Add me to the OCD crew. After reading the internetz the one seam bothered me so I went to Target this morning, picked up a pair, that one had an actual gap on the right AirPod, went back in and got another set and those are on point, so keeping them.
Now just need to return the first pair to Best Buy when they open. I did make a cash/gift card purchase there (it was the remaining balance on a gift card so the employee tossed it), so I'm assuming they will give me cash back as well as issue a new gift card for that same amount?
edit: best buy just issued a new gift card for the amount i previously had on the gift card and gave cash for the rest
glad i returned mine and got a perfect pair now that its done
no pic of my orignal right one but it more or left looked like op's pic, new ones look good:
if they dont look good, return em