Just figured it out.
FULL website screenshot option does not appear when I am on my VPN.
I turn off vpn and it appears first try on the same exact website.
I turn on vpn and the full website option disappears on screenshots.
!hah! I literally just registered an account on macrumors to tell the world! ...I am sure it is out there but I could not find this solution anywhere on any forums
I am using NordVpn