major con I had with that case was that the camera button wasn't covered which left a hole on the right side of the case that felt odd whenever my fingers brushed past it.
If they can truly fix the button issues, the Sheath is truly the perfect case. If you are still waiting for your order, hang on a little longer. The wait is worth it. Just make sure to check your buttons.