Long story short, I was a previous iPhone 4S owner, got the Galaxy Nexus, and my GN crapped out on me (motherboard failure or something).
Now that I'm in need of a new phone, I'm considering going back to the 4S, but am honestly having a hard time accepting iOS' shortcomings now that I know how amazing ICS is. And iOS 6 really doesn't impress.
Google Play sells the GN for 399, where as the 4S is 649. It's literally paying more for a phone that can do less. Very difficult to reconcile and justify that.
I haven't committed to a decision yet, but I'm leaning toward getting another GN. Hopefully I won't get a lemon this time.
You didn't have insurance? What about the manufacturer warranty?
Oh and I love the tab 2 as well. Find myself using it more than my iPad