As someone who uses a T2 Mac just for music listening, the 1-3 dropouts I get a day are not that big a deal. However, I don't know how anyone could use it for audio production.
it can become a nightmare. especially if you're doing some recording or mastering.As someone who uses a T2 Mac just for music listening, the 1-3 dropouts I get a day are not that big a deal. However, I don't know how anyone could use it for audio production.
yes I have been experiencing problems with my Mac, considering I only bought it less than a month ago. when I play any audio weather that be music or even when watching a movie, they are fine for about half an hour - three quarters of an hour but afterwards they begin to skip and crackle!Anyone else noticed their speakers randomly crackling on the new MacBook Pro 2018? It happens every so often for me. Only saw one other report so far here: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8466796
===============
Edit by Weaselboy
Moderator Note:
Also see the discussion in the news thread:
https://forums.macrumors.com/thread...ners-experiencing-crackling-speakers.2131577/
yes I have been experiencing problems with my Mac, considering I only bought it less than a month ago. when I play any audio weather that be music or even when watching a movie, they are fine for about half an hour - three quarters of an hour but afterwards they begin to skip and crackle!
I have contacted apple about the problem and they just told me too update the software to the new MAC MOJAVE update and the reset the NVRAM and the PRAM, however this didn't not seem to work.
I don't know if anyone else has tried to do this but it is getting to the point where I feel like apple are trying to fob me off because they seem to have a lot of users contacting them about this problem?
Yes of course I tried that, but the problem is not fixed with Mojave
Mine is USB, I also tried to get on amazon zoom tac 2r (thunderbolt) and it still had problems, but it was long time ago, returned it a week after testing.@ everyone... were you guys using a usb interface? I plan to do some pro audio with a UAD thunderbolt interface. So far I haven’t experienced any crackling with my 2.6 15 inches using internal speakers or headphones. Bluetooth is off
Well, unfortunately this is what happened to me today... I was using Spectrasonics Keyscape (A high CPU Virtual instrument) in Logic Pro X @ 64 samples Buffer on the internal audio through the MBP Speakers. I went on Youtube to get some info about something and then... The crackling began, electrical noise style really loud crackling occured. So I though I was not touched by this plague but it just feels like I am now. Tomorrow is my last day for returning the MBP.
Wifi was on and I had an external SSD via USB-C to USB3 adapter plugged in that's it. So dissapointed.
I had this crackling problem on High Sierra. Updated to Mojave and I have not been able to reproduce it since. Anyone who has been able to reproduce it on 10.14.2?
- MBP 2018 i9
Wanted to post an update...
I cloned my pre-Security Update backup to my internal disk. I have not had any crackling since Saturday...
(This includes a few 5-6 hour DAW sessions, one in Logic, one in Live.)
If you didn't experience the issue right away I'd consider either cloning a backup you made with CCC to an external disk or new partition/volume then booting from it to see if it sorts the issue out for you... (Leave your old volume there until you confirm it does or doesn't help. More on that below...)
If you don't use CCC another thing you might try is creating a new partition or container volume on your internal disk, then restoring to the new partition/volume from a TM backup made before you noticed distortion. Then set the restored volume as the startup disk and stress test it for a few days to see if it works. If it seems to do the trick you'll then need to clone the volume back using CCC, PLEASE READ BELOW, and email Bombich before you do...
Do not wipe your current internal Macintosh HD volume if using Time Machine.
Clean installing the OS from a bootable drive doesn't work the way it did on previous Macs, some people have not been able to boot after trying to clean install... It's related to some kind of security feature of the T2 that I don't fully understand yet... Also, just using recovery to internet restore will most likely reinstall the updates that seem to trigger the issue...
(I don't know for sure if the updates are the only source of the issue, I just know they were for me... That said it would explain all of the discussion about bridgeOS since Security Update 2018-002 had a ton of bridgeOS updates, some coreaudio and IO updates, as well as some OS specific firmware...)
Unfortunately if you bought the machine with Mojave and had the issue from the get go I don't know a solution yet due to the clean install issues mentioned above... And since I'm still on HS (and don't plan on going near Mojave anytime soon) I don't know if Security Updates 2018-002 and 2018-003 came bundled from the factory with Mojave installs...
Anyway fingers crossed... Hoping this works for others as well!
[doublepost=1547200527][/doublepost]One other thing...
If you use CCC you should have local snapshots of your clones unless you've disabled this feature. (They're on by default.) Assuming you do, you can mount the oldest snapshot while booted to your current volume, then clone the mounted snapshot to an empty partition/volume and boot from it for stress testing...
