Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

orvn

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 11, 2011
263
0
Toronto, Canada
My problem was WORSE than yours... because I bought my MacBook Air in the US, my Apple ID, my address, my credit card, etc... is in the US, but I am currently visiting PANAMA (an Apple rep wanted to know what this was, and I had to explain it was a country... I asked if he had heard of the Panama Canal and he had not... he probably thinks Michael Jordan occupies a seat in the U.N.). That means, among other things, that there are no genius bars in Panama - which is probably not such a bad thing if you consider that the first thing some of these "geniuses" recommend is replacing the hardware, when this is obviously a software issue.

My MBA was working fine until I bought the ML upgrade. Upon installation, I had to go through all those depressing screen shots and quickly found out my HD could not be repaired. Luckily, I had purchased Apple care... The first agent (I spoke to about 8 of them in the course of 2 days) gave me the instructions to perform an Internet Recovery: hold option/command/R while turning the machine on. To do that, you obviously need an Internet connection, but for some reason my Wi-Fi didn't show up on the list and the only solution I found was to connect through my iPhone Personal Hotspot. It took 12 hours... (in retrospect, since I was about to wipe off the HD, I should have done that from the start and it would have taken less time to do the procedure with 1 GB instead of 200 GB). Eventually I was taken to a screen with disk utilities options. I called Apple again, not wanting to do something stupid... on my own. I was instructed to create a single partition, with extended journaled (don't ask me!) etc... Everything went along fine, until at the end, when I needed to insert my Apple ID. Permission was denied... Pretty frustrating, to say the least... The issue was now that the IP address showed I was NOT in the US, but I had a US Apple ID... I requested to escalate the case and apparently no one had a solution to this. I observed that Apple had no problem selling me the ML upgrade (or any other app) while traveling outside the US...

The solution? To perform another Internet Recovery... This time, as we had wiped off the system, it took only about 5 hours. After which I called Apple again... You know the definition of crazy: to repeat the same thing and expect different results. I ended up talking to another senior adviser. Actually, she did all the talking... whenever I spoke she would drown my words with non-stop chatter. She offered to provide me with her contact information and I said: "please don't" before hanging up. She had me change my real US address with a fake Panamanian address. I did, but very reluctantly. I didn't think this would fool the system. I called back once again, and this time I had a great rep on the line. He had a better idea... I had completely forgotten about that little USB key that had come in the package of my MBA... I rebooted using that recovery key. He told me that was a temporary fix and that I would need to travel back to the US to have my stuff back... Not very encouraging... OK, now my system was back to Snow Leopard, like it was when I purchased the MBA. I had make a Time Machine back up, two months earlier (not to self, do a back up before upgrading!) and of course it was on Lion, so I went to the app store and tried to download again Lion, but the only option was ML so I decided to select the new OS anyway. It worked. After that, I selected migration assistant and transferred from the Time Machine back up. I got a weird message saying that the system was preventing log out and I had to call Apple again. It took a few simple steps (the back up had created a new user and I had to select the one I wanted and delete the useless one) and now I'm back on track. Like nothing happened, except my two months of data that I hadn't backed up... Of course, you can do the same thing with a replacement HD, but that doesn't sound necessary!
;)

Woah man. That's quite a story. Glad you got everything sorted despite the ordeal.

And I can't believe the tele-specialist you spoke with was so geographically impaired!
 

Daptin

macrumors newbie
Jan 16, 2011
15
1
Panama
wow...I cannot believe that you went through this whole ordeal and still kept a positive attitude and still stuck with :apple:? :confused::eek: because there is 1 other painless option (windows 7)
and that person who helped you never heard of Panama? wow... >.<
What's your secret? how do you keep this positive attitude? I would've been so mad. I'm still a bit peeved about Lion and ML OS (with all the bugs and the new implementations). snow leopard was my fav mac os--it was relatively stable and doesn't have so much animation.

I'm a real estate broker, and a positive attitude is a job requirement. I went through two days of hell... Some agents did suck, but I must say that on the whole you could sense their level of customer service is high. Not to sound mean, but I was not talking to Ravi in Mumbai... Sticking with :apple: in spite of everything? Well of course, mine is an :apple: family. The spirit of Steve Jobs lives on and I won't go back to Windows and a clunky PC. Once you hold in your hands anything designed by :apple: there is no turning back. I was born in Switzerland and I understand perfectly Steve's concern about the inside looking as nice as the outside!
 

taxiapple

macrumors regular
Jun 9, 2009
191
27
I had the same problem on one of my 4 iMacs.
The Applecare tech tried a few things and was about at a dead end. He said others had had the problem and the only thing he could tell them was to take it to an Apple store.


