Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Lion should really be on a disc

NoSmokingBandit

NoSmokingBandit

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Apr 13, 2008
1,579
3
Lion should really be on a disc, and this is why i think so:

Lets say something goes horribly wrong and i have to reinstall my OS. It happens to the best of us. Instead of popping in my Lion disc and installing like normal i'll have to...

1) Install Snow Leopard
2) update to the newest 1.6.X if my disc version is before the App Store was introduced.
3) Download Lion (~an hour depending on one's connection)
4) Install Lion
5) Update Lion

This could take a large part of your afternoon.

If there were a disc i'd simply:

1) Install Lion
2) Update Lion

and be done in an hour or so.

I suppose for people who have full Time-Machine backups they could just restore and keep going, but i find that backing up everything wastes space so i just back up personal files and media.

Anyway, thats just my thoughts on it, flame away.
 
I agree. Lion should be available on a disc. I assume it will and that app store only thing is a trial to see who is willing to go that way. I just reloaded OS X on a machine last week after upgrading the HDD and I would hate to have to through 3 "hoops" as you describe, though I should also mention that there are rumors that if you have use a Time Capsule as your router, updates are cached so the download time is drastically reduced.

Here's another scenario...

Do I shell out $29 per itunes account in my house or simply buy the family pack dvd and update them all?
 
Well, there is a Recovery partition, which should be fine in most cases. The only issue is if you replace your hard drive.

Maybe it's possible to clone the Recovery partition onto a DVD. Seems like that would work.
 
the fact that lion is only going to be available trough the app store is just ridiculous and mega ignorant!

just to give a fact...i have some close friends in south America and know for a fact that for example they can't even get there hands on a credit card or visa card...due to policies for people with low income, how are the less fortunate going to get there hands on a copy of the new OS when they don't even are allowed access to the app store?

once again this proofs Apple is probably the most ignorant company around.
 
harlem said:
the fact that lion is only going to be available trough the app store is just ridiculous and mega ignorant!

just to give a fact...i have some close friends in south America and know for a fact that for example they can't even get there hands on a credit card or visa card...due to policies for people with low income, how are the less fortunate going to get there hands on a copy of the new OS when they don't even are allowed access to the app store?

once again this proofs Apple is probably the most ignorant company around.
Click to expand...

How did they get a Mac in the first place?
 
Another possibility is that Apple (or a 3rd party) provides a utility to burn your own recovery DVD.
 
While I totally agree that Lion's availability being limited to the AppStore has some pretty strong negative implications we don't know the whole story yet. All Apple has to do is allow the downloading of the Lion .dmg from the AppStore so we can burn our own DVDs if we want and all of our concerns go away in one sweep.
 
It sounds bad right now but I think we all need to wait for the full story before passing judgment. There may be an easy way to make some sort of recovery disk or something of that nature.
 
astroot said:
How did they get a Mac in the first place?
Click to expand...

i was expecting these kind of intelligent reply's :rolleyes:

they buy them just like you do...Its not that those people are dead broke they do have money its just that in certain country's (same goes for allot of north african country's by the way) you need to have a certain amount of income or certain amount of savings money to get a credit card or visa.
 
harlem said:
i was expecting these kind of intelligent reply's :rolleyes:

they buy them just like you do...Its not that those people are dead broke they do have money its just that in certain country's (same goes for allot of north african country's by the way) you need to have a certain amount of income or certain amount of savings money to get a credit card or visa.
Click to expand...
Can't they use iTunes vouchers if they don't have a CC?
 
dukebound85 said:
could be gifts, craigslist or a variety of other ways

What about people under 18 who cant have credit but do have jobs?
Click to expand...

When I was young and needed a credit card for some purchase, I had my parents purchase it and I paid them back. Easy solution.
 
dukebound85 said:
What about people under 18 who cant have credit but do have jobs?
Click to expand...

You don't need a credit card. I'm 17 and I have my Visa Electron in iTunes. I got it when I was like 13.

yetanotherdave said:
Even worse, if you have a snow leopard upgrade disc, you have to install leopard, upgrade to snow leopard. update snow leopard, d/l lion, update.
Click to expand...

There is only one SL disc. The "upgrade" version can be used to perform a clean install.
 
i think this is just plain annoying, i am getting a vertex3 SSD next month and was waiting for lion to come out and do a fresh install.

i don't like doing upgrades at all and prefer clean OS installs anyway, but now i have to install snow leopard 10.6.x and then upgrade to 10.6.8 with the @#%$#$% app store integrated which i cannot disable even if wanted to and after that upgrade to lion.

that will take the better part of a day, leave unwanted traces of the old OS versions, fragmentation and i don't even know how my SSD will like that process, my OSX 10.6 disc doesn't even support TRIM so i am hoping at least that will fix itself during the install.

i just hope that there will be bootable downloads available after the release like the dev previews are now. I am more then willing to pay EUR 23 for lion but i *really* don't want the hassle of doing multiple upgrades.

any thoughts if this will be fixed?

stefan
 
NoSmokingBandit said:
Instead of popping in my Lion disc and installing like normal i'll have to...

1) Install Snow Leopard
2) update to the newest 1.6.X if my disc version is before the App Store was introduced.
3) Download Lion (~an hour depending on one's connection)
4) Install Lion
5) Update Lion
Click to expand...

not to disagree with your point, but it's likely the downloaded version of lion will be the most up to date, eliminating the need to install then update.
 
It should be on a disc because not everyone can download 4GB in less than 5 hours... I can, but can average Joe on a T-1ish line can? Or for that matter people on Satellite connections or slow DSL setups?

Not to mention people who are still on dial-up... although if you are on dial-up its time to upgrade (seriously)
 
I am confident that Apple will have a utility to create a USB or DVD copy from the downloaded version.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back