Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Stick or automatic?

  • Stick

    Votes: 86 68.8%
  • Automatic

    Votes: 39 31.2%

  • Total voters
    125
Stick.

I find it humorous when people complain about using a stick in heavy traffic. If you learn to not actually stop then you won't be using the clutch so much.

Also, the clutch in most cars these is is so light it's almost funny. The heavy-duty clutch in my Mustang feels like I'm stepping on a plum after I get out of my work truck. If your leg is tired after holding in the clutch through one red light then you'd probably be crying if you had to do the same in my KW :D

hey hey there I am one of those people who currently drive a stick since I learned how to drive 10 years ago and am more than likely go auto when I replace my car next year and one of them is the traffic I put up with daily.

It not that my leg is getting tired but more it just getting to the point that it is annoying. I do quite a few of the trick like using my gears to set my idle speed near that of traffic. But it is just dealing with the constant shifting. It more of the annoyance and inconveniences of it.
Will I miss it hell yeah I will. I love driving a stick shift and I will miss the connection with the car but I will have paddle shifters to help make up for it.

Also do not forget stick shift suck for dates because both hands are counstately tied up with the car. One to shift one to drive.

Lastly autos have gotten to the point where they remove most if not all the adatages manuals had on them. They can match to beat them in gas mileage. Faster off the line. A computer will time the shift perfectly and have less lag time in the shift. No human can match a computer.
 
hey hey there I am one of those people who currently drive a stick since I learned how to drive 10 years ago and am more than likely go auto when I replace my car next year and one of them is the traffic I put up with daily.

It not that my leg is getting tired but more it just getting to the point that it is annoying. I do quite a few of the trick like using my gears to set my idle speed near that of traffic. But it is just dealing with the constant shifting. It more of the annoyance and inconveniences of it.
Will I miss it hell yeah I will. I love driving a stick shift and I will miss the connection with the car but I will have paddle shifters to help make up for it.

Also do not forget stick shift suck for dates because both hands are counstately tied up with the car. One to shift one to drive.

Lastly autos have gotten to the point where they remove most if not all the adatages manuals had on them. They can match to beat them in gas mileage. Faster off the line. A computer will time the shift perfectly and have less lag time in the shift. No human can match a computer.

You've never been in a car with my parents, then. I swear to god, I can never feel them shift, they crawl along in traffic without a problem, and they start just as fast as anyone else without over revving it unnecessarily. I still think that humans can beat the machines, it just takes practice.
 
You've never been in a car with my parents, then. I swear to god, I can never feel them shift, they crawl along in traffic without a problem, and they start just as fast as anyone else without over revving it unnecessarily. I still think that humans can beat the machines, it just takes practice.

again humans are not as good as a computer since it will do it at the optimal point mix with how much power is being ask and gas mileage so it will match it exactly.

Like your parents I can and do shift where you are not going to feel it. It is not hard to do but still autos are getting to a point they are beating humans. Humans are not as fast or exact as computers. The techology for autos is getting cheaper, better and faster and like I said starting to get beyond what humans can match.
 
Stick, but like everyone says in traffic they suck. Also I live in a town with a bunch of 25mph and the older folks always liked to drive at like 22 which was right in between the gears of my car. :mad:

I'd so get a car that you can switch from auto to stick with ease.
 
Stick, but like everyone says in traffic they suck. Also I live in a town with a bunch of 25mph and the older folks always liked to drive at like 22 which was right in between the gears of my car. :mad:

I'd so get a car that you can switch from auto to stick with ease.

Well, you could just get a semi-automatic, but I know it's just not the same.
 
Since I don't drive yet I didn't answer the poll. This is my first car and it's a stick (3 speed to be exact) 351 Crate motor, my summer project :D
105quz6.jpg
 
Since I don't drive yet I didn't answer the poll. This is my first car and it's a stick (3 speed to be exact) 351 Crate motor, my summer project :D
<gigantic effing picture>

Might want to put some tIMG tags on that, boyo. Cool car, vintage! Must be weird to drive a 3 speed transmission though if you're used to anything else.
 
