Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I dont understand what you’re asking me for. A source for what? To tell you that it’s good practice to keep computer OS’ up to date? A source to tell you that there are vulnerabilities in every software, particularly out of date software? A source to tell you that internet connected devices can be hacked? Do I honestly need to prove these facts with some kind of internet article?
If you do use older unpatched devices on the Internet, it’s a good idea to connect them to an IoT style network where each device is isolated on the network. This will help prevent unauthorized access to other devices on your network should the unpatched device be compromised. (Or any IoT device, as many are full of security flaws).
 
If you do use older unpatched devices on the Internet, it’s a good idea to connect them to an IoT style network where each device is isolated on the network. This will help prevent unauthorized access to other devices on your network should the unpatched device be compromised. (Or any IoT device, as many are full of security flaws).
That's kind of the point here though. Older devices MAY be connected to the internet. But, at least in my case, they are not being used to browse the internet, nor for financial transactions (banking) or to transmit personal details over the internet.

The advice is to be careful with out of date devices. And that's good advice. You are also giving good advice.

But if the primary app you're using on an old iPad is a recipe app or Spotify, or Pandora, etc, how is this really relevant?

The assumption is that people are taking these old devices out for serious transactions/sessions on the internet - with all their personal details on the device. And that just isn't the case.
 
That's kind of the point here though. Older devices MAY be connected to the internet. But, at least in my case, they are not being used to browse the internet, nor for financial transactions (banking) or to transmit personal details over the internet.

The advice is to be careful with out of date devices. And that's good advice. You are also giving good advice.

But if the primary app you're using on an old iPad is a recipe app or Spotify, or Pandora, etc, how is this really relevant?

The assumption is that people are taking these old devices out for serious transactions/sessions on the internet - with all their personal details on the device. And that just isn't the case.
It is possible to gain access to your network and therefore everything on it, if some insecure device on your network allows it - making it a moot point on what device you do your sensitive stuff.
Not saying it’s particularly likely, or anything - it just should be pointed out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iObama and rmadsen3
I still have the original iPad mini - works fine but trying to find some uses for it. It's running iOS 9.3.5.

But because it's still logged into my iCloud it's trying to download my photo library but it now exceeds the iPads paltry 32 GB of storage.
 
I dont understand what you’re asking me for. A source for what? To tell you that it’s good practice to keep computer OS’ up to date? A source to tell you that there are vulnerabilities in every software, particularly out of date software? A source to tell you that internet connected devices can be hacked? Do I honestly need to prove these facts with some kind of internet article?
You asserted that using unpatched Apple devices is a security risk, either on the device itself or “at risk via many other means”. I’m curious what compromises in the wild are being used on these unpatched, insecure devices.
 
I still have the original iPad mini - works fine but trying to find some uses for it. It's running iOS 9.3.5.

But because it's still logged into my iCloud it's trying to download my photo library but it now exceeds the iPads paltry 32 GB of storage.
You can turn off various parts of iCloud. Try turning off the photo library.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Basic75
You asserted that using unpatched Apple devices is a security risk, either on the device itself or “at risk via many other means”. I’m curious what compromises in the wild are being used on these unpatched, insecure devices.


As you asked for verification: Apple itself agrees with me:

Keeping your software up to date is one of the most important things you can do to maintain your Apple product's security
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rmadsen3
As you asked for verification: Apple itself agrees with me:


Aside from face value, what other reasons do you think Apple might agree with you? I can think of one…selling you a new device so you can stay updated. Tell the customer it's all about security, fear makes you buy to stay safe.

Apple told everyone that would listen for years that jailbreaking is bad. Yet, they changed their policy a few years back so that jailbreakers don't have to restore their devices to get service. A tacit acknowledgement that it was never about security, but control.

Apple says a lot of things. But people can't assume that everything they say or do is because they always put their customers first.
 
Last edited:
I've never met anyone in my entire life who threw away a working Apple device. I have, however, met many that collect broken ones, even activation locked ones.

I'd really like to know where this mythical Apple landfill is that I'm always hearing about because I know a lot of people who would go reclaim everything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ignatius345
You can surely just take it somewhere rather than relying on a pickup?

That doesn’t matter. If you’re connected and you have a non security updates os then you are at risk via many other means
Vulnerable to what? People are talking about repurposing these for Netflix. Should we be throwing out our TVs that haven't gotten updates, too?
 