While he had put me on hold, I used a Snow Leopard disc to open Disc Utility. Was able to Verify & Repair disc and subsequently was able to FINALLY get Mountain Lion installed. Took a long time and was frustrating but the main thing is .....I did not have to replace my hard rive.
 

Daptin

macrumors newbie
Jan 16, 2011
15
1
Panama
I had the same problem on one of my 4 iMacs.
The Applecare tech tried a few things and was about at a dead end. He said others had had the problem and the only thing he could tell them was to take it to an Apple store.


While he had put me on hold, I used a Snow Leopard disc to open Disc Utility. Was able to Verify & Repair disc and subsequently was able to FINALLY get Mountain Lion installed. Took a long time and was frustrating but the main thing is .....I did not have to replace my hard rive.

Ha, ha... what saved me, in a way, is that there was no genius bar they could refer me too. I can only imagine how many HD are being needlessly replaced!
 

snifferdog

macrumors newbie
Jul 26, 2012
3
0
ML killed my Lion HD

Ha, ha... what saved me, in a way, is that there was no genius bar they could refer me too. I can only imagine how many HD are being needlessly replaced!

Does anybody know if I can use for example OSX Tiger DVD to use the Disk Utility to repair my Macintosh HD.? I had Lion and was updating to ML when this disk error appeared out of nowhere.
I dont have a Lion DVD, came installed on my MBP.
 

daviruchu

macrumors newbie
Aug 1, 2012
1
0
I have the same exact problem

Everything that is in the screen shots happened to me. I did not back up my Computer since i didnt thing it was gonna be a problem. I dont know what to do now, if i can at least backup my files from disk utility that would be great, does anyone know how to do this? i tried everything else and cannot repair the disk or verify it. Its obvious that Mountain Lion has bugs and now we as consumers have to deal with it. Worst of all is that my imac doesnt have guarantee its a 2009 27" imac. Please help:(
 

orvn

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 11, 2011
263
0
Toronto, Canada
Does anybody know if I can use for example OSX Tiger DVD to use the Disk Utility to repair my Macintosh HD.? I had Lion and was updating to ML when this disk error appeared out of nowhere.
I dont have a Lion DVD, came installed on my MBP.

Everything that is in the screen shots happened to me. I did not back up my Computer since i didnt thing it was gonna be a problem. I dont know what to do now, if i can at least backup my files from disk utility that would be great, does anyone know how to do this? i tried everything else and cannot repair the disk or verify it. Its obvious that Mountain Lion has bugs and now we as consumers have to deal with it. Worst of all is that my imac doesnt have guarantee its a 2009 27" imac. Please help:(

Guys.
Please read the whole thread.

The DiskWarrior solution on the previous page works. It does not require a Time Machine backup.
 

derekc

macrumors newbie
Aug 8, 2012
1
0
Here is how I got away with it:
Use the DiscUtility Repair on the Volume "Macintosh HD", though it is grayed out and installer claimed it to be impossible.

Situation was that: on install, right after 30 seconds or so, installer complaint about the disc being damaged and could not be repaired.
Like the first screen photo of this thread "Install Failed".

Using the OSX stock Disc Utility, the drive ("1 TB .... Media") was available but the volume "Macintosh HD" was grayed out.
Using repair on the drive itself did not do anything, it was reporting everything is fine on the partition.

Finally, on a last check before putting the thing into it's box for transport, I gave it a click to the gray "Macintosh HD" and to my surprise found the "Volume Check" button still available. Doing that, the repair check sequence kicked in and reported:
- 2 additional leafs found that were not in the catalog
- 1 additional folder found that was not on file
Guess where they were coming from...

Final message: Volume has to be repaired. Repair button showed enabled.
I gave little hope to it as the installer already stated contradictory.
But at the end I've got a green light.

Then, when trying the install on the "Macintosh HD", it was complaining the drive is locked. Bummer.
But this was from the repair process I assumed and rebooted, after which the installation procedure kicked in automatically and completed without any issue.

I wish everybody facing the same issue good luck with this procedure.

Sweet! This one worked for me.

It did take 2 days+ continuous retry to download the 4.3Gb installation... I was worried the file could be corrupt and perhaps I bricked the install, but reading that the disk had failed was a bit of a shocker. (Memo to self: always take a backup before you do this sort of thing ;)

I didn't get the message about drive locked - it went straight into the install message 37 minutes remaining...

Installation seems to be complete with "Parallels Service" being declared as incompatible with ML. No loss as I've switched to VMWare Fusion, but interesting non-the-less.

~Derek
MBA upgraded from Lion to ML!
 

