Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

klasma

macrumors 604
Jun 8, 2017
7,405
20,658
Because if you put a power button anywhere else, with a product this small and light, you won't be able to press it without having to hold it with your other hand first. It's 1.5lbs.
The solution is to put it on the top. But maybe Intel patented that?

1730471003238.png
 

Fishrrman

macrumors Penryn
Feb 20, 2009
29,175
13,225
dmr says:
"It's not 1997. When have any of us routinely used the power button to turn our computers on or off?"

It's still "1997" here.
I shut down my Mini every night, and flip off the power to the surge suppressor, too.

I'll even shut off the Mac if I'm going out for a couple of hours.

Same with my MacBook Pro 14".
It's downstairs now, shut off, and I won't power it on until I use it later this afternoon.

I've done things that way since my first computer back in '86 (Apple //c).
Old and grey now, and I'll be doing it until "the end".

Don't assume that everyone behaves and believes as you do.

I'm thinking that if I get a 2024 m4pro Mini, I'll set it "on its side", "server-rack-style".
May custom-make a "cradle" for it to sit in on the desk...
 

klasma

macrumors 604
Jun 8, 2017
7,405
20,658
You'd have to expose the bottom for better airflow so the power button would be in the correct position.
I would assume that the thermal design expects the top of the case to participate in heat dissipation, so I wouldn’t place it directly against an also-hot display with that side. The bottom side, on the other hand, effectively serves as a spacer.

1730473050059.png
 

imdog

macrumors 6502
Jun 20, 2017
353
789
Disneyland
I like what I've seen about the new mini so far and may be buying one, but I agree it's a bad design choice. I think they easily could've made it so that it was underneath but not right on the bottom so you could just reach the underside of it and do it without lifting it
 
  • Like
Reactions: GusBougadis

dmr727

macrumors G4
Dec 29, 2007
10,636
5,710
NYC
I like what I've seen about the new mini so far and may be buying one, but I agree it's a bad design choice. I think they easily could've made it so that it was underneath but not right on the bottom so you could just reach the underside of it and do it without lifting it

I don't think anyone thinks it's a good design decision, but some of us are reacting to the hysterics: "This is a disaster."
 

halo9

macrumors newbie
Mar 26, 2023
14
30
In breaking news Apple has issued an apology for the misleading promotional images of the new mac mini. Aparantly a staff member in marketing accidently flipped the images while using the new usb-c magic mouse. The story goes that the battery ran out so they plugged it in to charge, but not wanting to wait and miss the deadline, they were using the mouse tethered while charging when the mistake occured.

The correct image of the device is as follows with the power button on top for easy access and top vents to allow for better heat dissipation and cooling. This is achieved with minimal use of the fan by utilising convectional currents to lower power use. An Apple spokesperson stated;

"We are very sorry for this mixup and confusion. Apple is commited to lowering power use even when devices are in use.... our aim is to please the power concious users and affirm our green stance... Now you can easily press the power button when walking away from the desk, even for 5 minutes, to enjoy maximum power savings... and you can enjoy up to 2.7x less power use over the M2 Mac Mini's cooling solution, even under heavy loads"

macmini.jpg


* for those that trigger easily, this is a parody ;p
 
Last edited:

nylonsteel

macrumors 68000
Nov 5, 2010
1,579
507
power button on bottom - a bad design for sure
aapl - how could you have approved this design?
i guess another reason not to upgrade from my old core i7 mini
while i'm on the subject - the power button on the mini should be in front - be it old or new style case
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Jumpthesnark

polaris20

macrumors 68030
Jul 13, 2008
2,511
790
I'd initially not been too bothered by the power button being on the bottom, seeing it as no different to placing the power button on the back of the device in reality. Except rather than reaching to the back you'd reach to the bottom left of the device and press the inset button. The circular base would of course have enough height so you could place your finger under the corner. No problem.

That's now all changed as The Verge has just confirmed you have to actually lift up the device to press the button. Yes, lift up your desktop computer to turn it on. From the hands on article "He also says there’s no way to reach the power button, which is on the underside of the computer, without lifting it up."

https://www.theverge.com/2024/10/30/24283861/apple-redesigned-mac-mini-macbook-pro-imac-m4-photos

This is a disaster.
OMG, it's so heavy too!! What will we do?!
 

Night Spring

macrumors G5
Jul 17, 2008
14,858
8,038
With their “courage”, capacitive tech like new iPhone 16 shutter button, they could have easily built the button into the Apple logo.

I also think it would be nicer to have the apple logo as a button. Then I would always be reachable and not accidentally pressed as I assume most people don’t stack stuff on top of a Mac mini?

If the logo was the power button, wouldn't my cats turn the Mac mini on/off when they walk on it?

Do we have a power button on the AppleTV? No? Why not? Probably because it's not really deemed a necessary thing given that it would rarely if ever need to be turned off. Perhaps they see the Mac mini in this way too.
No power button might actually work, as long as there's some way to shut it down when the system freezes. I think with the Apple TV, you have to pull the power cord. That's not really ideal.
 

GusBougadis

macrumors member
Sep 25, 2024
42
40
I suggest making a Mac Mini M4 on apple wheels for an extra 999 dolars. This version is good for those who can't lift the computer. Just roll it around the table. Save not only energy but also strength. The height will allow you to safely press the power button
I suggest making a Mac Mini M4 on apple wheels for an extra 999 dolars. This version is good for those who can't lift the computer. Just roll it around the table. Save not only energy but also strength. The height will allow you to safely press the power button.
🤣🤣
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.