I live in Phoenix, AZ, which is not a small city. The city offers ONE hazmat/electronics recycling pickup per year. You have to schedule it in advance, tell them specifically what you are recycling and make sure it's outside on the day of pickup. That's all fine. But one per year is ALL you get.
There's also a few places that will accept your stuff for free, you just have to drop them off there.

I've done it near 32nd St and Indian School a few times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
I've never met anyone in my entire life who threw away a working Apple device. I have, however, met many that collect broken ones, even activation locked ones.

I'd really like to know where this mythical Apple landfill is that I'm always hearing about because I know a lot of people who would go reclaim everything.
Yeah...don't most people re-sell or repurpose their apple devices? I've also never heard of anyone throwing away any Apple device that still works.
 
I’m spreading fud for suggesting you should keep your connected devices updated? I guess someone should tell Apple or any other OS maker that they needn’t worry anymore about security patches. Security is a myth and telling anyone otherwise is fud.
What security risks do you believe they're opening themselves up to?
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
I've never been able to buy a new iOS device without selling the old one to help pay for it.

Kudos to those of you even able to hold onto multiple versions of Apple devices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: winxmac
There's also a few places that will accept your stuff for free, you just have to drop them off there.

I've done it near 32nd St and Indian School a few times.
I'll have to make a plan for that then, thanks!

I'm out near Camelback Ranch, 107th Ave and Camelback - which is why I need to make a plan. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: IJustWannaTalk
My iPod touch 4th gen can no longer download from my Apple Mail (iCloud) account and going to the iCloud section in Settings gives a message about invalid or outdated security certificate.

It can only go up to iOS 6.1.6 so almost no apps can be installed and even those that can still be installed no longer work on iOS 6

I think it will no longer activate via Wi-Fi if I decide to Erase All Content and Settings.
 
I've never been able to buy a new iOS device without selling the old one to help pay for it.

Kudos to those of you even able to hold onto multiple versions of Apple devices.
There's a trick to it. You buy new, just not the most current device. For instance, in 2021 I got the 11 Pro Max new. That's when the 12PM was current and the 13PM was on the way.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: brilliantthings
I’m spreading fud for suggesting you should keep your connected devices updated? I guess someone should tell Apple or any other OS maker that they needn’t worry anymore about security patches. Security is a myth and telling anyone otherwise is fud.

while I didn't accuse of that myself

I was asking what people should take care about

so if you think there are legitimate concerns to take care about you might say what they are and how you suggest people go about taking care to mitigate them
 
I'll have to make a plan for that then, thanks!

I'm out near Camelback Ranch, 107th Ave and Camelback - which is why I need to make a plan. ;)
Nice! Same complex as Jewell's Bakery. Can't remember the name. Might be Thomas, now that I think about it. But definitely right next to Jewell's. Took my old iMacs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eyoungren
Hi Everyone,

Nothing special just a quick observation of mine.

I find it interesting how useful older iPads still are in spite of them being massively out of date. For example, in my kitchen I have an old iPad 3rd generation running version 9.3.5 of the iPad OS. The iPad lives in my kitchen in an Apple iPad Dock (Model A1381) with the audio out attached into my Apple iPod Hi-Fi speaker and the power to the wall to keep the iPad charged. This setup gets used every single day for streaming Pandora and other compatible audio apps to the speaker. I also have recipes stored on the iPad for cooking and I occasionally use it for reading materials I've stored on it from various places and sources. In other words this thing is great and extremely useful for me. The best part is I got the iPad and the iPad dock free when I found them discarded in a recycle bin. Shockingly the battery still also holds a great charge and I've never had any issue when I un-dock it for reading....the battery seems to just go and go. Anyways I really find it disturbing when I see article on all of the e-waste in the world and especially how it's dumped in developing parts of the world and it's really something to be able to usefully continue the life of my older "obsolete" electronics and not have to really compromise what I use them for for as long as possible.

Anyways, just my 2 cents about this subject.

Thanks everyone.

Good 2¢! I have donated an old iPad to a local animal adoption agency. And another, I use as a display for weather info from my Tempest Weather Station (https://tempestwx.com/station/171431/grid). Of course the other good thing to do is to buy a used unit instead of new one and, to just "live with" a mildly obsolete iPad.
 
Hi Everyone,

Nothing special just a quick observation of mine.