Again, leave your old volume behind until you confirm it does or doesn't work...
Another thing you may not be aware of in CCC is the ability to restore only the OS from a local snapshot.
I tried this and it didn't work for me however I'm pretty damn sure this was strictly because of my SafetyNet settings...
In that case email Bombich and ask them how to clone the current volume to a new volume first, then fully restore only the OS from the older snapshot to the cloned volume, with SafetyNet turned off ... (SafetyNet won't overwrite modified files unless it's fully disabled. Since the Security Updates modified some of the OS's files SafetyNet leaves the updated files alone, leaving the problem hanging around... I didn't find an article about this until I'd already cloned back... Luckily it went ok.. In hindsight I would have played it safe.)
As long as you leave your current volume intact you have nothing to lose other than the few minutes it takes to clone to a new volume... Then just set it as the startup volume and test...
Yup. At least for me that was the case...You got me confused here. Are you saying it is the Security Updates that caused your crackling issue? I thought they were supposed to fix them.
Yup. At least for me that was the case...
https://forums.macrumors.com/thread...akers-crackling.2128234/page-49#post-26923285
Yeah in theory they should... All I know is crackling showed up as soon as I did a back-to-back install of 2018-002 and 2018-003... Since rolling back the issue's gone.
The Logic errors I posted in the thread above started the day after I installed them and sure sound like the crackle is jitter... After reading up about other errors I've seen in Console seems like it might be related to a buffering or core audio driver error.. (All of which the T2 chip manage.)
Anyway... I keep auto-updates turned off in the App Store and run CCC before installing any kind of OS/security update for exactly this reason. Recommend others do too until Apple get their **** together.
I am going to *cautiously* declare that 10.14.3 beta4 has improved matters considerably for me.
As somebody who has forked out 4k for something to make music on, at 11 days in out of my 14, I was just about ready to return it. Under 10.14.2 I was getting constant clicks and pops.
With the beta I am now largely down to the once a minute smart battery manager click if the first core is heavily loaded. Why can't Apple fix this CPU spike after six months ?
If I really monster the first core with Live, Logic and VCV Rack all running big patches at once then I can get dropouts but running exactly the same on my maxed out 2015 iMac the i9 MBP actually has less dropouts.
I would be interested to hear any other success stories. 3 days to go (and the Vega 20 screen flicker is NOT fixed yet).
I went online to tech support because I had the same crackling issue on my MacBook Pro i9 32GB 1TB 2018. I just wanted to do a chat quickly to at least get another issue in their logs, but they instead wanted to talk to me about the issue, so tech support called me the next day.
This is what happened: I first told them that I understand about when new technology comes out and of course there is sometimes difficulties and therefore was not rude to him nor irritated, but explained I just want this fixed. I stated that I am on High Sierra and want to stay with the OS that came with the system, for I have software that works with High Sierra and does not work with Mojave and I am kind of stuck to not upgrade.
I further explained to him that I did some research before calling and wanted to resolve the issue etc. After showing that I was not going to be a jerk (though I was upset after spending over $4,000, but held it in) and told him that I already knew that he will tell me to upgrade to Mojave as the solution, he tried first to help me, but nothing resolved the issue.
I also asked him does his records show that it is a T2 chip problem and if maybe he could share what his engineering department said is the issue (if he could tell me). I told him I understand that he cannot tell me much...but again since I was cooperative (nice) with him, he said that he would look through what engineering has said and then put me on hold. He came back a few minutes later and said that it is a known issue by apple engineering and that it is a software related issue. By upgrading to Mojave, it should resolve the issue. but if it continues, after upgrading, then you can send it in for repair. I told him that I would rather not send it in (I had issues before when product returning form repair), so we did some other checks, but no resolution.
Unfortunately..The solution: Upgrade to Mojave...that is of course not acceptable (sloppy engineering). Can't do a recall or lawsuits on MacBook pros if there is a software fix. So we are just stuck and have to upgrade. And Apple is covered.
If it is a software issue, then it can be fixed in High Sierra. Apple DOES NOT want to go back and work on the last version to fix it since they have moved on to a new OS. We have no choice if it is not a hardware issue. The tech said to try using bluetooth headphones or external audio options through the headphone jack and that some people have had good experiences with that if I have to stay on High Sierra...but that defeats the purpose of having a laptop...
So...if it is a software issue, that means Apple corrected a few files in Mojave. isn't Mojave REALLY just an upgrade version of High Sierra? The tech kind of hinted that it is an audio issue...so why not copy all of the audio related files, core audio files etc. from Mojave and port them into High Sierra and see if it resolves the issue...? I am willing to try, but do not know which audio related files to port. MAYBE that might fix the issue? I am willing to try.
