Personal hotspot is badly broken

[John Mcgregor]

So i have a new iPhone 6S Plus and a retina MacBook Pro, but when i try to use personal hotspots on my MacBook it just doesn't show up under wifi menu. I have to retry many times before it shows up.

Also when it shows up and i can connect it is then impossible to disconnect. It will reconnect again and again and again. The only way i found to disconnect is to flip the switch on the iPhone manually.

Now i have no idea if its iOS 9, OS X or problem in both. I'm running El Capitan.


It worked flawlessly on my iPhone 6 with iOS 8 and Yosemite.

 

[gordon1234]

I have almost the same setup - iPhone 6s, Retina MacBook Pro (2015), latest software on everything.

In my case, everything works perfectly - I tether every day, sometimes for hours, and I've never had any problems at all.

I'd suggest first trying to tether with another device or computer to see if the phone is the problem.

 

[jgelin]

I had the disconnect issue the other day at the cafe. I could not untether from my iPhone 6s+ from my MacBook Air. Had to turn off wifi for it to stop reconnecting.

 

[John Mcgregor]

I have almost the same setup - iPhone 6s, Retina MacBook Pro (2015), latest software on everything.

In my case, everything works perfectly - I tether every day, sometimes for hours, and I've never had any problems at all.

I'd suggest first trying to tether with another device or computer to see if the phone is the problem.

Sadly i gave my iPad Air to charity last week, so i have nothing to test this on.

 

[John Mcgregor]

This is super annoying.

 

[AndyK]

Do it via bluetooth if you're not trying to share the connection to a third party. I do this on a daily basis and it works great.

 

[John Mcgregor]

Do it via bluetooth if you're not trying to share the connection to a third party. I do this on a daily basis and it works great.

Doesn't work at all.

 

[John Mcgregor]

So my OCD took over again and i finally found the issue. As always it's wifi drivers. I found the driver from GM candidate, disabled system integrity protection and replaced the driver. Now i can see my iPhone under wifi almost instantly and it disconnects correctly and also personal hotspots get correctly disbaled on the iPhone as well. **** you, Apple.

 

[AndyK]

Pretty sure you're making an error. I was curious about this error and was doing some work at my folks home office and I managed to pair / hotspot my phone via bluetooth to their 3 Macs with no issues. I also turned on the wifi hotspot and they all detected it. The phone is a 6S.

It's extremely unusual that you would need to force a driver change like that. Which version of El Capitan & iOS are you running?

 

[John Mcgregor]

Pretty sure you're making an error. I was curious about this error and was doing some work at my folks home office and I managed to pair / hotspot my phone via bluetooth to their 3 Macs with no issues. I also turned on the wifi hotspot and they all detected it. The phone is a 6S.

It's extremely unusual that you would need to force a driver change like that. Which version of El Capitan & iOS are you running?

Latest.

 

[Stickharuhi]

So i have a new iPhone 6S Plus and a retina MacBook Pro, but when i try to use personal hotspots on my MacBook it just doesn't show up under wifi menu. I have to retry many times before it shows up.

Also when it shows up and i can connect it is then impossible to disconnect. It will reconnect again and again and again. The only way i found to disconnect is to flip the switch on the iPhone manually.

Now i have no idea if its iOS 9, OS X or problem in both. I'm running El Capitan.


It worked flawlessly on my iPhone 6 with iOS 8 and Yosemite.

Yes see my test here https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/iphone-6-and-ipad-air-2-personal-hotspot-miserable.1888510/. I report many bug report to apple bug report site. But no fixed.

But mostly (to 60%) iOS personal hotspot broken. Android 4-6 hotspot no issue. Or the jailbreak tweaks mywi.

I am not sure why, the iOS personal hotpot mostly broken. I think the code from the Apple developer very bad. Because I use many android device with other android version (4/5/6). All this android device no issue.
And the jailbreak tweaks mywi 9.0 (the jailbreak developer has better code and api). This is that issue in iOS, it give parts in iOS the not good. Here is good this iOS part as open Source, then the Community add better code.

 

[Stickharuhi]

Not forget: The hotspot (ad-hoc + internet sharing) from OSX is very good.

Again: Android hotspot,jailbreak tweaks mywi and OSX hotspot no issue. No broken.

iOS personal hotspot mostly (60%) broken. I test with iOS 7,8,9. Not fixed. Has you test with clean install without backup? Yes!!!

 

[John Mcgregor]

Not forget: The hotspot (ad-hoc + internet sharing) from OSX is very good.

Again: Android hotspot,jailbreak tweaks mywi and OSX hotspot no issue. No broken.

iOS personal hotspot mostly (60%) broken. I test with iOS 7,8,9. Not fixed. Has you test with clean install without backup? Yes!!!

If i setup it manually it works just fine, but i want it to work automatically without me flipping the switch.

 

[maxsix]

I've regularly experienced OS X and iOS wifi/personal hotspot problems. Apple is challenged, when it comes to wireless they're very weak. Sometimes it works other times it doesn't. Never a dull moment. It's a gamble like Las Vegas

 

[Stickharuhi]

I've regularly experienced OS X and iOS wifi/personal hotspot problems. Apple is challenged, when it comes to wireless they're very weak. Sometimes it works other times it doesn't. Never a dull moment. It's a gamble like Las Vegas

Yes correct. iOS personal hotspot is as in Las Vegas.

