I see your point. But a couple of things... 1st, you can see that as "a problem" or as an upgrade slash feature addition just based on how you decide to look at things. For mouse and KB users it's hot roll-over corners. Faster information consumption, faster system state overview, less clicks, less effort, etc. And 2nd I think this is a good indication of the kinds of transitions which will be forced on us over the remainder of the decade. Not dissimilar to Apple's own Magic TrackPad and all the buzz about surface computing from the likes of MS and Corning Glass, I think it serves as an excellent indication of the kind of future we will be led into. The only question is if we will go willingly, kicking and screaming, or dismantle and destroy the whole thing. I personally vote for the later as resistance is futile and all our bases belonged to them!
BTW, I wonder if you're old enough to recall that the exact same arguments you bring up here were also made when we were led into a windows environment from the blinking DOS prompt?
Resolutions:
http://www.oostdam.info/index.php/sectie-blog/296-windows-8-disable-metro-gui
http://gizmodo.com/5972918/six-hidden-windows-8-features-you-cant-live-without
Additional Musings:
http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/lion_without_the_finder
http://mac.appstorm.net/roundups/utilities-roundups/5-alternatives-to-the-os-x-finder/
http://superuser.com/questions/89619/how-to-disable-finder-launching-at-login-in-snow-leopard
http://arstechnica.com/business/201...built-for-the-cloud-built-for-virtualization/
http://www.infoq.com/news/2011/10/GUI-Less-Windows
Less clicks? I don't know…
Sure I might be the way things are heading right now but it doesn't mean it will be something that sticks. But we'll see. I doubt Apple will go down the ”2 in one” path for OS X, though. Launchpad might be an indication of the opposite, but personally I don't see any point in using it so it's a good thing it's an option, whereas the ”touch-GUI parts” of Windows 8 feels more forced upon you.
But we'll see how things evolve.
I understand people can be skeptical to change and be wrong (switch from DOS prompt to Windows), but you must agree change in itself isn't necessarily a good thing. Just because this way of mixing two GUIs is a new approach it doesn't need to be a positive change. But like I said, we'll see…
As it is now I like working in OS X even more since I did the upgrade to Windows 8 (among other things missing the drop shadows for the Windows, where did that go?).
Yup, I agree with that.