Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

KdParker

macrumors 601
Oct 1, 2010
4,793
998
Everywhere
The person having problems doesn't care how many other people are having the same problem; they just care that THEY are having that problem.

Sure. But most people just get the phone replaced if it is defective. And I would care how many people experienced my same issue with a phone. Will help me judge whether or not to move on.
 

Vegastouch

macrumors 603
Jul 12, 2008
6,185
992
Las Vegas, NV
Well then you send it in and use a backup phone for a few days. Either way, I don't think think this is something that would sway someone from getting a certain phone. If you really like the phone / OS, the fact that you can't change the battery won't force you to like a phone that does let you change it.

Yeah, thats not inconvenient :rolleyes:

What about that in anyway is easier than just putting in a spare battery.......that is cheap on eBay?

Seems to sure sway some.

----------

how many iPhone users are having issues with power that you need a new battery?

I had 3 iPhones and haven't noticed any power issues.

Maybe not but many complain of the battery life and if you want to get a replacement or get a bigger one, all you have to do is pop out the original and pop in the new one. Takes 5 seconds.

You can add bigger batteries like these(post #61 of this thread) https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/15451901/
 

Mac.World

macrumors 68000
Jan 9, 2011
1,819
1
In front of uranus
Well maybe I should weigh in here. In the past year, I went from the iPhone 4, to the GSII Skyrocket (LTE GSII), to the HTC One X, and back to an iPhone 4S (all on AT&T).

First off, I must say, yes, the screens on the androids were amazing, and the iPhone needs a larger screen, probably even larger than the one we're getting on the next iPhone. However, I did end up going back to iPhone. This was for several reasons, which may or may not pertain to others.

1. The general bugginess/lagginess, especially in scrolling. Lots of little annoying bugs, and the feeling that everything wasn't as solid as it should be, and scrolling was not always smooth, even on the supposedly unbelievably powerful One X.

2. I needed automatic and seamless integration with my iTunes library and podcasts. Even with the iTunes syncing apps on android, not everything makes it over to the phone, especially iTunes-purchased videos, like music videos or movies with the fairplay drm. And no way to get them onto an android either that I could see. You pretty much end up starting a play store account and start buying things over there. I was tired of having a partial iTunes library, mostly music only.

3. I needed integration with other Apple products. I was used to using my iPhone as a really good remote for the Apple TV for instance, and this is not possible on android as far as I can tell. Also the airplay and airplay mirroring are really nice features that are difficult to reproduce on android. I can use my iPhone as a controller to play iPhone games on my TV through airplay mirroring.

So, in general, I just needed to go back to get the solid reliable functionality that I was used to. I do see how android may appeal to others, however, especially people who need a larger screen or rooters/hackers.

I would never have recommended android to someone with your needs, #2 specifically. #3 can be done with Android and apple tv though. ;)

As for games, you haven't seen what the S3 or Nexus devices can do, have you? It puts the iphone to shame. Why in the world would anyone want to play a game using their phones screen, especially a tiny phone like the iphone? . And no tactile feedback to know if you are hitting the right button? I use a wireless PS3 controller with my S3 and Nex7 and either play on the phones screen or on my 50" hdtv. Now that is mobile gaming! :D
 

matttye

macrumors 601
Mar 25, 2009
4,957
32
Lincoln, England
Sure. But most people just get the phone replaced if it is defective. And I would care how many people experienced my same issue with a phone. Will help me judge whether or not to move on.

I know this, but I'm not sure why we're going round and round in circles.

Somebody said they're not sure why it's such a big deal to get the phone replaced if the battery dies. I simply said there are much better ways of doing this; I.e. by simply swapping the battery with a spare by taking off the back cover, slotting it in and replacing the back cover.

Imagine if you had to get your car replaced when the battery died.

Why would anybody rather backup their phone, take their phone to the store (which is hours away for some people; some even have to mail it in because there is no store where they live), and then restore the backup on their replacement, rather than just swap with a spare battery that's sat on their desk?

This makes NO sense.
 

Vegastouch

macrumors 603
Jul 12, 2008
6,185
992
Las Vegas, NV
Cant recall which thread i talked about this in but i got my twp back battery covers today from China from This Site .

I got two covers. A Mettalic cover and a cover with leather on th back. NFC does NOT work with the metal cover on but it does with the leather one on.

Here are the back covers i got:

20120817_193147.jpg


20120817_193158.jpg
 
Last edited:

JodyK

macrumors 6502a
Jan 29, 2010
717
22
Northern Atlanta suburbs
I am so deeply rooted in the Apple Eco System that I could never go back ... Plus I really don't like the Android operating system ... Yes I tried one back in the day.

