Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

X-Ravin

macrumors regular
Nov 30, 2008
145
9
Just installed, not seeing a difference on mine. Maybe slightly better scrolling in launchpad, but everything else feels the same.
 

aj8690

macrumors regular
Aug 28, 2012
116
111
Columbus, OH, USA
Have only been using it for a little bit but I do feel that Mission Control and switching between spaces is smoother on Retina while on Intel HD 4000 in scaled resolution.
 

dcorban

macrumors 6502a
Oct 29, 2007
915
30
I have 10.8.2 and the EFI update installed on my 2012 Air. I haven't tested everything, but Safari is significantly smoother on sites like theverge and afterposten. They were rather choppy before, even after a fresh reboot. Now, they are almost completely smooth, except for a little judder.

Contacts and the App Store are still chunky as hell, but why care how choppy a maximize animation is on these apps?

* Note that I have only clicktoflash installed in Safari. Maybe people with poor Safari performance have certain extensions installed?
 

davidmcguigan

macrumors member
May 21, 2009
45
0
I have 10.8.2 and the EFI update installed on my 2012 Air. I haven't tested everything, but Safari is significantly smoother on sites like theverge and afterposten. They were rather choppy before, even after a fresh reboot. Now, they are almost completely smooth, except for a little judder.

Contacts and the App Store are still chunky as hell, but why care how choppy a maximize animation is on these apps?

* Note that I have only clicktoflash installed in Safari. Maybe people with poor Safari performance have certain extensions installed?


We're actually talking about Retina MacBook Pro specific performance.
 

bwrlane

macrumors newbie
Jul 31, 2012
3
0
London, Great Britain
It's out, can people with retinas report back? Is the graphics performance any better? Is it worth my returning my new non retina to get a retina? Inquiring minds! Thanks!!!



It is definitely better but not perfect. Scrolling in Safari is slightly better. Scrolling in heavy sites is still laggy. Mission control with lots of apps open again is still laggy but the improvement is noticeable.
 

mrapplegate

macrumors 68030
Feb 26, 2011
2,818
8
Cincinnati, OH
No! It's not the hardware. Stop blaming the hardware for the software issues that Apple can't deal with.

Did you read the article I linked to? Others think it is hardware as well.
At the default setting, either Intel’s HD 4000 or NVIDIA’s GeForce GT 650M already have to render and display far more pixels than either GPU was ever intended to. At the 1680 and 1920 settings however the GPUs are doing more work than even their high-end desktop counterparts are used to

To be quite honest, the hardware in the rMBP isn’t enough to deliver a consistently smooth experience across all applications.
 

cmChimera

macrumors 601
Feb 12, 2010
4,308
3,844
It is definitely better but not perfect. Scrolling in Safari is slightly better. Scrolling in heavy sites is still laggy. Mission control with lots of apps open again is still laggy but the improvement is noticeable.

This is where I'm at. I've definitely noticed an improvement in Mission Control. It still get's a little choppy when I have a lot of windows up (Discrete graphics work fine though) but overall is much better.

And when I say a lot, I mean 10+. Which is stretching the usability of Mission Control for me anyway.
 

dcorban

macrumors 6502a
Oct 29, 2007
915
30
We're actually talking about Retina MacBook Pro specific performance.

It's pretty obvious that this isn't specific to the retina pro. Anyone who claims otherwise should test other MacBooks, because it is immediately obvious.
 

iOrbit

macrumors 6502a
Mar 8, 2012
569
30
can everyone in this thread please confirm the following:

if you had Mac OS X Lion before, it was fine/smooth?

it has been an issue since Mountain lion.


now the last thing i ask of people with retina macbook pros:

does the lagg decrease alot when you change your dock option to be on the
left or right side of the screen (so it becomes a 2D Dock)

??

when i do this, on my 2011 macbook pro, i see alot of improvement on the lag. its practically gone, im convinced the UI lagg is partly to blame with the new dock (in reference to mission control and swiping. i don't know about Safari)

the reason i suspect this is because my lag issue was quite worse on my 1080p external monitor, which i can only assume is to do with the fact its pushing more pixels than my built in lcd on the laptop.

the 10.8.2 update has improved things, but its still not like Lion.

its also a factor that when my GPU is on the intel one, the problem is at its worse.

for me the problem is completely gone when i have the dock on Auto-Hide, so it isn't visible while swiping.
 
Last edited:

Cassadian

macrumors regular
Sep 4, 2012
140
0
Did you read the article I linked to? Others think it is hardware as well.

Both GPU's can handle refreshing millions of pixels. They can't handle the scaling software.

Try running your rMBP at full resolution and look for the lag. There probably won't be any or at least minimal lag.
 

mrapplegate

macrumors 68030
Feb 26, 2011
2,818
8
Cincinnati, OH
Both GPU's can handle refreshing millions of pixels. They can't handle the scaling software.

Try running your rMBP at full resolution and look for the lag. There probably won't be any or at least minimal lag.

I think you misunderstand me. I don't even have a rMBP. I was stating what other experts have been reporting. Anandtech is a well respected source for CPU and GPU reviews. They stated the hardware limitations. I was just pointing them out. Other publications have stated the same. I am just the messenger :)
 

davidmcguigan

macrumors member
May 21, 2009
45
0
Crapple

Both GPU's can handle refreshing millions of pixels. They can't handle the scaling software.

Try running your rMBP at full resolution and look for the lag. There probably won't be any or at least minimal lag.

