Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone XS iPhone XS applies skin smoothing to the front facing camera, this cannot be disabled
- Thread starter silvertech
- Start date
-
- Tags
- camera camera bug photos
- Sort by reaction score
I saw this video as well. Pretty astonishing IMO.
I honeslty have no words right now. Just...unreal.
I absolutely cannot have my selfies looking like that. I know it's 2018, and I mean no offense to anyone, but I do NOT want my friends thinking I'm smoothening my skin in my selfies.
Seriously. This is not cool at all for me.
Why is his shirt so bright in the XS photos though? I’m a photographer and this just seems to be bad camera behavior or metering. It’s so much lighter, so it does seem to be extra Exposure or noise reduction.
This seems like a bug to report rather than a conspiracy.
I just received an XS Max today and the front camera doesn’t do this to my pictures.
This seems like a bug to report rather than a conspiracy.
I just received an XS Max today and the front camera doesn’t do this to my pictures.
I never use the front facing camera anyway. However most phones are doing it now so what can you do.
Yeah this is something Apple didn’t really need to do. The front facing camera on the X was already good. It’s honestly like all they added to the front facing camera was this filter and said it was better.
For some people this problem will be HUGE. Personally i don’t take a whole lot of selfies, but for people who do this could be an issue
For some people this problem will be HUGE. Personally i don’t take a whole lot of selfies, but for people who do this could be an issue
As far as I can tell, this is a new Noise reduction technique by the ISP.
I don't think it discriminates skin from other textures, it applies to everything.
I don't think it can be called a beauty mode, because it doesn't just apply to faces.
I don't think it discriminates skin from other textures, it applies to everything.
I don't think it can be called a beauty mode, because it doesn't just apply to faces.
Did you even watch the video? Its only the front facing camera. No where in the video does he mention that it affects the rear camera, because it doesn't.
We’re mostly guys here (women don’t talk about their phones like we do), but there are very favorable comments about the selfie-smoothing effect with different audiences. The smoothing is an effect that’s been used in conventional film photography via portrait lenses for a century, so use of the effect at least is not new. It would be nice to have a toggle though.
You can indeed add smoothness in an image editor, and you can also sharpen images or add noise or grain. I take it most users are probably using selfies as-is and not exporting to image editors as an intermediate step, so I can see the smoothing as a default since selfies are usually a large part faces. Most general audiences are going to like the effect.
https://www.cultofmac.com/579503/iphone-selfies-xs/
One thing is for certain, no matter what Apple does, they’re damned if they do and damned if they don’t lol.
Cheers, Azy
You can indeed add smoothness in an image editor, and you can also sharpen images or add noise or grain. I take it most users are probably using selfies as-is and not exporting to image editors as an intermediate step, so I can see the smoothing as a default since selfies are usually a large part faces. Most general audiences are going to like the effect.
https://www.cultofmac.com/579503/iphone-selfies-xs/
One thing is for certain, no matter what Apple does, they’re damned if they do and damned if they don’t lol.
Cheers, Azy
Lol, okay fine get a toggle. I on the other hand am going to send Tim Cook a thank you note and a bottle of champagne after comparing the selfie I just took with my 8 Plus to the one I took with my Max. Steve was right, we don’t know what we need until they give it to us. I can learn to appreciate the fantasy!
Someday when I’m dead and buried and the grandkids see these photos of me they won’t know it was some crazy algorithm and just think grandma was kind of cute at 52!I have a Pixel 2 whose selfie actually makes me look twenty years older and like I downed a lot of vodka over a bad weekend. I’d take it personally, but it does that to my gorgeous teenager, too.
My Samsung S9+ is so heavily altered I feel like I’m trying to see a picture of myself after downing the vodka that the Pixel 2 made me look like a drank.
It’s not an issue, it’s a feature.
Of course they know about it, they intended it to be there (vs say the X), it isn’t accidental.You can do a lot with even a simple free editor on your phone, like Lightroom.The question the designers obviously had is ‘what’s the best option for most people?’
But I agree, a toggle would be a nice simple fix.
Cheers, Azy
This is true, AFAIK there’s no public evidence - but if you’re an engineer (I am a retired engineer) an effect of this magnitude is not something that usually happens unknowingly. That said, there’s a new camera with larger pixels, so it could be X camera code on a Xs sensor, but since cameras are so important and tested extensively it seems less plausible that it is unintentional. The Xs series cameras really are completely new.
And of course if they ‘fix’ it, there will be an equal or greater number of people wanting it back.
Cheers, Azy
This comment actually made me laugh out loud at work. The thought of your friends analyzing extreme closeups of your face on social media is just hilarious.
An interesting conjecture. I guess we'll see how it plays out.
I don't have a need to share selfies with the rest of the Internet. It seems a little narcissistic but, that is the world we now live in. I rarely use the front camera as it is. Most of the time I am using it as a magnifier.
Im a photographer and into other creative arts. So are a lot of my friends. In fact, most creative people tend to buy Apple products despite huge advancements on the MS side of town on winning over creatives.
Your anecdotal based insults pretty much sucks.
Not sure that generalization really applies that much either.
I have permanent sun damage on my face. If I want to show someone how bad it is and need to ask someone about it, I don’t want my skin smoothed out. There are certain circumstances where this would be inconvenient. No need for anyone to judge.