With that being said I have a few friends who just got the S3 and they really love it so far. I put my hands on it and it is impressively thin and very fast. Screen is LARGE compared to the iPhone.

This will only motivate Apple to keep doing what they do and make the iPhone better and better! YES competition is good for us, the consumer!
 

Sdahe

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Oct 26, 2007
1,723
23
San Juan, PR
Well... got the Galaxy S3 since August 11... it's been 11 days. What can I say?.. ok

1. NO LAG... I haven't seen any lag what so ever. The phone is very smooth.

2. SPEED 4GLTE: I'm just going to say... WOW!.. yesterday I did a speed test and got 18MG of download and 4MB of upload. It's insane. You will love when uploading videos to Youtube.

3. Camera performance in low light: Excellent... check out this video of a concert I went last weekend - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bsFJxS_O-wo

4. WIDGETS: I'm really loving this...

5. SCREEN: the resolution is amazing. Videos and photos are so sharp and crisp. The screem is gorgeous.

6. BATTERY: it goes all day.. no problems here. Sometimes I think is better than the iPhone's battery.

7. SYNC: I can sync my phone with my calendar and contacts with my mac.. even better since it's all online. Just like icloud.

I don't think I'm coming back to iPhone
 

daveathall

macrumors 68020
Aug 6, 2010
2,379
1,410
North Yorkshire
Well... got the Galaxy S3 since August 11... it's been 11 days. What can I say?.. ok

1. NO LAG... I haven't seen any lag what so ever. The phone is very smooth.

2. SPEED 4GLTE: I'm just going to say... WOW!.. yesterday I did a speed test and got 18MG of download and 4MB of upload. It's insane. You will love when uploading videos to Youtube.

3. Camera performance in low light: Excellent... check out this video of a concert I went last weekend - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bsFJxS_O-wo

4. WIDGETS: I'm really loving this...

5. SCREEN: the resolution is amazing. Videos and photos are so sharp and crisp. The screem is gorgeous.

6. BATTERY: it goes all day.. no problems here. Sometimes I think is better than the iPhone's battery.

7. SYNC: I can sync my phone with my calendar and contacts with my mac.. even better since it's all online. Just like icloud.

I don't think I'm coming back to iPhone

I've had mine over a month now and echo your thoughts above. I don't think that I will be going back to an iPhone.
 

teltras

macrumors newbie
Aug 22, 2012
12
0
Well... got the Galaxy S3 since August 11... it's been 11 days. What can I say?.. ok

1. NO LAG... I haven't seen any lag what so ever. The phone is very smooth.

2. SPEED 4GLTE: I'm just going to say... WOW!.. yesterday I did a speed test and got 18MG of download and 4MB of upload. It's insane. You will love when uploading videos to Youtube.

3. Camera performance in low light: Excellent... check out this video of a concert I went last weekend - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bsFJxS_O-wo

4. WIDGETS: I'm really loving this...

5. SCREEN: the resolution is amazing. Videos and photos are so sharp and crisp. The screem is gorgeous.

6. BATTERY: it goes all day.. no problems here. Sometimes I think is better than the iPhone's battery.

7. SYNC: I can sync my phone with my calendar and contacts with my mac.. even better since it's all online. Just like icloud.

I don't think I'm coming back to iPhone


I´m an iphone user since 2009, but since Galaxy S2 was released...I´m not comming back to ios.

Iphone 4S sold! Hello galaxy S3
 

Catdogchicken

macrumors regular
Sep 13, 2011
106
0
Sheffield UK
Think I'll be next on the S3 brigade. Got one in my basket on Amazon. Think I might give ios a few iterations before I consider it again. As long as it plays with my Mac I'm happy. Sdahe, what app do you use to sync your S3 with calendar and contacts on your Mac?
 

Sdahe

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Oct 26, 2007
1,723
23
San Juan, PR
Think I'll be next on the S3 brigade. Got one in my basket on Amazon. Think I might give ios a few iterations before I consider it again. As long as it plays with my Mac I'm happy. Sdahe, what app do you use to sync your S3 with calendar and contacts on your Mac?

You dont need an app for that. All you need is a Gmail account. Then you go to your calendar and contact preferences and add your gmail account for sync. It works perfect.
 

LIVEFRMNYC

macrumors G3
Oct 27, 2009
8,877
10,987
Well... got the Galaxy S3 since August 11... it's been 11 days. What can I say?.. ok

1. NO LAG... I haven't seen any lag what so ever. The phone is very smooth.

2. SPEED 4GLTE: I'm just going to say... WOW!.. yesterday I did a speed test and got 18MG of download and 4MB of upload. It's insane. You will love when uploading videos to Youtube.

