I have both new models, a 15” MBP and a high end Windows 10 gaming/photo/video editing computer. I use them all for very different things and hate trying to accommodate the wrong tool for a task.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is anyone keeping both sizes (11-inch and 12.9 inch) of the iPad Pro 2018?
- Thread starter haruhiko
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I have both new models, a 15” MBP and a high end Windows 10 gaming/photo/video editing computer. I use them all for very different things and hate trying to accommodate the wrong tool for a task.
Having used both 11 and 12.9 for a while, I'm pretty tempted to keep both around, but definitely can't justify the cost of both. They feel a bit too close in size to me to keep both around.
For the prior 18 months I used a 2017 iPad Pro 12.9, and a mini 4. That felt like a nice combination. The 12.9 was almost always sitting on the keyboard in landscape. The 2018 12.9 feels significantly lighter to the point that I do carry it around and use it more as an "iPad" compared to the 2017. I'm kind of torn on which one to keep right now (12.9 or 11), but boy would I love an updated 8-9ish inch iPad to complement the 12.9.
For the prior 18 months I used a 2017 iPad Pro 12.9, and a mini 4. That felt like a nice combination. The 12.9 was almost always sitting on the keyboard in landscape. The 2018 12.9 feels significantly lighter to the point that I do carry it around and use it more as an "iPad" compared to the 2017. I'm kind of torn on which one to keep right now (12.9 or 11), but boy would I love an updated 8-9ish inch iPad to complement the 12.9.
I'm thinking about whether I should get both of the iPads, one for home use, one for bringing out..what do you think?
Yep, i keep them in my lambo
Man I hate to say that I’m in this situation as well.
Writing on the iPad Pro with the Pencil is definitely better on the 12.9. I write a lot of notes and there is so much more space for my hands to move around and using it on split screen is perfect. I’m a musician so it’s definitely better to read music sheets on the 12.9 as well. However as a tablet to be used when moving around or on the couch, it’s doable but it gets very unwieldy and uncomfortable after 10 minutes use or so.
Typing with a Smart Keyboard, from my experience of trying them out on the apple store, seems to be equal on both sizes. I prefer typing on the 11 though because of the compact feel to it. It’s almost like typing on a really portable mini laptop. Also I’d need to constantly reach up higher on the 12.9 to navigate the screen with my finger compared to the 11. This is very annoying with Word and Excel.
So I’m thinking the best compromise from both sizes to complete each other is:
12.9” + Apple Pencil: for writing on split screen and reading music sheets
11” + Smart Keyboard: for a more on-the-go typing up messages, emails, browsing the internet, occasional word processing
I know all the problems I listed are very first world problem situations and the solutions are very pricey but hey, as mentioned above, thinking is free 😄
Writing on the iPad Pro with the Pencil is definitely better on the 12.9. I write a lot of notes and there is so much more space for my hands to move around and using it on split screen is perfect. I’m a musician so it’s definitely better to read music sheets on the 12.9 as well. However as a tablet to be used when moving around or on the couch, it’s doable but it gets very unwieldy and uncomfortable after 10 minutes use or so.
Typing with a Smart Keyboard, from my experience of trying them out on the apple store, seems to be equal on both sizes. I prefer typing on the 11 though because of the compact feel to it. It’s almost like typing on a really portable mini laptop. Also I’d need to constantly reach up higher on the 12.9 to navigate the screen with my finger compared to the 11. This is very annoying with Word and Excel.
So I’m thinking the best compromise from both sizes to complete each other is:
12.9” + Apple Pencil: for writing on split screen and reading music sheets
11” + Smart Keyboard: for a more on-the-go typing up messages, emails, browsing the internet, occasional word processing
I know all the problems I listed are very first world problem situations and the solutions are very pricey but hey, as mentioned above, thinking is free 😄
I’m glad this thread got resurrected. With iPadOS I’m feeling like the once perfect 11” is cramped for multitasking. BUT it’s perfect for travel.
I don’t have a 12.9 IPP, but I’d guess it’s way better for multitaksing but a lot less convenient for travel.
Basically, until Apple invents a folding IPP the optimal solution is to get both, right?
I don’t have a 12.9 IPP, but I’d guess it’s way better for multitaksing but a lot less convenient for travel.
Basically, until Apple invents a folding IPP the optimal solution is to get both, right?
For me, I returned my 12.9” iPad for the 11” one because yes, that 1.9” made all the difference when handling it and walking around the classroom with it.
I sold my 12.9 and got a 2019 MacBook Air and kept my 11 inch iPad. Better combo for my needs work and at home
Kind of - I kept my 10.5 Pro when I got my 2018 12.9. I didn't want to sell it for a loss and I had already given an iPad to my daughter so I decided to hold onto it. It doesn't get much use as I like the 12.9 so much.
I said it’s still doable, but after a long period of time it does make a difference.
I finally capitulated with a 12.9 (after much heaving and hawing) as I needed more RAM. More importantly, mom needed an iPad to replace the 2018, so I just gave her the Air 3.
I am surprised how much I like the 3rd gen, iPP beyond the 2nd gen pencil (Not using Face ID). An 11" for travel/commutes would be great, but I will wait until the 4th gen. I'd prefer a Mini with the Pro design and specs, but I do not think Apple will go there.
I am surprised how much I like the 3rd gen, iPP beyond the 2nd gen pencil (Not using Face ID). An 11" for travel/commutes would be great, but I will wait until the 4th gen. I'd prefer a Mini with the Pro design and specs, but I do not think Apple will go there.
I use a 12.9, but yes, for casual iPad use, it does feel unwieldy compared to the 11. Nearly 1.5” wider and taller, and 40% heavier.