Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

TokyoKiller

macrumors regular
Aug 2, 2023
147
311
Get AppleCare+ while you can. Do it online or via the phone itself as it will run diagnostics and make sure phone works before letting you buy it I believe. Avoid going in store if possible.
 

TokyoKiller

macrumors regular
Aug 2, 2023
147
311
I second this approach. Years ago, I had a flat-panel iMac that I purchased from the Apple Store, and within the first few days of owning it, my cat decided to check it out, and that was when I found out that an iMac can be top heavy. My cat brushed alongside the front of the iMac wrong, and it flipped forward off of the desk, hit the keyboard, and landed in my chair. Functionally it was fine, but it had a nice gouge in the bottom, on the chin. I took it into the store I purchased it from, and they were able to repair it for just the cost of the parts, without AppleCare, which I promptly purchased after, and have for every Apple product since. They did me a solid, so perhaps Apple will help out the OP too.....
On iPhones, there is less flexibility if I can be honest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: phillytim

menist

macrumors 6502a
Jun 10, 2010
688
594
California
Get AppleCare+ via your iPhone, wait a couple days, message Apple about the damage and ask for a express replacement. They'll send you a new/refurb iPhone replacement with a extra box to send the damage one back. Pretty sure you will have to pay for the accidental damage fee.
 
Last edited:

auwkeung

macrumors regular
Apr 8, 2008
104
33
Just buy AppleCare+ and pay your deductible, they will send you a replacement no question asked.
They cannot discern an accidental damage vs a deliberate damage, and by providing AppleCare+, they probably already expect people to make such claims
 
  • Like
Reactions: phillytim

phillytim

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Aug 12, 2011
1,784
1,272
Philadelphia, PA
Yesterday I stopped by the local Apple Store, and acted like I was buying an iPad (which I am going to be upgrading my ol' iPad in the near future).

In the conversation I showed the person my phone, said I just got it and dropped it and damaged the camera - he looked at it and said that it should be fine - and that Apple doesn't AppleCare "normal wear and tear".

I didn't go to the Genius Bar itself to expressly ask about the damage, because I was hoping the floor person would give me some insight - he had no pity on me. lol
 

IconIc215

macrumors 65816
Oct 11, 2013
1,427
1,255
Yesterday I stopped by the local Apple Store, and acted like I was buying an iPad (which I am going to be upgrading my ol' iPad in the near future).

In the conversation I showed the person my phone, said I just got it and dropped it and damaged the camera - he looked at it and said that it should be fine - and that Apple doesn't AppleCare "normal wear and tear".

I didn't go to the Genius Bar itself to expressly ask about the damage, because I was hoping the floor person would give me some insight - he had no pity on me. lol
Are you going to try again at another store or just wind up keeping it?
 

phillytim

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Aug 12, 2011
1,784
1,272
Philadelphia, PA
Are you going to try again at another store or just wind up keeping it?

Perhaps I'll just go straight to the Genius Bar at the Apple Store, show them what happened and ask how much an OOW repair would cost - and see if they show any mercy.

If that doesn't turn out, then I'll just go the route of using my AMEX Purchase Protection (within 90 days) reimbusement to get the camera lens repaired by Apple (or replaced, if Apple so chooses).

I really do not want to scam anyone; it was a horrible mishap on a shiny new object.

Perhaps the bigger lesson here is: do not buy something valuable on a Friday the 13th, as I did. ⛈️;) LOL
 
Last edited:

eyoungren

macrumors Penryn
Aug 31, 2011
29,659
28,433
Do you think the Apple Store would even have replacements available, in this time of high demand of the new product?
Apple diverts some units from production for replacement. They are brand new, they just go into those white boxes you see at the Apple store instead of a retail box.
 
  • Like
Reactions: phillytim

eyoungren

macrumors Penryn
Aug 31, 2011
29,659
28,433
Just buy AppleCare+ and pay your deductible, they will send you a replacement no question asked.
They cannot discern an accidental damage vs a deliberate damage, and by providing AppleCare+, they probably already expect people to make such claims
They can, however, determine COSMETIC damage, whether it's ACCIDENTAL or not.

