Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Sorry to resurrect but I did a google search and found this.

I really wanted Rivet for my mini but the damned dock icon would annoy the other half (her mini is a part time server, since she rarely uses it hehe) however I noticed one thing.

They say that Rivet has to have a dock icon for App Store rules, however, Alfred and Caffeine which were both downloaded from the store, run in the notification area and do not require dock icons.......

Bit of a white lie from TLAF perhaps?

Went with iSedora instead, and besides, Rivet aint even in the App Store yet either! So they've forced a permanent dock icon on everyone for no reason!

I was thinking the same - I replaced Evernote with the version from the App Store (so I get update notifications) and it works exactly like it did before with an icon in the notification bar and nothing in my dock
 
Whats wrong with that message? or am i missing something?

The freeware Sparkle application update engine is able to silently download an update, install it and then ask for restart of an app. Just a single-click experience. Using Mac App Store you need to:
1. fire up the App Store app (it doesn't check for updates automatically in the background),
2. click to "Updates" screen,
3. select your updates,
4. quit apps to update, if they're running,
5. update,
6. manually restart the apps updated.
Not quite the most comfortable way.
 
I'd bet the Mac App Store contract stipulates you can't do that.

Nonsense. There are no restrictions whatsoever that Apple would put on any software sold outside the Mac AppStore, even if there is a similar version on the AppStore. (Speaking from factual experience, with totally different versions of my software on the companie's website and the Mac AppStore).


The freeware Sparkle application update engine is able to silently download an update, install it and then ask for restart of an app. Just a single-click experience. Using Mac App Store you need to:
1. fire up the App Store app (it doesn't check for updates automatically in the background),
2. click to "Updates" screen,
3. select your updates,
4. quit apps to update, if they're running,
5. update,
6. manually restart the apps updated.
Not quite the most comfortable way.

On the other hand, the applications "Angry Bird", "Precipice of Darkness", "Fotomagico", "Clarus", "Blush", "Reflow" (just taking the first six on the MacAppStore home page) and all the others can be updated in exactly the same way. So one app that had auto update against 1000 apps updated automatically.
 
The freeware Sparkle application update engine is able to silently download an update, install it and then ask for restart of an app. Just a single-click experience. Using Mac App Store you need to:
1. fire up the App Store app (it doesn't check for updates automatically in the background),
2. click to "Updates" screen,
3. select your updates,
4. quit apps to update, if they're running,
5. update,
6. manually restart the apps updated.
Not quite the most comfortable way.

Ahh ok. I see your point on updates not being automatic. Thats a bit of a bummer. Coming from windows though i'm used to the rest of the crap so its a non issue for me :D But i can see why people have issues.
 
On the other hand, the applications "Angry Bird", "Precipice of Darkness", "Fotomagico", "Clarus", "Blush", "Reflow" (just taking the first six on the MacAppStore home page) and all the others can be updated in exactly the same way. So one app that had auto update against 1000 apps updated automatically.
http://osx.iusethis.com/top?sparkle=1&page=1
This is the list of apps using Sparkle framework for updating. 64k+ entries. This is 64 times as much as the 1000 you've mentioned :)
 
Seriuosly, if you expect control over your operating system, hardware, and software, why did you buy a Mac in the first place?

This is the most telling remark and my general concern over Apple and OSX. Their control over the OS. they're making it a more closed environment with every update it seems. Apple's track record is such that I would not be surprised to see apple only allow apps from the app store in a future release of OSX, all in the name of security.
 
dont worry so much about apple controlling the OS , its all for our safety as the governments around the world want to have control over the computers ,so they can easier control what you are doing, so far they rely on isp data to see what you send in emails, which websites you visit , but they need to know ,what kind of photos you store ,what documents you have on your computer , and the big two apple and microsoft just have to follow governments needs :rolleyes:
some have warned about it already 10 years ago , but nobody really did listen to these paranoid people ....now its to late, we only can watch how far this control goes

dont take it to serious
 
Last edited:
I think it best to remove the App Store icon from the dock. When you need to window shop the App Store (sorry, couldn't resist the pun) just go to the Apple icon :apple: on the upper right and you will find "App Store" under Software Updates. That's a good place for it. Of course Apple will first park in the dock to encourage impulse buying.
 
You're looking at it from the wrong angle. Apple was merely allowing you to not have a Dock icon before, and now they decided it was their right to put the requirement back in.

Seriuosly, if you expect control over your operating system, hardware, and software, why did you buy a Mac in the first place?

Model citizen right here guys!

DO WHAT YOU'RE TOLD!

DO NOT QUESTION!
 
Thats the beauty of the free market, somebody will eventually make a utility that removes/hides icons from the dock. Give it a few weeks.

One, two, three, watch out, I am starting to hold my breath right... NOW!

Tom B.
 
How come I was able to remove the Twitter Icon from my dock after downloading it from the Mac App Store? I just dragged it off the dock.

Exactly. All of my apps I have removed from the dock, and only some of them are forced to stay in the dock when running. Alfred and Caffeine can run as background tasks.

Some Devs and fans seem to be inventing truths it seems
 
I've downloaded a couple of apps. One i want to keep in the dock, so doesn't bother me, hut the other I just dragged into my Applications folder - so definitely not a limitation of the OSX App Store.

David
 
Considering the dock was never intended to be a place for all your applications, that response makes me suspicious.

Unless Apple are messing around with the HIG again? Who knows. Everything I want from the App Store I already have.
 
Eh, it's the same old story of people overreacting (and other people deliberately exaggerating).
 
Such a terrible situation. Horrible.
Have you considered you know...removing the icon from the dock?
 
At least you can delete the appstore icon from the dock. ;)

I have updated one of my home Macs to 10.6.6 and this was the first thing I did. Opened the the store once though, realized I need an account for free apps ( :rolleyes: ) and removed it never to be opened again.

If you don't like the appstore like I do, simply don't use it.

I did the same thing. If i want to download something i wouldnt use the Appstore anyway. They charge you for most of it.
 
I've never had a problem removing an icon out of the dock from the Mac App Store. Has something changed?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.