I find it interesting how useful older iPads still are in spite of them being massively out of date. For example, in my kitchen I have an old iPad 3rd generation running version 9.3.5 of the iPad OS. The iPad lives in my kitchen in an Apple iPad Dock (Model A1381) with the audio out attached into my Apple iPod Hi-Fi speaker and the power to the wall to keep the iPad charged. This setup gets used every single day for streaming Pandora and other compatible audio apps to the speaker. I also have recipes stored on the iPad for cooking and I occasionally use it for reading materials I've stored on it from various places and sources. In other words this thing is great and extremely useful for me. The best part is I got the iPad and the iPad dock free when I found them discarded in a recycle bin. Shockingly the battery still also holds a great charge and I've never had any issue when I un-dock it for reading....the battery seems to just go and go. Anyways I really find it disturbing when I see article on all of the e-waste in the world and especially how it's dumped in developing parts of the world and it's really something to be able to usefully continue the life of my older "obsolete" electronics and not have to really compromise what I use them for for as long as possible.

Anyways, just my 2 cents about this subject.

Thanks everyone.

:)
I use my first one in my separate art studio now. It's both my blue-tooth jukebox for a nice speaker and also access to synced photos in my Photos app that were loaded on the computer in my house. I have two stands that hold it in any position while I use it for photo reference while I paint. Handy when I need to use my fingers to enlarge one for a detail. And with wifi, I can order art supplies I'm running low on right on the spot. I let go of my Verizon connection with it because for those purposes I don't need it for any of that.
 
There's also a few places that will accept your stuff for free, you just have to drop them off there.
Has anyone mentioned in this thread that Apple Stores will take their old functional or non-functional devices back? I figure they probably stand the most chance of getting properly disassembled and recycled with Apple.

FWIW they're also doing a promotion right now where you get 10% off an accessory if you recycle something.
 
I've never met anyone in my entire life who threw away a working Apple device. I have, however, met many that collect broken ones, even activation locked ones.

I'd really like to know where this mythical Apple landfill is that I'm always hearing about because I know a lot of people who would go reclaim everything.

Well I know for a fact none of my 12 Apple devices are in a landfill. Because I still have all of them, and they all still work, to some degree. The oldest is my iPod running iOS 6.

Not too long ago one of the first circuit boards hand soldered and signed by Wozniak himself was sold for $250k, and it was still working.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: IJustWannaTalk
Vulnerable to what? People are talking about repurposing these for Netflix. Should we be throwing out our TVs that haven't gotten updates, too?
Well, Internet connected tv’s are also inherently dangerous when they’re not kept updated yes, all devices which are attached to the outside world via your network is an increased attack surface to you network. I’m sure most people here understand that, and take my advice as what it was, but it seems I’m wrong.
What security risks do you believe they're opening themselves up to?
It’s not me ‘believing’ something, it’s an actual fact that devices which no longer receive security updates are less secure. So if you feel you can live with whatever may come of that, then great. I was simply pointing it out.
while I didn't accuse of that myself

I was asking what people should take care about

so if you think there are legitimate concerns to take care about you might say what they are and how you suggest people go about taking care to mitigate them
I already said that there are legitimate concerns, and advised people to take care and attention if using an out of date device connected to the internet. I really dont need to offer any advice on top of that - people can judge for themselves. But it’s not something I have just made up. It’s extremely common knowledge to people that have something other than a cursory interest in tech, that connected devices have huge attack surfaces, and one must make sure they’re secure.

Aside from face value, what other reasons do you think Apple might agree with you? I can think of one…selling you a new device so you can stay updated. Tell the customer it's all about security, fear makes you buy to stay safe.

Apple told everyone that would listen for years that jailbreaking is bad. Yet, they changed their policy a few years back so that jailbreakers don't have to restore their devices to get service. A tacit acknowledgement that it was never about security, but control.

Apple says a lot of things. But people can't assume that everything they say or do is because they always put their customers first.
Yeah yeah. Gotcha. Thing is, I’m not saying it because Apple said it - some other poster kept telling me to offer a source, so I just found an Apple one considering we’re talking about an iPad. The simple and verifiable fact of the matter is that if you connect a device to the internet (Computer, NAS, iPad, tv, fridge) then its a gateway into you home network. If the OS of whatever device is no longer secure, then unless you mitigate it on your network by purposely isolating it, then its made your network (and everything you do on your network) less secure. Obviously plenty of people dont care, for some reason, but that doesn’t mean what I am saying is untrue.

This thread is about using older devices, which I also do, and great! I havent said I’m against it. All I said is that one must take care when using no longer updated devices if they’re to be connected to the internet. It was merely prudent to remind people of this fact.

I’m surprised at the lack of knowledge within the thread to be honest.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.