I'm not going to lie, both the 15" and 17" with matte screens both look hideous to me. I actually like the glassy screen. You might say "oh man the glare must be killer!" but it really isn't. When you first go outside, of course you notice it, but after using it for more than a minute, your eyes adjust and focus on what you're doing on the computer and not your ugly mug.
the 17 matte looks hideous, but the "Post Pics of 15 Matte" thread or w/e its called has some really sexy pictures of the 15 matte.