While I hated to see that occur, it was the right way to finish the movie. I applaud the makers of Rogue One to have the guts to put that out there.And I was fairly surprised at the outcome of the story, to be honest. With Hollywood usually of the mindset of "let's see what happens and make more if needed", killing off the entire cast without even a hint of a possibility for a sequel is not something I would have expected from Disney.