Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Siri sucks, why?
- Thread starter bleomycin
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I'd say since the ios5.1 update, Siri's performance has decreased significantly. She fails to understand basic commands about 30% of the time.
I've recently asked her, "directions to <an address>" and she quickly showed me the map with directions. I then used Siri to "text my daughter", which she did without flaw then asked her to show me the directions again with the exact same wording and, I believe, inflection. Instead of the directions she began an email to someone in the contact list. ????
Now she often responds, 50% of the times asked, through the phone earpiece which is inaudible in the car. Sometimes she speaks through the speaker, sometimes through the earpiece. I can't determine what makes her do this? It happens when the phone is in 'Silent' mode or 'Audible'.
I am utterly frustrated. Clearly it is beta software at best. Amazing when it works correctly, but lately that's only half the time.
I've recently asked her, "directions to <an address>" and she quickly showed me the map with directions. I then used Siri to "text my daughter", which she did without flaw then asked her to show me the directions again with the exact same wording and, I believe, inflection. Instead of the directions she began an email to someone in the contact list. ????
Now she often responds, 50% of the times asked, through the phone earpiece which is inaudible in the car. Sometimes she speaks through the speaker, sometimes through the earpiece. I can't determine what makes her do this? It happens when the phone is in 'Silent' mode or 'Audible'.
I am utterly frustrated. Clearly it is beta software at best. Amazing when it works correctly, but lately that's only half the time.
I have two iPhone 4Ss. One of them is 5.1 and the other is 5.0.1 and jailbroken. I wish I had never "upgraded" the other one to 5.1, and there is no way to go back.
Siri on the Jaibroken 4S is FAR better than on 5.1. For one thing, you can get great Siri fixes that enable her to give things like sports scores and information, which for some reason the geeks in Cupertino refuse to allow regular Siri to do, along with many other tweeks.
Since 5.1, Siri is dumber than ever. Voice rec problems that never existed before have surfaced and when voice rec is not an issue, she doesn't understand commands that were not a problem before.
Once you get Apple out of the picture via Jailbreak, you can get Siri much close to what you want it to be.
Siri on the Jaibroken 4S is FAR better than on 5.1. For one thing, you can get great Siri fixes that enable her to give things like sports scores and information, which for some reason the geeks in Cupertino refuse to allow regular Siri to do, along with many other tweeks.
Since 5.1, Siri is dumber than ever. Voice rec problems that never existed before have surfaced and when voice rec is not an issue, she doesn't understand commands that were not a problem before.
Once you get Apple out of the picture via Jailbreak, you can get Siri much close to what you want it to be.
I agree that it Sucks
I have a UK accent I find Siri works better for me when i switch it to the UK mode. but i live in the USA and although the iPhone has a GPS knows where i am Siri is so dumb it tells me i have to be in the US to use the MAP feature!!!!!!!!! i find it does the same if i switch to the Australian recognition mode...
Well i am in the US? Just because i sound British does not mean i am in England. there are lots of us that live and or travel to the USA. So i guess apple is saying you can only search us maps when using a US Accent and while located in the USA.
Thats BS.
But after the upgrade to 5.1 it has become useless. I can say something like "Siri where is the closest Wallmart" ( Yes i am in US english mode and in the USA) and the dumb thing sais sorry i dont understand where is the closest wallmart.
Now i know it understood me as it repeated the exact question i asked it back to me it was just clueless as to what i was saying.
or another example is i say "send a text to my wife" and it sais it is calling a random contact from my address book. i have to grab the phone and stop it.
I say remind me to look up a price for air fair to England when i get home and it sais it does not understand me. I ask it again and again slowly and clearly until i just give up.
I have tried it without any earpiece with the one that comes with the phone. with a high end noise canceling blue tooth device. and with Apples blue tooth device none of them give better results. I have 5 phones and none of us are getting better results. and the rest of us are from the US so Accents are not the cause.
messed up with this one.
I have a UK accent I find Siri works better for me when i switch it to the UK mode. but i live in the USA and although the iPhone has a GPS knows where i am Siri is so dumb it tells me i have to be in the US to use the MAP feature!!!!!!!!! i find it does the same if i switch to the Australian recognition mode...
Well i am in the US? Just because i sound British does not mean i am in England. there are lots of us that live and or travel to the USA. So i guess apple is saying you can only search us maps when using a US Accent and while located in the USA.
Thats BS.
But after the upgrade to 5.1 it has become useless. I can say something like "Siri where is the closest Wallmart" ( Yes i am in US english mode and in the USA) and the dumb thing sais sorry i dont understand where is the closest wallmart.
Now i know it understood me as it repeated the exact question i asked it back to me it was just clueless as to what i was saying.
or another example is i say "send a text to my wife" and it sais it is calling a random contact from my address book. i have to grab the phone and stop it.
I say remind me to look up a price for air fair to England when i get home and it sais it does not understand me. I ask it again and again slowly and clearly until i just give up.
I have tried it without any earpiece with the one that comes with the phone. with a high end noise canceling blue tooth device. and with Apples blue tooth device none of them give better results. I have 5 phones and none of us are getting better results. and the rest of us are from the US so Accents are not the cause.
messed up with this one.Your problem is using an ear piece. Siri works fine through the iPhone microphone, through my BT headset or through my car, it barely works. The clarity of the input device makes all the difference.
I couldn't agree more - Siri is totally useless! Over and over I have tried to get an appropriate response but to no avail. I speak slowly and clearly but Siri continues to reply with senseless responses.
I hate to say this but I honestly think its because people don't know how to use it. I find it incredibly useful.
