Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Whiteapple

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jan 17, 2006
213
0
Haute Savoie,France
Spanky Deluxe said:
If you can afford it I'd go for the Mac Pro. I've had a Core Duo Mini for a while now and it seemed just a little bit slow at times. IPhoto isn't as much hampered by the CPU speed as it is the hard drive imo. The 5400rpm drive in there is considerably slower than a desktop variant. Even if you put in a 7200rpm drive you still will not be at the same level of speed as a 7200rpm desktop drive. Sure you could put in a 7200rpm drive, attatch a firewire external hard disk, max out the ram at 2GB and upgrade the CPU with a Merom part at some point and you'll have a good machine. Don't expect any gaming miracles though and once you've done those upgrades there's nowhere to go from there. Besides which, the cost of those upgrades probably = the amount needed to go Mac Pro.

As far as FrontRow goes, well its not too hard to 'find' a copy of it, especially if you have a FrontRow enabled machine lying around and then you can get bluetooth remotes specifically for FrontRow. The remote won't look as pretty as the Apple one but it''ll work through walls!

Yes, you're right, and I was thinking that for durable investment, the mini isn't quite the right thing, isn't it? Neither is an iMac...
I'll just persuade my mom to go for a MacPro, and if she says "no", then I'll wait and get the base line mini (C2D or not...) when they are updated. I think I'll forget about the self-upgrading part, where I'm not too confident on thermal paste & stuff...

Keep giving your impressions please. So far, I come to the conclusion that the Core Solo is insufficient, and the Core Duo is OK, but perfectible.
On the other hand, the MacPro isn't a great investment, and quite toxic, as for gaming habits...I mean, even a 7300 GT is better than my FX5700 Ultra, which is way enough to have a flat life, nerd-like entertainment, without enjoying the daylight, for example...
;)
 

scud

macrumors newbie
Aug 31, 2006
9
0
Tell your Mom that a Mac Pro is simply a better long-term investment.
 

Origin

macrumors regular
Aug 11, 2006
115
0
Nantes, France
Whiteapple said:
Oh, well that's nice to hear ! Do you think you can sleep while leaving the computer on? I can do this with my noisy PC, but it's very painful.
How about these SATA problems, are they sufficient to prevent me from gaming under XP?

I think you can sleep near it without problems ;) . I was away for 48 hours last Friday and my wife thought that the MacPro was powered off !

There is a workaround to the SATA pb, so you can get fullspeed. The MacPro is a dream in 1440x900 under BF2, CSS, FarCry, TrackMania Nations and Flat Out, the games I already tested, with the stock 7300GT !!! I can't wait for my X1900 XT ....
 

Whiteapple

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jan 17, 2006
213
0
Haute Savoie,France
Origin said:
I think you can sleep near it without problems ;) . I was away for 48 hours last Friday and my wife thought that the MacPro was powered off !

There is a workaround to the SATA pb, so you can get fullspeed. The MacPro is a dream in 1440x900 under BF2, CSS, FarCry, TrackMania Nations and Flat Out, the games I already tested, with the stock 7300GT !!! I can't wait for my X1900 XT ....

Yes, thank you very much, but the whole point is I want to STOP gaming:p

Either way, the MacPro seems to be the way to go, instead of upgrading a mini like hell, without even being sure it will boot...

And I'm sure I'll keep it for 5 years, time during which I will surely learn stuff I'll need its power to exploit.;)
 

generik

macrumors 601
Aug 5, 2005
4,116
1
Minitrue
Whiteapple said:
Yes, thank you very much, but the whole point is I want to STOP gaming:p

Either way, the MacPro seems to be the way to go, instead of upgrading a mini like hell, without even being sure it will boot...

And I'm sure I'll keep it for 5 years, time during which I will surely learn stuff I'll need its power to exploit.;)

If you are looking to keep a computer for 5 years I'd wait for the quad core chips coming early '07.
 

Whiteapple

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jan 17, 2006
213
0
Haute Savoie,France
generik said:
If you are looking to keep a computer for 5 years I'd wait for the quad core chips coming early '07.

Hmm...Weren't you this one poster telling to some student in IT that he did NOT need a laptop computer? And now you suggest that I should wait for Octo Cores? Funny:p

No, 2.66 x 4 Ghz power is enough, and it's way overkill at the moment, sufficient for 5 years.;)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.