Like most people in Europe, I learned stick (on a hideous toyota Yaris car, fitted-would you believe it?!!-with standard cup holders on _both_ sides of the dash _and_ in the door frames. What sort of self-respecting car comes with standard cup holders? VISIBLE ones? and more than one of them??! lol

But, the family car is an automatic, which I hardly ever use so my driving skills haven't progressed much after I finished the lessons and got the permit (the wonders of great public transportation, lol). But my grandpa's big peugeot 403 monster (a 1964 car, _if_ you please ;)) is sitting in my gran's garage, and sometimes I wish I could have a go there--in spite of being barely able to drive as it is. Then again, I do regularly use a 1946 Leica rangefinder, so I guess I just like solid metal technology with pleasing mechanical noises :clunk:
:)
 
I have a stick shift, five speed Ford pick up truck. But the truck works on "automatic". I don't really have to think about shifting. After 30+ years of driving every day with a stick shift I just don't notice it. In traffic, hills and whatever, it is just not something I think about much. When driving my wife's automatic I find myself going for the clutch now and then by habit, feel dumb when the left foot hits the floor.
 
I couldn't read this whole thread because after seeing "stick" mentioned a few times I felt like my eyes were about to bleed.
I think the terms you yanks are looking for is Manual Vs. CVT Vs. Automatic gearbox. (No it's not a shifter either)

Cheers
 
Stick for driving for fun.

Auto when stuck in traffic.

My car is an Auto. They only make the standards in Europe
 
I couldn't read this whole thread because after seeing "stick" mentioned a few times I felt like my eyes were about to bleed.
I think the terms you yanks are looking for is Manual Vs. CVT Vs. Automatic gearbox. (No it's not a shifter either)

Cheers

What's with people getting all weird about other people calling it stick? It's just a nickname, I call it clutch half the time (though rarely manual). It's like by calling it stick, you're destroying the integrity the manual transmission. I don't get it.
 
Stick. I don't have my license yet (or permit for that matter) But I've driven enough to know that I don't really care for automatics too much. I always find myself bored if it's not a manual.

Here's hoping I can find a car with a manual for my first one...
 
I love to drive stick shifts.

Driven many vehicles with stick shifts including tandem dual farm trucks where you had to double clutch. Fun as hell with a heavy load on an old gravel road.

Having said this, automatics are convenient.

And for this kid, when I was in a leg cast for about 6 months, allowed me to drive where as with a stick I could not have driven. :)
 
I drive an automatic because the wife insisted. I hate it. It's cliche, but manual allows for so much more control. They are especially good for parking.
 
i prefer auto coz i can do more than if i would drive stick

like drinking my protein/bcaa shakes while driving to gym, or eating my breakfast while sitting in stop and go traffic on my way to work :rolleyes:

Isn't that Illegal ? Driving without Due care and attention? well it is here anyway.
 
i prefer auto coz i can do more than if i would drive stick

like drinking my protein/bcaa shakes while driving to gym, or eating my breakfast while sitting in stop and go traffic on my way to work :rolleyes:

Tell you the truth driving a manual really does not effect me in that way and I think any experienced manual drive would agree. I still can and do eat breakfast some times while driving to work in stop and go traffic hell I have driving to work with a coffee cup in my hand the entire time.

You need to remeber the car is set up for the gears to go 1-2-3-4... so all I do is push or pull the stick up and down and it slides into the correct gear. On the few times that I need a better grip I just switch hands real quickly and even then I can get to the correct gear with just my wrist.

Sum it up. your "excuse" is not really an excuse at all.
 
It's just what they're called over here. Just like they call it a bonnet in the UK and a hood over here.

I've learnt a lot today…

I've never heard the term "stick" before in my life :)
Also didn't know the US doesn't have amber lights :eek:

Is it illegal to use mobile phones in the US whilst driving? It is here.
 
Manual!

Traffic, hills -- doesn't matter. I'd always rather choose the gears myself.

My first drive in a manual car was because I went to a party with my roommates, and they both drank. So I had to drive their manual transmission car (a 1970s Celica) home, despite my total lack of inexperience. Somehow with their guidance, I made the trip without stalling.

My car is a Civic. 202,000 miles and 16 years on the original clutch. So far.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.