Lancer

macrumors 68020
Jul 22, 2002
2,217
147
Australia
Good to hear it worked out in the end, I just finished making a new CCC copy of my G5 Leopard in preparation for my new iMac... is 2 months according to the latest rumors :lol:

I figure 2 backups are better than one and I'll use one in a USB3 case to migrate to my new iMac, much faster than USB2 or FireWire. And in case anything goes wrong.
 

eb80314

macrumors newbie
Sep 26, 2012
1
0
DiskWarrior worked!

I had this problem and just got my MacBook Pro running again. In short, the ML installer did major damage to the directory of the drive the OS is installed on, making it unusable. Apple's Disk Utility could not repair the drive's directory. Applecare told me that I had to format the drive and install the old OS. This would work, but was not necessary in my case.

DiskWarrior by Alsoft was able to repair my severely damaged hard drive directory.

Once DiskWarrior repaired and replaced the drive's directory, I rebooted, and the ML installer started again. After running for a few minutes, it threw an error telling me that it couldn't install because it couldn't make a recovery partition on my drive (I will not address this error in this thread, it's a different problem.). The installer allowed me to restart and revert to my previous operating system, which I am using right now to type and post this the comment.

My system seems to be running as it was before I attempted the ML install. It appears that I lost no data, applications, or application settings. I'm not going to bother with ML at this time, since my system is working correctly again, and I don't really need any of the newest features right now. (I know better than to be an early adopter, grrr.)

In my case, the ML installer DID NOT damage the existing operating system, damage any of my data, nor did it do irreparable damage to the drive. I DID NOT NEED TO FORMAT the drive, I just needed to repair the drive's directory with a utility that could actually fix it.

To use DiskWarrior to repair your drive's directory, you must either

  • boot your broken Mac to a new enough DiskWarrior dvd (my version 4.1 would not boot my 17" i7),

  • boot your broken Mac to a different drive (or partition) with MacOS and DiskWarrior installed on it, or

  • connect your broken Mac to another Mac with DiskWarrior on it (using a Firewire cable), and boot the broken Mac in "Target Mode" (hold down the "t" key when you start it). Target mode allows the second Mac to access the drive of your broken Mac. I used this method, connecting my MacBook Pro to my old PowerPC Powerbook, by the suggestion of Alsoft tech support, using the instructions on their web site. (Research Target mode for more details/options.)
I am in no way affiliated with Alsoft.

I'm furious with Apple, though. This is the kind of crap we associate with Microsoft. And to get pure BS from the AppleCare folks is inexcusable (I left their BS out of this post, for brevity's sake, but it was ludicrously stupid, I assure you.).

I hope this post helps point some of you in the right direction.

I was able to install the purchased DVD of DiskWarrior 4.4, which took two days to arrive; Alsoft sends it first class mail. After inserting the disk and then rebooting and then pressing the 'C' key, DiskWarrior launched after several minutes. I was able to effectively repair the Hard Drive.

I had to reboot several times before realizing that the DiskWarrior needed to be ejected and the Snow Leopard start up disk inserted. Reinstallation of Snow Leopard went smoothly.

Not sure when I am going to attempt reinstall of Mountain Lion. What a headache.

Thanks for the advice to use DiskWarrior!!
 

Philscbx

macrumors regular
Jan 4, 2007
174
0
Mpls Mn
Thanks for the advice to use DiskWarrior

This entire Thread could easily be a number one hit video of the Year on YouTube.

Actually - I set up video camera when I installed FCS - just incase it went bad.
A pile of discs to install - but it went Ok.

Just by chance - looking through Evernote things to to list -
I had note about DiskWarrior & decided to search for it here on this site - What an Amazing Find.

Just wanted to say 'Thanks to All' who invested much time in perfecting the entire process.
Guess what I'm ordering this week before any attempt to upgrade.
Currently on 10.6.8 on both machines - Quite reluctant to update.
 

bwillwall

Suspended
Dec 24, 2009
1,031
802
I mean, it sounds like the drive failed. I've killed drives before, especially SSDs in notebooks.

Luckily, it sounds like you have a Time Machine backup?

Wait, is it easy to kill solid state? I thought it was more reliable?
 

Mal

macrumors 603
Jan 6, 2002
6,253
30
Orlando
Yeah, SSDs have a limited lifespan. Only a certain amount of time before they stop accepting writes and corrupt.

Take that "limited lifespan" with a grain of salt. For many of those drives, that lifespan will exceed yours. It's not like they're going to stop working after a year or two just because there was data being written to them.

When SSD's fail, it's almost certainly a problem with one of the components, but it's nearly impossible that in this case the write limit has been reached.

jW
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.