That issue is iOS use not the code from OSX ad-hoc. Therefore can you on iOS not create hotspot without celluar access. On OSX,Android and jailbreak tweak mywi no issue (to 100%). More as 50 test here.

My result is iOS personal hotspot to 60% broken.

 

[XTheLancerX]

Also experiencing issues, and I wish that personal hotspot was more feature packed. Like, I would love to be able to see *what* devices are connected not just how many, and also how much data each device that has connected has used. I have only used hotspot between iOS and iOS devices, but I do frequently run into issues where it says the password is incorrect even though it definitely is not, then it connects briefly and disconnects, connects again, disconnects again. All in very rapid succession. Then it just quits and doesn't connect again.

Sometimes switching between Wi-Fi and bluetooth works but you sometimes have to try each method multiple times before it finally cooperates. Instant Hotspot is also flaky.

 

[John Mcgregor]

Also experiencing issues, and I wish that personal hotspot was more feature packed. Like, I would love to be able to see *what* devices are connected not just how many, and also how much data each device that has connected has used. I have only used hotspot between iOS and iOS devices, but I do frequently run into issues where it says the password is incorrect even though it definitely is not, then it connects briefly and disconnects, connects again, disconnects again. All in very rapid succession. Then it just quits and doesn't connect again.

Sometimes switching between Wi-Fi and bluetooth works but you sometimes have to try each method multiple times before it finally cooperates. Instant Hotspot is also flaky.

For me it works much better in Yosemite.

 

[Stickharuhi]

Also experiencing issues, and I wish that personal hotspot was more feature packed. Like, I would love to be able to see *what* devices are connected not just how many, and also how much data each device that has connected has used. I have only used hotspot between iOS and iOS devices, but I do frequently run into issues where it says the password is incorrect even though it definitely is not, then it connects briefly and disconnects, connects again, disconnects again. All in very rapid succession. Then it just quits and doesn't connect again.

Sometimes switching between Wi-Fi and bluetooth works but you sometimes have to try each method multiple times before it finally cooperates. Instant Hotspot is also flaky.

Correct as in my test here. Sometimes is hotspot available or not. Then off,on,off,on not working. Now restart the device. With happiness then it works. Therefore in my test to 60% broken. OSX ad-hoc,Android hotspot,jailbreak tweaks mywi no issue.

Apple can not fixed, because in this category are the Apple developer very bad. Here is the community very good.
But Apple lock iOS or not allow jailbreak tweaks e.g mywi.

Why not allow jailbreak tweaks for normal iOS tasks? Because Apple hate undocumented API. The tweaks mywi is not open source(Apple can not check and add for their iOS system) , but has better code/api as Apple iOS personal hotspot.

How can fixed this issue?? When Apple not need help from the community.

Then please add OSX ad-hoc code!! And add then e.g as you say "more options" etc...

 

[maxsix]

It's rather suspicious that Apple cannot or will not fix this issue.

One minute Apple and is acting superior and charging high prices, the next they can't even get it to work as promised.

They're the only company that has a large contingent of customers that'll buy anything and make excuses for Apple when it fails to work right.

 

[C DM]

It's rather suspicious that Apple cannot or will not fix this issue.

One minute Apple and is acting superior and charging high prices, the next they can't even get it to work as promised.

They're the only company that has a large contingent of customers that'll buy anything and make excuses for Apple when it fails to work right.

Plenty of companies have followings and just regular customers and also have products and services that aren't perfect.

 

[JamesMB]

For me it works much better in Yosemite.

Yup....I downgraded my rMBP back to Yosemite, and no more problems. I should have read the reports in the OS X El Cap section of MacRumors, before I upgraded, but I just blindly upgraded. I won't make that mistake again...No more .0/day 1 OSX releases for me.

 

[AbSoluTc]

It's rather suspicious that Apple cannot or will not fix this issue.

One minute Apple and is acting superior and charging high prices, the next they can't even get it to work as promised.

They're the only company that has a large contingent of customers that'll buy anything and make excuses for Apple when it fails to work right.

Here it comes.

 

[maxsix]

Yup....I downgraded my rMBP back to Yosemite, and no more problems. I should have read the reports in the OS X El Cap section of MacRumors, before I upgraded, but I just blindly upgraded. I won't make that mistake again...No more .0/day 1 OSX releases for me.

The last three_major_ revs of OS X have suffered from inconsistent unacceptable personal hotspot performance, in fact Yosemite (clean install was horrible)

Yet the real underlying true factor is it works for some and not for others. It's this exact characteristic that Apple should have solved long ago. But with compliant tolerant customers, Apple has little reason to fix it.

 

[chekz0414]

I find it odd that you're having this issue, I have a Retina MBP Late 2013, and iPhone 6s Plus and no issues here.

 

[John Mcgregor]

I find it odd that you're having this issue, I have a Retina MBP Late 2013, and iPhone 6s Plus and no issues here.

Good for you.