Report 4:
Well, after using my MacBook for a week now, fully charging and discharging about 3 times, and having enough charge/discharges to have the System Profiler saying I have a 'cycle count' of 9....
It looks like on 'max power saving plus AirPort', I'm going to get somewhere between 3:30 and 4 hours. Right now, I've been running for half an hour, and it says I have 4:00 left. Last night it lasted 3 and a half hours of pretty heavy, but not processor intensive, use after having been asleep for two hours unplugged, but fully charged.
This is all with power on 'Better Battery Life', Bluetooth off, AirPort on, screen brightness on one tick, one processor core turned off (via developer tools' added 'CPU' preference pane.)
Of note is that the System Profiler's 'power' section lists a 'full charge capacity' of 5574 mAh, and it took a few full charge cycles for it to have a 'remaining capacity' of that at full charge. (i.e. the first few recharges, even after a full discharge, then plugged in for 8 hours, it did NOT read 5574, but rather 5027. Now when plugged in long enough, it will read 5574.)