Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Frankly, they can charge $149 for it for all I care. It comes with iTunes and iPhoto, and Windoze comes with BSOD.

When I said "some of us were hoping to have a passing resemblance to Mac OS 9", I meant in terms of the care and attention given to user-interface considerations. A lot of Aqua's user-interface details seem completely arbitrary and weird. Sure, some are clever and good, like the zoom button.

But for Mac OS X to be "unlike anything else out there" is not necessarily a good thing.

When we argue about pinstripes-vs.-brushed metal, this argument has an underlying badness to it: Why are those the choices? Why does that creaky clone of System 7, Windows, have more user-configurability than Mac OS X? What do you mean, I can't select a different system font? I can't select anything other than "blue or gray" button highlights?

Anyone remember Workplace Shell under OS/2? To change the font of something - anything - you opened a font palette, dragged the font you wanted and dropped it on that thing. You could also drag and drop colors.

Macintosh used to be a paragon of human-factors design. Now it looks like a hodgepodge of trendy widgets. Brushed metal, feh! As if that made any difference at all. :(
 
good idea rower, im stopping this argument. gopher here keeps talking about hard evidence and stuff like we are on law and order or something. you think what you wanna think and ill think what i wanna think. 129 isnt a big deal, we will end up paying it or not.

iJon
 
cubist:

I understand now. Mac OS X looks as though it was designed by a committee, which it was. If Xerox PARC was still there, maybe they would have had more inspiration from which to draw. ;)

The brushed metal thing is so wrong. The close|minimise|maximise boxes in colour don't make sense to those who have no automotive frame of reference.

Workplace shell was good, though not perfect, but I think it represented where Apple should/would have gone had Steve Jobs stayed.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.