3. Camera performance in low light: Excellent... check out this video of a concert I went last weekend - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bsFJxS_O-wo

4. WIDGETS: I'm really loving this...

5. SCREEN: the resolution is amazing. Videos and photos are so sharp and crisp. The screem is gorgeous.

6. BATTERY: it goes all day.. no problems here. Sometimes I think is better than the iPhone's battery.

7. SYNC: I can sync my phone with my calendar and contacts with my mac.. even better since it's all online. Just like icloud.

I don't think I'm coming back to iPhone

Overall agree. Haven't had any lag yet, and surprisingly battery life is good. I think my iP4 has better stand-by life, but for daily usage the GS3 batt life is up to par with my iP4. Screen is amazing for watching vids. I also have no problems with one hand usage, and my hands are not big at all.

One thing I'm struggling with is finding a decent car charger that charges fast enough. I had to resort to getting a AC power converter which I plug the original usb power adapter to. And even when charging from AC(car or home), it still charges slower than the iPhone.
 

Calidude

macrumors 68000
Jun 22, 2010
1,730
0
I think my iP4 has better stand-by life
Do you use the Facebook app on your phone? Facebook's app is notoriously well known for causing some of the worst battery drain in the Android app world. Those guys at Facebook must be getting some heavy duty datamining wakelocks on their app.
 

garybUK

Guest
Jun 3, 2002
1,466
3
I'm interested in know if anyone has compared a jailbroken iPhone to a rooted/stock/whatever S3 ? this 'freedom' everyone is on about, i don't see how it's different.

I am being offered a new phone by my work and interested to try a S3 along side my iPhone.

Also can you use the phone's stock with other stores or are you tied to Play?
 

Sdahe

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Oct 26, 2007
1,723
23
San Juan, PR
One said that the new iphone will put the Galaxy S3 to shame.... well, I think the Galaxy S3 already did that with the iPhone 4S... The GS3 put the iPhone 4S in shame... big time!!! and will continue like that with the new iphone.

I know...the truth hurts!.. sorry :)
 

AustinIllini

macrumors G5
Oct 20, 2011
12,699
10,567
Austin, TX
This. I tried the S3 for about 2 weeks and am back. Coming from the OG EVO I thought I'd like to go back. Tried it and just wasn't the same. Our household and everything we have is now Apple so it just didn't work for us. Missed the simplicity.

Same thing happened to me. Not being able to integrate with all my other Apple stuff was just too much of a pain.

----------

One said that the new iphone will put the Galaxy S3 to shame.... well, I think the Galaxy S3 already did that with the iPhone 4S... The GS3 put the iPhone 4S in shame... big time!!! and will continue like that with the new iphone.

I know...the truth hurts!.. sorry :)

You're right about the S3 and the 4S. There really is no comparison because the phones are so different and both great in different ways.
 

Zaft

macrumors 601
Jun 16, 2009
4,570
4,049
Brooklyn, NY
One said that the new iphone will put the Galaxy S3 to shame.... well, I think the Galaxy S3 already did that with the iPhone 4S... The GS3 put the iPhone 4S in shame... big time!!! and will continue like that with the new iphone.

I know...the truth hurts!.. sorry :)

Your opinion doesnt = truth. learn that
 

chrisrosemusic1

macrumors 6502a
Jan 31, 2012
696
21
Northamptonshire, England
Think I'll be next on the S3 brigade. Got one in my basket on Amazon. Think I might give ios a few iterations before I consider it again. As long as it plays with my Mac I'm happy. Sdahe, what app do you use to sync your S3 with calendar and contacts on your Mac?

Just thought I'd let you know that Samsung released 'easy phone sync' for us UK S3 users. You can now sync with iTunes. Mix that with allowing your other iOS devices and OSX to sync with gmail and its the same experience as iPhone. You can even use automated to sync the photos to photo stream so they are updated on your iOS devices when you take a pic.

Easy as pie. Mine is coming tomorrow. Actually excited about a new phone for first time in years!
 

alphaod

macrumors Core
Feb 9, 2008
22,183
1,245
NYC
I bought a Galaxy S III a few months ago and it is still one of the fastest phones I've used. Screen is great and I've been using Android for quite some time.

However thing that keeps from making a permanent switch is the crappy keyboard. I have SwiftKeys which is bit better but still it feels inferior compared to the iOS keyboard. And Android marketplace still feels disorganized.
 

BoxerGT2.5

macrumors 68020
Jun 4, 2008
2,114
14,154
I bought a Galaxy S III a few months ago and it is still one of the fastest phones I've used. Screen is great and I've been using Android for quite some time.

However thing that keeps from making a permanent switch is the crappy keyboard. I have SwiftKeys which is bit better but still it feels inferior compared to the iOS keyboard. And Android marketplace still feels disorganized.

Try the Jelly Bean keyboard, best one I've found.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.