Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Originally posted by johnnowak
I'm with phil. 99% of p2p usage currently involves porn or piracy. There's no reason for it.

You could say the same about computers in general.

I guess when I D/L old TV shows that aren't on anymore (Invader Zim, 60's Spider-Man, Clone High, etc.), acoustic/live stuff, old dead people (Mahalia Jackson for one), and the like I'm suddenly a thief and a pirate. Ok. I'd love to buy that stuff, but, well... I can't. They don't sell it, don't show it on TV.

Maybe if I looked real hard I could find some of that stuff. I know Zim is on TV sometimes, but I've never seen some of the eps shown and they haven't put it out on DVD or anything. Some bands put out heavily-edited live stuff. I'd go to a concert, but instead of playing the songs I want to hear, the "artists" decide to play stuff off their new album.

And there is a new Mahalia CD out, but it doesn't have the song I want.

Oh yeah, and porn. Lots of porn. But mostly softcore stuff.
 
Originally posted by solvs
You could say the same about computers in general.
you could, but it wouldn't be true, and even if it were, it would be piracy over the concerted effort to prevent it rather than an app that roundly facilitates mass piracy.
 
Originally posted by johnnowak
I'm with phil. 99% of p2p usage currently involves porn or piracy. There's no reason for it.

Well, BitTorrent at least is used legitimately a lot, and I think it's been shown in this thread that there are legitimate uses. Also, if the porn isn't pirated, why not share it? :)
 
Originally posted by BWhaler
No, not if you have the author's permission.

It could be cheating if you represent the work as your own.

What are you stoned?

try handing in an essay, or any other assignment, better yet, copy someone's test and when you get accused of cheating, tell them that you had his or her permission to use it.

Then... time yourself to see which one of you can back your bags faster when you get kicked of college
 
Originally posted by Phil Of Mac
Only if you label them "hot asian girl gets reamed sex porn ***** bbw xxx xxx porn porn sex anal oral"



And people will know to search for it?



That's plagiarism.

1 - Most P2P apps have a browse feature.
2 - See number 1.
3 - No, it's cheating on homework. It's not illegal if he authorizes others to copy his work.

P2P is not the devil. Leave it alone.

Dan
 
Originally posted by alset
P2P is not the devil. Leave it alone.

P2P is indeed not the devil. However, not reading an entire thread before you reply is. If you had read one more post down, you would have seen that I had admitted there was a legitimate use for P2P. But, of course, then you don't get the emotional satisfaction out of pestering me, do you? Now I asked a question and it was answered and I'm happy. Don't mess with my happy equilibrium.
 
Originally posted by Phil Of Mac
P2P is indeed not the devil. However, not reading an entire thread before you reply is. If you had read one more post down, you would have seen that I had admitted there was a legitimate use for P2P. But, of course, then you don't get the emotional satisfaction out of pestering me, do you? Now I asked a question and it was answered and I'm happy. Don't mess with my happy equilibrium.

let it go Phil, let it go
 
Originally posted by revenuee
let it go Phil, let it go

Thanks.

Phil, I'm not out to target you... I've just noticed twice in as many days that you attacked the morality of others. Forgive me if I jumped the gun on my post.

Dan
 
Originally posted by alset
Thanks.

Phil, I'm not out to target you... I've just noticed twice in as many days that you attacked the morality of others. Forgive me if I jumped the gun on my post.

Dan

I've only attacked the immorality of others. And in this thread, I only questioned the value of P2P. I didn't attack anything, I only questioned it. Questioning is good, despite the fact that Socrates was put to death for it.
 
Direct Connect is great for bootlegs. Downloaded more then half my Audioslave shns from there.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.