1. You are well advised to also use an anti-virus software on OS X, especially if you exchange documents with the rest of the world.
Meh. As others have already refuted. I've used Macs for seemingly 15-20 years and never seen a virus.
2. AppleCare comes nowhere near the service you get from Dell, for example. You call Dell and they come to your house or office to fix (or replace) your machine. Within 24 hours - guaranteed. With AppleCare... Wait for an appointment to bring your computer somewhere. And wait. Good luck.
I guess we all have different experiences. I've talked to Dell and it seems like it is always someone in India. Apple on the other hand is always clear english. Further when I need a new part or repair they send out immediately and e-mail me a pre-paid shipping label to return the defective part if needed.
3. ...Like a PC, a Mac is just a computer - a tool to get a job done.
Well, like a Pugo a Ferrari is just a car.
Macs and PCs are both tools but they are hardly identical. Hardware-wise, sure you can spec them pretty close but the OS is the big difference. I swear it takes 4-5 menus or dialogs to change a user password on a PC. That's ridiculous and the control panels are a mess. Little in the OS is coherent unless you already know what it is and what it does, etc. However, if you really want/need to run Windows and PC software, you can run them natively in a window in the Mac OS. You can't really run Mac OS and applications in the Windows OS...and no "professional" is going to work with a hacked system and applications.
Basically, your husband's right. You will get "more bang for the buck" when you buy a PC.
There is little to no difference in price when you really spec it out, and when you say "bang for the buck" how do you value the fact I've dropped my 12" PowerBook on its corner on concrete, fallen on it and bent the screen in, etc. and always have it wake from sleep and operate perfectly with minor cosmetic damage (i.e. a dented casing on the corner). Try that with these plastic PC laptops. Good luck. The Mac OS also has more "bang for the buck" for me because the interface is far more efficient which makes my work easier and take less time...which is money.
Windows performs much faster than OS X on the --SAME-- machine
My 12" PowerBook running a single core 1.33ghz PowerPC processor and 1.25 gigs of starts up from cold boot to log-in screen in about 30 seconds and another 10-15 seconds to desktop ready to use. On dual core Core2Duo Sony, Toshiba, Compaq and HP laptops I tried with processors 1.8ghz+ and 2+ gigs of RAM Vista was consistently around 2 minutes from cold boot to desktop ready to use.
I don't know if you plan on using software like Lightroom or Aperture. Aperture is only available for OS X, so if you choose to use it, the platform discussion is already over before it's even begun. Lightroom exists for both platforms.
Personally, I do not like Lightroom's user interface and philosophy; Aperture is more compatible with me and the way that I think and work. For me, Aperture is --the-- killer application for the Mac. I also do more stuff in Aperture than in PhotoShop Extended.
If you use a Mac you can pretty much run any piece of software in the world via BootCamp, Parallels, VMware, etc.. You can't say that for a PC.
In my experience, owning a Mac is MUCH more costly than owning a PC.
Again my experience differs. In my 15-20 years of using a Mac I can count the hardware failures on one hand and still have fingers left over. Not so on the PC. In fact, in the cases where we purchased PCs for half the price of a Mac, the dollar value of hardware failures and the wage time lost being unable to use them for work exceeded what it would have cost to just buy the Mac in the first place.
To make your Mac usable, you will have to buy a good deal of small Shareware tools - for most of which you would get Freeware alternatives in the Windows world.
I have never needed to buy any shareware to make my Mac usable. I have no shareware whatsoever. In fact, Macs can do more "out of the box' than PCs virtually all the time. Example: Does Vista yet allow you to save as PDF from any application? Apple has had this functionality for years which for a long time was only available after paying Adobe $200 for the requisite version of Acrobat.
Also if you use Expose you know how supremely efficient this is for your workflow. This alone makes the Mac an order of magnitude more efficient than the PC for multitasking or other "real world" workflows. I think you'd have to find shareware or other add-on to do the same on the PC...if it is even available.
Furthermore, Apple upgrades their software very frequently and drops support for older versions way too fast, thus indirectly forcing their customers to upgrade. The Windows market is much slower and software simply "lasts longer" in the PC world.
Many Vista users would disagree.
On the other hand I can run Apple's latest OS on my 4-5 year old laptop without issue. I keep 1 version back though because I still use Classic on that computer to run nearly 10 year old applications.
From a strictly economic point of view, choosing the Apple platform doesn't make much sense
I suppose that is in the eye of the beholder. See above.
All the best,
Jesse Widener
Art and Structure design studio