Hi guys, i was planning to get a MacBook Pro but at the store where they sell it they sell me the Pro they sell me the air for the same price, i feel that the Air is better value because it's thinner and it has almost the same features.
I want to use the computer around the house, take it to work, starbucks, a daily usage computer, like something between my desktop and iPhone, and that's NOT an iPad in my case, i would use it to download music and sync my iPhone on iTunes, apereture, even light video editing probably just twice a year or so, one part i care about is Second Life (3D Virtual World)... is the performance the same even with a lower clock processor? since 3D apps use more GPU than CPU.
Would 4 tabs in safari + iTunes music + secondlife + 1 Work app go fine all together? should i get the pro?
The Pro weigh's just 1.5 lbs more than the Air; maybe even less difference if your using the SSD on the Pro.
I have a 2.53GHz 13" MBP and a 1.6GHz "Revision B" MacBook Air. The difference between the two machines is like night and day.
I have given up trying to run fairly intensive graphics apps (InDesign, PhotoShop) on the MBA. The iWork suite is fine, but anything more sophisticated bogs down the processor.
I love traveling with the Air, but I find myself growing increasingly frustrated because the machine is just downright sluggish. If I had to choose between the MBA and the MBP - that is, if I could only have one - I'd pick the Pro hands down.
The 1.86/2.13 GHz Penryn CPU is plenty of power for Photoshop and Adobe CS
then you basically say a 300 dollar cell phone is a ripoff because you can get 25" monitor with that money, sometime you just want somethig light to do basic stuff, of course they force you to pay a premium for that, I just want one because it costs me as much as the MBP
My MBA is perfect for traveling, though I wouldn't recommend it for your primary Mac. I view it as a "supplemental" machine that I travel with. I do any heavy lifting at home on a desktop. If it's going to be your main Mac, get the MB Pro.
I run an MBA as my only computer.
It does everything I want and this includes gaming in bootcamp.
I'm not sure how intensive second life is, but the other stuff is definitely a breeze for the 2.13 ghz model of MBA.
To those who think "MBA is supplementary" or "MBP and MBA is no comparison", most of you must not have even toyed with the MBA, it's a lot more powerful than at first glance.
At any rate, if you didn't make the request about 2nd life, I'd say definitely go for it, but I'm just not sure what 2nd life is, though I have a feeling it'll likely run quite well, you'd be surprised at what the 2.13 ghz can do.
I'd never understand why anybody would ever buy a MacBook Air unless they literally just browse the Internet and listen to music.
The Apple online refurb store, that is.
When I consider the 2.13 Air vs. a 13" Macbook Pro... the latter for me would be the $1,199. one plus the optional 256 SSD.
None of these new Macbook pros have shown up in the refurb store, yet. How long should that take?
......... It just occured to me that I don't know if that optional 256 gb SSD offered for the 13" MBP is of a slower or faster type? Would it hold true for the 13" MBP (as in the Air, per the recent revelation) that Samsung ones are slower, and Toshiba-sourced 256 gb SSD's are faster?
(If I call Applestore 800 number, would they be able to read the part # of the MBP's SSD to me?)
A refurb discount on that version of a current model MBP would offset some of the high ... is it $750. or $800. ... that they charge for that SSD option.
Very long story.
... but perhaps our situations have more differences than is easy to imagine.
I won't be opening any computers, or self-installing, then uninstalling a SSD if I need Apple service. And there is no "lab" whose computers I can borrow if my laptop has downtime.
I'm not in school yet... I have a deadline of January to write some new things for an application for a grad program, which I can only afford if I also win lots of scholarships. Once in school (a writing program) I must produce a piece of finished writing 7 days a week, and on some days hand in that plus a bigger assignment. There's a thesis in both long-form plus a slide-lecture version. Competitveness to get year #2's scholarships means getting stuff published while in the first year, too.
Since I'd be a commuting student 4 days a week, and bouncing around to various non-school libraries and bookstores on Fri.-Sat.-Sun... this literally means carrying the laptop around 6 or 7 days a week. (With a big cheap monitor on my desk in school, and another one on my desk at home.) The program has a part-time IT advisor, but supplies no hardware. Ever.
If I have any downtime or worse, disputes about which company has to fix anything, then I'll fall behind competitively, and then won't be able to win the set of big scholarships and grants essential to study there for the 2nd year.
The work pace is -- run, run, run! Using the computer for writing and research - all day, every day.
I plan to use the computer for 5-6 years, to the end of the 2nd battery. If I overpay by $500. or even twice that amount for big enough and durable enough (SSD) memory... what's that compared with (if this is the case) increasing the odds of downtime or repair disputes...... which could lose me over $20k in grants and turn the whole grad school undertaking into a financial trainwreck?
So, nobody's going to let me use their computer if mine breaks. My laptop must work reliably -- first for a year of preparatory work, and then if I win a big enough grant package to get into the school -- starting 9/2011 I'll need the computer to work every single day for the next 21 months, without fail.
If Apple's SSD's are now the fast kind, then the only attraction of other sources is -- having 256gb on an Air ....... or if the Air's skimpiness and update-stalling forces me to go with the 13" MBP + wear a backpack every day, the attraction would be avoiding Apple's price-gouging on 256gb... or maybe even being able to afford 512?