Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
A personal observation, take it for what you paid for it, but...

In my reading over many years about the problems others have with Macs, very often it seems that the Macs that have "the highest rates of failure" are those that are "all spec'd up" -- the ones that have been bought with the highest-speed CPUs, fancy GPUs, etc.

Lower-end and midrange Macs just seem to "last longer" with fewer problems.
The only exception is the Mac Mini -- they all seem about the same.

Again, my observation only.
Might be relevant as to considering your next purchase.
I have a slightly different take on that: the people buying Macs with lower specifications probably aren't the enthusiasts who use this web forum, and if they have any hardware problems they'd probably go straight to Apple without posting about it. Most people buying Macs with higher specifications are plugged into communities and will share their experiences.

Apple has the data on returns and warranty hits. They won't do well if their higher-end machines are regarded as untrustworthy, and if the enthusiasts start trashing them widely. People accuse Apple of not exerting the same level of attention to detail as when Steve Jobs was in charge, but whether you believe that or not it's very difficult to believe that they're not carefully ensuring that higher-end upgrade options can't be used reliably.

The problem is that sometimes I start thinking what if, given the scorching summer temperatures in my area and the fact that I do not use A/C (ambient temperature sensor in the iMac was always around 45ºC, even my brain has problems working at this ambient temperature, I prefer the -10ºC of the winter here), it could be that the cooling capabilities of the top iMac are not enough for my workloads and climate-change influenced increasing summer ambient temperatures. If I buy the same configuration and there is anohter failure due to the excessive room temperature next summer this would my main concern.
45˚C isn't a higher temperature for the sensor. My Mac is earlier and tends to idle in the upper 40's; under load I go into the 60's (I'm living in the tropics). People say that heat kills electronics, and to a certain degree that's true. But modern systems have various failsafes to ensure that they don't go into dangerous temperatures for the components.

As long as you're not riding the upper end of normal all the time, the temperature alone probably isn't a concern. A few years ago I read about thermal stress on components - that is, how being cycled from room temperature to high operating temperatures in a short amount of time causes more stress on components than operating consistently at a higher (but within tolerance) temperature. It makes sense; you hear about similar concerns in caring for your kitchen cookware and utensils. Yet even that is something that has an impact in the long run. I only bring it up because it's interesting to me that people worry about the temperature alone, yet people regularly are subjecting their systems to thermal cycling stresses and don't even think about it.

Maybe it had nothing to do with the high operating temperatures and it was only a faulty component. But this is the question that I do not know how to address.
Are there widespread reports of failure with this computer? I haven't heard of them, but you could check that. Do you live in one of the hotter parts of the world, and have you had other computers fail due to heat issues? You have a winter, so I'm guessing that you do not, and it sounds like this is the first failure you've experienced so I'd guess heat isn't killing things for you left and right. Are there things you can do to help ease your concerns - perhaps moving your computer so that it isn't in direct sunlight, or ensuring that it has good airflow? Go ahead and do that.

By the way, is there any recent rumors about a possible new iMac Pro 2 for this last quarter of the year 2019, given that the old one is almost 2 years old now?
No rumors at this point, and it's unknown what Apple will do with the iMac Pro. The new Mac Pro is coming out this autumn, so the suspicion is that Apple won't do anything with the iMac Pro for at least the next six months so as not to draw attention and sales away from the Mac Pro.

Hardware failures happen, no matter how careful you try to be and no matter which company you go with. I've had two MacBook Pros that had faulty graphics chips (the big, bad faulty ones where Apple issues an extension of warranty support for failures related to that issue even if people don't have AppleCare in effect anymore. It was inconvenient to not have my computer for the few days it took to repair them, but it was all done at no cost. It's a stark difference with when I had to try and get repairs done on a PC about a decade ago; maybe PC companies have upped their standards since then, but Apple still tends to be on top in the ratings and if my experiences are anything to go by, there's a reason for that.

The lesson I take away from your experience isn't to avoid Macs or iMacs, but to try and buy directly from Apple if you can. The subpar part of your experience really sounds like it centered around dealing with the third-party dealer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sam Marks
Hahahahahahahhaha, one bad product and you want to go windows? Man you need to get some thick skin if you want to go down that route.

Things break, its normal. (if its small number of course)
So having attitude of "one lemon and I'm out" is not gonna get your far in this world.
Warranty is for a reason and return period as well. Use it all the time.
Really no point wasting time here if you don't know what was wrong and we can't really help you. Just do what others said. Immediate Apple return and get another. If you get 5 in a row and they are all messed up MAYBE then you can think about leaving Apple but until then you really need to know that nothing is perfect. Small % will have defects and as a customer you are always protected. Especially with EU laws.
So, get a new one and don't be so sensitive. It will only drive you crazy :)
Good luck, keep us posted (with info) :)

Finally, the reseller agreed to give me my money back (full refund, as I requested, almost $4,000) for the defective iMac 27 i9 vega 48 that died short after start using it. It has been checked by the Apple service and it has a manufacturing defect. They did not specify what lethal (the computer is dead) defect but it could be a cooling problem or the logic board.

At last I will have the money back to think about what next computer I will buy. This experience has not been very for my confidence in the Apple brand. I do not know if I buy another iMac if I will get another lemon or it will die in the next few weeks due to my workload. It is for me very sad to say this, but I consider trying Windows 10 and the new AMD CPUs (after 10 years away from the PC realm), or a hack system (that I will manufacture my self with 0 defects, not like the last iMac).

Another option is a new Mac Book Pro, but as I travel a lot for business and the airlines are banning these computer onboard the planes it could be a big problem for me for mobilty.

Or, maybe I will wait for the new iMac Pro 2 2019 later this year :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sam Marks
I had 2 iMacs 27" 2019 i5 3.0Ghz .. one died at 6 months from purchase ... repaired on warranty (board and power suply ... the second one died last week (Out of warranty) 1,000 USD quoted for Board replacemnt... in less thant 2 years two computers died the same way...I think something is wrong with that model......
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nguyen Duc Hieu
I had 2 iMacs 27" 2019 i5 3.0Ghz .. one died at 6 months from purchase ... repaired on warranty (board and power suply ... the second one died last week (Out of warranty) 1,000 USD quoted for Board replacemnt... in less thant 2 years two computers died the same way...I think something is wrong with that model......

That's a very concerned info to me.
Maybe I'll need to rethink about purchasing an Intel iMac, and build a Hackintosh system instead. PC parts have 3 years or 5 years warranty, much longer than a typical iMac.
 
That's a very concerned info to me.
Maybe I'll need to rethink about purchasing an Intel iMac, and build a Hackintosh system instead. PC parts have 3 years or 5 years warranty, much longer than a typical iMac.
I had an iMac last 10 years. It did need a hard drive replacement which was covered by Apple Care (covered the Mac for 3 years). Personally, I would not build a Hackintosh. To much hassle trying to get everything working. I have built Windows systems but Windows is designed to run on a wide range of hardware.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nguyen Duc Hieu
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.