How are you asking it questions? I say things like this:
"Apartments in Harrisburg PA"
"Sushi restaurants nearby"
"Rental cars nearby"
etc. Its been flawless for me.
If thats the case then they shouldn't have advertised it the way they do on tv. You can do those same things with androids voice search and in my experience androids voice search is better transcribing the words you said accurately.
It works as advertised, I'm not sure what the problem is...
I can ask it the same stuff they do on the commercials if I want and it works just fine. It works better than any other voice recognition out there and returns much more relevant results.
Siri is how I found my new apartment when it wasn't on Google.
Siri typically works alright with me if there is no background noise, and I have a pretty heavy accent, which it has trouble with at times. It doesn't work hardly at all in my Car, but that's more because it runs through my Car phone system. Aside from that, the reason I don't use Siri is because it is completely useless on AT&T, 80% of the time I get a network error.
I rarely use it unless I'm bored and have extra time to repeat what I say to it. I have a deep voice tone and it almost always screws up simple words even when there's no ambient noise. As soon as I artificially raise the tone of my voice, the amount of errors drop.
I asked Siri "where is the nearest 7-11" and it continued to show "sorry, I don't understand where is the nearest sarin elephant"
I asked Siri "where is the nearest 7-11" and it continued to show "sorry, I don't understand where is the nearest sarin elephant"
I use Siri all the time and on the whole find it very useful. I very rarely type any more apart from when in public obviously as you can look a bit of a prat dictating everything.
Living in the UK, my only disappointment with Siri is the common grumble that prior to launch we were assured that there would be location aware searches from Q1 2012.
This hasn't happened and there have been no further announcements to my knowledge of a revised timescale. I accept that Siri is marketed as a beta product but this is still a disappointment, albeit fairly minor.
Overall Siri has saved me quite a bit of time by using it everyday.
Living in the UK, my only disappointment with Siri is the common grumble that prior to launch we were assured that there would be location aware searches from Q1 2012.
This hasn't happened and there have been no further announcements to my knowledge of a revised timescale. I accept that Siri is marketed as a beta product but this is still a disappointment, albeit fairly minor.
Overall Siri has saved me quite a bit of time by using it everyday.
Lol I don't use Siri much in public too !
I'm lucky enough to be jb and use the latest Siri tweak which allows me to ask Siri to find ATM 's and restaurants etc.
The only time I use Siri seems to be in my car. It works very well for me in the car. Just used it the other day to find the nearest ups store. Mostly I use it in the car to send or respond to text messages. This is done in my old car which is somewhat noisey. I should mention when I use Siri, I speak directly into the microphone at the bottom of my iPhone.
I haven't found myself using it in public but use it at home and in the car all the time. I typically only have problems using Siri in a specific area of my daily travels but I have found that although the phone says I have full bars the network never works in this spot, Internet won't connect and iMessage won't send.
Had iPhone 4S and Siri rarely worked. Now have iPhone 5 hoping that it would improve Siri...it's just as bad if not worse. Had a BB and it worked perfectly when calling contacts. My latest problem with Siri is when I say call a contact it shows the name on the screen but will take 30 seconds or more to call the number. I called Apple and they told me that my signal strength may be weak but just had the same problem with 5 bars!!! They also suggested a hard reset that didn't help either. I'm somewhat of a geek and know what I'm doing so I can truly say, and without reservation, that Siri really SUCKS big time. Very surprised and disappointed in Apple.
And yet to add balance , on my 4s with ios6 I get no lag whatsoever wether its a command to open an app, ring a contact or as a question.
Occasionally he will get a word wrong when I'm sending a text, but I think that's more down to my accent.
Siri is a dangerous distraction in the car.
Siri is fine for "directions to nearest... " and a few other simple things but at times it can be distracting to try to get Siri to understand some words (my accent is very neutral - I use the voice recognition with near 100% accuracy in Messages and Mail.)
At first a novelty but with experience Siri is very disappointing.
Siri is fine for "directions to nearest... " and a few other simple things but at times it can be distracting to try to get Siri to understand some words (my accent is very neutral - I use the voice recognition with near 100% accuracy in Messages and Mail.)
At first a novelty but with experience Siri is very disappointing.
I have a UK accent I find Siri works better for me when i switch it to the UK mode. but i live in the USA and although the iPhone has a GPS knows where i am Siri is so dumb it tells me i have to be in the US to use the MAP feature!!!!!!!!! i find it does the same if i switch to the Australian recognition mode...
Well i am in the US? Just because i sound British does not mean i am in England. there are lots of us that live and or travel to the USA. So i guess apple is saying you can only search us maps when using a US Accent and while located in the USA.
Thats BS.
But after the upgrade to 5.1 it has become useless. I can say something like "Siri where is the closest Wallmart" ( Yes i am in US english mode and in the USA) and the dumb thing sais sorry i dont understand where is the closest wallmart.
Now i know it understood me as it repeated the exact question i asked it back to me it was just clueless as to what i was saying.
or another example is i say "send a text to my wife" and it sais it is calling a random contact from my address book. i have to grab the phone and stop it.
I say remind me to look up a price for air fair to England when i get home and it sais it does not understand me. I ask it again and again slowly and clearly until i just give up.
I have tried it without any earpiece with the one that comes with the phone. with a high end noise canceling blue tooth device. and with Apples blue tooth device none of them give better results. I have 5 phones and none of us are getting better results. and the rest of us are from the US so Accents are not the cause.
tap the words it displays that it didn't get, then edit them to say what you said. That way it will learn over time.