You're exactly right. And it pisses me off that Apple released it as is and still hasn't fixed the issue 3 months later. It cost me a hell of a lot of money and productivity.

----------

I think you misunderstand me. I don't even have a rMBP. I was stating what other experts have been reporting. Anandtech is a well respected source for CPU and GPU reviews. They stated the hardware limitations. I was just pointing them out. Other publications have stated the same. I am just the messenger :)

I think you misunderstand this thread.

Yes, OS X has graphics problems and struggles here and there on all macs.

But on the retina it's way way way worse. That's why it's such a big deal and why we're all depressed and suicidal ( jk ).
 

bwrlane

macrumors newbie
Jul 31, 2012
3
0
London, Great Britain
can everyone in this thread please confirm the following:

if you had Mac OS X Lion before, it was fine/smooth?

No it wasn't fine at all. I was really surprised when I saw how the rMBPs were in the Apple store (running Lion). They delivered a much WORSE experience than any mac I have seen in a long time. Including my late 2010 macbook Air.

I still bought one (2.6, 512GB, 16GB) because I was prepared to sacrifice the aesthetic smoothness for the overall quality and power of the machine.

Mine came with Lion. It was laggy. I upgraded to ML. I was still laggy and I didn't notice an improvement or deterioration. After upgrading to 10.8.2 there is a DEFINITE improvement, but it is still laggy.

now the last thing i ask of people with retina macbook pros:

does the lagg decrease alot when you change your dock option to be on the
left or right side of the screen (so it becomes a 2D Dock)

??

No. I have experimented with both. No obvious difference. Complex websites remain very choppy in Safari. As is Mission Control with lots of Windows open.

the reason i suspect this is because my lag issue was quite worse on my 1080p external monitor, which i can only assume is to do with the fact its pushing more pixels than my built in lcd on the laptop.

I use a 1920x1200 external monitor. When this is connected, the lag is COMPLETELY gone. All lagging scenarios with the retina screen are perfectly smooth with the external monitor. Note that the external monitor only runs with the dGPU. If you try to enable the iGPU with the external monitor, your machine will crash.

the 10.8.2 update has improved things, but its still not like Lion.

Lion was no better than 10.8.1 with my rMBP.

for me the problem is completely gone when i have the dock on Auto-Hide, so it isn't visible while swiping.

This makes no difference with my rMBP
 
Last edited:

King Shady

macrumors 6502
Aug 22, 2010
374
134
San Jose, CA
Installed both updates, and definitely impressed. Swiping between full screen apps is now much more fluid and there is no visible choppiness. yay :D. I was so tired of the stupid lag and choppiness
 

liquidtwitch

macrumors regular
Dec 7, 2011
116
48
Brisbane Australia
finding mission control much much faster, still slow when I force hd4000 though - but im pretty satisfied with the improvement.

However, I found lag before the 10.8.2 update to be really inconsistant. I could never work out what apps open would cause it, so it might return.
 

throttlemeister

macrumors 6502a
Mar 31, 2009
550
63
Netherlands
After installing all the updates, it is definitely a lot better. Not perfect, and it will still stutter once in a while, but a lot better.

Benchmarks also confirm it: 10.8.0 gave a score of 88 on the UI test, with 10.8.2 and EFI update I am getting 220 on the same test.

Running like 1920x1200 fwiw.
 

jffluis

macrumors regular
Aug 28, 2012
145
25
can everyone in this thread please confirm the following:

if you had Mac OS X Lion before, it was fine/smooth?

it has been an issue since Mountain lion.


now the last thing i ask of people with retina macbook pros:

does the lagg decrease alot when you change your dock option to be on the
left or right side of the screen (so it becomes a 2D Dock)


??

when i do this, on my 2011 macbook pro, i see alot of improvement on the lag. its practically gone, im convinced the UI lagg is partly to blame with the new dock (in reference to mission control and swiping. i don't know about Safari)

the reason i suspect this is because my lag issue was quite worse on my 1080p external monitor, which i can only assume is to do with the fact its pushing more pixels than my built in lcd on the laptop.

the 10.8.2 update has improved things, but its still not like Lion.

its also a factor that when my GPU is on the intel one, the problem is at its worse.

for me the problem is completely gone when i have the dock on Auto-Hide, so it isn't visible while swiping.

Yes, it worked with facebook. When i put the dock in 2D, facebook scrolls much smoother!
 

0x000000

macrumors 6502
Aug 26, 2011
283
5
does the lagg decrease alot when you change your dock option to be on the left or right side of the screen (so it becomes a 2D Dock)

Yes, it worked with facebook. When i put the dock in 2D, facebook scrolls much smoother!

Stumbled upon this. If anyone wants to try it, this may help. Type this into terminal to get the 2D dock at the bottom of the screen:

defaults write com.apple.dock no-glass -boolean YES
killall Dock


dock_old_look.jpg


NO at the end restores it. Those who want to fiddle with the system, /Library/CoreServices/Finder.app -> show contents and then somewhere you'll find PNGs to customize your dock :)
 

Woodcrest64

macrumors 65816
Aug 14, 2006
1,310
526
Maybe I'm just not seeing it but I found with the latest update for Mountain Lion that most of the UI lag that I noticed originally is gone. I think Apple has done a terrific job of optimizing OSX for the Retina display. Obviously it will get better with future releases of the rMBP but as of right now my machine is running very well.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.