Cosmetic damage, which does not prevent the device from working correctly, might be a cause to send OP's device back. Because Apple does not cover cosmetic damage whether that damage is accidental or deliberate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: phillytim

TokyoKiller

macrumors regular
Aug 2, 2023
147
311
Just buy AppleCare+ via the phone as we've suggested here and break the damn thing and go through the replacement process. Being up front with Apple these days isn't like it used to be back in the day, company is a penny pincher now.
 

phillytim

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Aug 12, 2011
1,784
1,272
Philadelphia, PA
Just buy AppleCare+ via the phone as we've suggested here and break the damn thing and go through the replacement process. Being up front with Apple these days isn't like it used to be back in the day, company is a penny pincher now.

Which is a real shame, knowing that Apple sits on that $3 Trillion dollar wad of cash - as so many of we peons scramble our pockets to patronize it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TokyoKiller

eyoungren

macrumors Penryn
Aug 31, 2011
29,659
28,433
Just buy AppleCare+ via the phone as we've suggested here and break the damn thing and go through the replacement process. Being up front with Apple these days isn't like it used to be back in the day, company is a penny pincher now.
Which is a real shame, knowing that Apple sits on that $3 Trillion dollar wad of cash - as so many of we peons scramble our pockets to patronize it.
Yeah, someone here commented recently in a thread of mine that the Apple Geniuses now are basically just salespeople. As salespeople, dealing with customers over a repair or replacement means they aren't selling anything. And that means they are not meeting the metrics that were established when Ahrendts took over managing all the Apple stores.

That, I think is why Apple Geniuses now are always trying to sell you something. And @phillytim, is probably why you had such a cold reaction when you were 'looking' at iPads. The genius probably deduced your real reason and wasn't going to get a sale from you, so shut you down.

I had a similar thing when trying to get a new battery recently for a 6 Plus. I disagreed with the genius's assessment of my device (failing logicboard he said) and he knew he wasn't getting a sale (of a new phone), so low and behold, Apple's system would not allow him to order a battery.
 
  • Love
Reactions: phillytim

phillytim

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Aug 12, 2011
1,784
1,272
Philadelphia, PA
Decided to take another shot at the Apple Store, after remembering that I took this photo when I initially picked up my phone (before dropping it)—which shows banding while taking a photo of an area with a large LED screen, and worries me that it will happen again.

As we all capture LED screens of some sort nowadays—be it at an Phillies game, an Apple Store, nightclubs, or even our own home TV—and I believe that we should expect better from a $1200+ device that is used for professional movies and media coverage, without the photo banding that I experienced.

Today I had an Apple Genius appointment, who had no mercy about the chipped camera, and could not replicate a banding photo from the camera—this Apple Store had no big led screens to attempt a comparative replication of my situation either.

She seemed warm to the idea of giving me a replacement phone, and even checked stock to see they had some on hand, but her manager would not approve the phone exchange.

The Apple Genius did agree about the idea that I could return the phone, and buy another—but she cautioned me by saying that the photo banding issue could also happen with any other 15 Pro Max.

And that my out of warranty repair would be the $199 back glass.

So there’s that.

Also interesting: the Apple Genius cautioned me about placing tempered glass protection on the rear cameras—that the tempered glass adhesive could distort the image or trap grit in the cameras and cause issues.

[EDIT: At this point, I actually feel like that may just be another Apple ploy to make money from more unprotected cameras being scratched/chipped/broken.]

So if I want decent rear camera protection, looks like I’d have to get a more protective case. I loved my 11 Pro Max in Apple leather case—it took a beating and never cracked or chipped. SMH

So IDK ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Gave it my best courteous shot; never hurts to ask.

Perhaps my next phone will be a Google Pixel—which has a solid-looking rear camera mechanism, that is easily protected with any decent case.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0028.jpeg
    IMG_0028.jpeg
    222 KB · Views: 65
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren

eyoungren

macrumors Penryn
Aug 31, 2011
29,659
28,433
Yes. I have found employees to be very reasonable.
OP literally posted this right above your message…;)

Today I had an Apple Genius appointment, who had no mercy about the chipped camera, and could not replicate a banding photo from the camera—this Apple Store had no big led screens to attempt a comparative replication of my situation either.

She seemed warm to the idea of giving me a replacement phone, and even checked stock to see they had some on hand, but her manager would not approve the phone exchange.

Not so sure that's 'very' reasonable. 🤷‍♂️
 
  • Love
Reactions: phillytim
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.