If someone who knows more about macOS (developer etc.) could tell me what files to grab, I will do it and try. I want to stay on High Sierra and will try anything to avoid upgrading right now.
If it is a software fix, what files were fixed?
Can anyone tell me what files to try? Thanks.
My matters have progressively gotten worse, I'm considering sending it in for repair just to see what happens (that is if they dont offer me a direct replacement), I have a backup 2016 I can use for a while.
My issues are routed towards bluetooth, i've removed the possibility of USB interference. 10.14.3 should be released very soon, hopefully this week. Given the two betas days between each other. That will be the final straw, thats 6 months, plenty of time to resolve an issue.
I fully understand that by changing some lines of code for audio on the T2 chip can lead to widespread problems with other components within the mac, so its not just as easy as that. But 6 months is surely the deadline.
You have tried beta4 ?
I wish I had an answer for this... That said, there were a lot of audio extensions and frameworks updated in the Security Updates that caused issues for me. Below are a few screenshots of what was updated with audio related files marked in red.
Also note the modified timestamp, (just so you can confirm these were modified during the updates....)
As far as files that show dates in late November just be aware these are the build dates shown in timestamps... The actual install date for me was Dec 9th, and I've confirmed this by using spotlight to show only modified files from that date...
As you can see System Information makes it seems like less files were modified, but when you actually look in hidden folders you find there are a ton of files updated that either correspond to the extensions and frameworks or don't disply there because they're hidden by default. Many of which are system audio files... (This is also only a tiny portion of files I found modified that date... There are TONS...
You can also see bridgeOS was updated.
And a firmware update was also deployed...
Some of the files that might not seem related at first glance, as far as I've been able to get info about, handle hardware drivers... E.g. IOKit for example deals with drivers for onboard hardware, all of which are handled by the T2/bridgeOS now, including the audio hardware. (The T2's basically taken the place of what used to be SMC, at least as far as I've been able to find out... (Again though, there's very little info about bridgeOS anywhere online, and virtually nothing about it on Apple's site.) There are some articles and video I've found though that explain how it now handles the audio hardware, SSD controllers, camera, microphone, etc... (My understanding of this is crude at best... I do know however that T2/bridgeOS handle the hardware mentioned.)
Also, here's a link answering your question about what was updated in 10.14.2
(Many of which were also updated in the High Sierra Security Update released on the same day.)
http://rixstep.com/1//20181209,01.shtml
AS FAR AS WHAT ELSE YOU CAN DO...
I highly encourage you to call customer relations and file a complaint. Complaints it seem are what this is going to require to get this seen as a 'problem' internally... (I've already filed two complaints. And I'll keep filing them until their sick of hearing my voice...)
And if you have shares in Apple you really need to let that speak for you as well... As I've said in both complaints how is my money safe investing in a company that thinks it's ethical to break the OS my machine shipped with?
OTHER STRATEGIES:
Since I've found that at least on my machine the problem showed up with the security updates, then went away when I clone back from a a backup made before installing them, I'm going to play their game by creating a new partition and install of 10.13 as it came from the factory. (Not a container disk, but an old school partition... This way that version of the OS is 'walled off' from files that might unknowingly getting 'referenced' if in a container disk.)
From there I'm going to stress test and document each incremental update either introducing the issue, or improving it.
1. I'll start with the original OS and stress that for a day, screen capture, and record video.
2. Install the supplemental updates I had installed for the first 3 months that worked for me, screen capture, and record video.
3. Install the first security update, screen capture, and record video.
4. Install the second security update, screen capture, and record video.
Assuming the issue comes back they'll give me the same line about requiring me to update to Mojave.
Then I'll update the new partition to Mojave to stress test if Mojave actually does improve the issue or not... (I won't be kind in my stress tests... I know the behavior so well that if Mojave doesn't fully fix the issue I should be able to reproduce the issue within a day or two..)
If Mojave fails then I'll file another complaint citing that Engineering's requirement didn't address the issue...
If the tone doesn't change after that then It's time to send a fax and write a letter to the CEO's office, then file a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission and BBB then send a follow up letter and fax to the CEO's office. If I'm still back at square one then Apple can kiss my shares goodbye and it's time to embrace the reality that Windows may be the only way forward...
PM me if you want info about filing a complaint or want the fax number and mailing address for Tim Cook's Office...
Wow...thanks for the info. I will try. Thanks for taking the time. I would like to write a compliant to Apple, but what should I say so they don't just ignore it?