Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Feel free to replace the CPU (you obviously know what you are talking about), and then come back to us when you have an unrelated problem and Apple refuses to fix it. :rolleyes:

Well, the example was rooted in truth. I did replace the HDD in my old MacBook Pro back in 07. And my battery did proceed to get shot in a bad Firmware update. And I did take it into a Genius Bar. And he did replace my battery under warranty.

Per you guys, did I just luck out because I certainly didn't try to hide the upgraded HDD from the Genius?
 
Well, the example was rooted in truth. I did replace the HDD in my old MacBook Pro back in 07. And my battery did proceed to get shot in a bad Firmware update. And I did take it into a Genius Bar. And he did replace my battery under warranty.

Per you guys, did I just luck out because I certainly didn't try to hide the upgraded HDD from the Genius?

No, you just got a Genius who isn't a stickler for the AppleCare terms. Most of them don't really care about minor things like HDD replacements even if they do void warranty, however a CPU swap is definitely over the threshold.
 
True, but even if you are careful, there's always that remote chance that something will go wrong, especially since it's not "user serviceable," if you will.

There's the remote chance something will go wrong even with user serviceable upgrades. see: Mac mini memory upgrade.

No, you just got a Genius who isn't a stickler for the AppleCare terms. Most of them don't really care about minor things like HDD replacements even if they do void warranty, however a CPU swap is definitely over the threshold.

So HDD replacements void the warranty but most Apple reps ignore it. Seems like a bad precedent to be setting if most of them do it.

Anyway... since the Quad-core iMacs are the first Intel Macs outside the Mac Pros to have socketed, non-soldered CPUs, I suppose we'll be finding out soon whether that really is a "threshold" for Applecare.
 
So HDD replacements void the warranty but most Apple reps ignore it. Seems like a bad precedent to be setting if most of them do it.

Anyway... since the Quad-core iMacs are the first Intel Macs outside the Mac Pros to have socketed, non-soldered CPUs, I suppose we'll be finding out soon whether that really is a "threshold" for Applecare.

the laptops never used to have a "user replaceable hdd" before. now it does :D so there goes that aspect. imac will be a good indicator
 
I like to read about people who think it's a big deal replacing parts inside computers^^
Don't put fingerprints everywhere, don't strip the screws and hair dryer trick for the warranty label or remove it while computer is still hot (label is not even special from looking at iFixit), done deal lol.
In case of problem repeat procedure and put original cpu back in.

Of course paying the the 200$ upgrade makes more sense, but who knows in a couple of years when the warranty is over^^
Don't think that upgrading from a i5 to i7 will change much though, unless you really really do cpu intensive stuff 24/7.
 
So HDD replacements void the warranty but most Apple reps ignore it. Seems like a bad precedent to be setting if most of them do it.

Anyway... since the Quad-core iMacs are the first Intel Macs outside the Mac Pros to have socketed, non-soldered CPUs, I suppose we'll be finding out soon whether that really is a "threshold" for Applecare.

I thought this at first too, but as it turns out Gugucom pointed out in another thread that they have in fact been socketed for a while now. The GPUs are still soldered on, but the CPUs have been replaceable on a majority of Intel iMacs.
 
Well they will void the warrent if you break something if you do upgrade the ram in the mini. If you dont break something and get it working your fine according to them.
 
Warranty

You're making it sound like some big deal when it's really a pretty simple upgrade for anyone who knows even the slightest about what they're doing.

And, the way you phrase it sounds like the entire warranty is being chucked out the window for replacing the CPU, which isn't true (at least in the US). Yeah... you're probably out of luck getting warranty service on the CPU, but if something happens to another component, I challenge Apple to prove that my swapping the CPU directly caused the SuperDrive to die, the Hard Drive to crash, or the LCD to fail.


Its actually in Apples Terms & conditions for the warranty within the warranty period the unit can only be opened by an Apple Authorized Service centre

Self repair voids the warranty and taking this unit to an Apple Service Centre after this has been done will be rejected for repair by them!!!!!
 
Self repair voids the warranty and taking this unit to an Apple Service Centre after this has been done will be rejected for repair by them!!!!!

Key word there. Upgrades are not repairs and the machines aren't sealed units.
 
Neither.

Its actually in Apples Terms & conditions of the warranty that a claim will be denied only if the user breaks something in the process.
 
The argument in this thread is completely uncalled for. The op apparently JUST ordered a new iMac - they probably haven't even shipped it to him yet, and some of you are actually suggesting he cracks the thing open to perform operation on it? I can't believe anyone is even having this discussion.

I like tinkering with computers just as much as the next guy, but there's no question that the only logical option is to return the computer or cancel the order and place another order for an i7.

I especially like the person in this thread that thinks a HDD replacement is even in the same ballpark as a CPU replacement, especially when it comes to Apple's warranty.
 
I like tinkering with computers just as much as the next guy, but there's no question that the only logical option is to return the computer or cancel the order and place another order for an i7.

Thats totally right. For $200 difference, I wouldn't even risk popping off the glass.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.