Having your screen not even with your bezel is like your door not being even with the other door when closed or your tail light stock out a little from the edge of the car to where water can get in. (in the iPhones case, dust)...
So yes, i would take my BRAND NEW Mercedes (kind of equivalent to the iPhone in comparison to other phones) back. Mercedes has been known for its high prices and good quality like Apple is also known for.
So yes to answer your question, yes i would want my car to be fixed to where it is like all the other cars on the lot that were made correctly.