Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone looks?
- Thread starter whooleytoo
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I know everybody's using the excuse that with a full screen there aren't many options, but what I don't get is, what's up with the space on the front that isn't taken up by the screen? Why didn't they do something more interesting with that? Something to remind us it's still an iPod. The "home" button looks like it could have come from any non-Apple generic electronics product, it's really.. blah. A small faux-click wheel lookin' thing (a la Shuffle, or Apple Remote), or even just the Apple logo (a la iMac) would have been preferable.
Also, there seems to be too *much* empty space on the front. Maybe that was necessary for mechanical reasons, but I think it really detracts from the overall look. Hopefully the widescreen video iPod (an inevitability, I should think), which will not require a home button or motion sensor, will be able to dispense with that empty space.
I'm also not too crazy about the way the side is shaped. Everything else in their product line, including iPods, has been moving more and more towards clean, simple lines, but this is all weirdly curved like something from the G4 era. I would have preferred the "big candy bar" look of the 1G nano or 5G iPod, only with a full-coverage touch screen.
Also, there seems to be too *much* empty space on the front. Maybe that was necessary for mechanical reasons, but I think it really detracts from the overall look. Hopefully the widescreen video iPod (an inevitability, I should think), which will not require a home button or motion sensor, will be able to dispense with that empty space.
I'm also not too crazy about the way the side is shaped. Everything else in their product line, including iPods, has been moving more and more towards clean, simple lines, but this is all weirdly curved like something from the G4 era. I would have preferred the "big candy bar" look of the 1G nano or 5G iPod, only with a full-coverage touch screen.
I'm talking about the design/styling, rather than the number of buttons. The iPod Nano (for example) is just one solid colour/material in a clean design and as a result looks stunning, IMO. The iPhone on the other hand is glossy black, silver, matt black and chrome. Blech..
My problem has a current smartphone (don't know the model) with virtually an identical face, round cornered design with a large screen, black glossy face and a chrome bevel, and one button in the centre under the screen, you could easily mistake the two from a distance.
The iPhone's design isn't original or unique - that's strange enough for Apple. Furthermore, considering we won't see the iPhone for another 10 months here it's going to be a year-old design by the time it debuts here. In consumer electronics terms, that's a long time.
what could possibly be nicer about it? black & silver are the epitome of style? I wish macs would get that treatment. that grated brushed aluminum idea is terrible. That's grilled G5 tower is one of apples worst design decisions ever
i believe, the original G5's design has less to do with design, but more with functionality.
because the iPhones does not use a stylus, the icons had to be huge, so our fingers could "touch" it. if the icons were smaller, the spacing would be smaller and it would not be cool for a big guy to use the iPhone. the guy would be pressing 3 icons in your theory.
Well, the size of the screen limits the size and shape of the device to a degree.
Personally, I'd go for a design with slightly less rounded edges (more like the existing iPod designs), but that's just personal preference.
I certainly wouldn't use more than two different materials in the exterior case. Perhaps an attractive glossy (or chrome, or..) material for the front fact, with a complementary matt material & colour for the sides (where you grip the device - no finger smudges) and back. I wouldn't go for the contrast between the front (glossy black) and back (matt silver) of the current design.
I actually rather like the G5 tower's design. It's manly and mechanical looking, and yes, functional as well. My biggest gripe with it is that the case is just freakin' huge, and still only accomodates two hard drives internally (in the original design). I think the perforated aluminum texture was a real innovative material to use, and internally the layout is a work of (engineering) art.