Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Tesla's Insane New Phone Is A Game Changer (RIP Apple)
- Thread starter iHorseHead
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Bear
One thing the internet cult of Tesla is in love with is the idea of wireless electricity, but I think they fundamentally misunderstand the issues associated with it, they just think “magical free electricity off of the air”. Some of the problems it has, though, are efficiency (you generally don’t lose that much power over wires, but nondirectional broadcasts [think radio stations or TV stations, which wireless power stations would most resemble] are subject to the inverse square law and would have to run at super high power outputs to provide adequate electricity for electrical urban lighting at modern levels of electrification, and that’s not getting into electrical uses of HVAC, consumer electronics, and industrial electronics, oh, and electric vehicles), RF safety, and energy sources (widespread use of wireless electricity would basically require nuclear or hydrocarbons, renewable energy would be an absolute non-starter). And, contrary to the cult of Tesla, said electricity would certainly be billed in some way. Generally, those places and applications where wireless power transfer get used today are point-to-point systems, where transmission losses can be minimized (due to the use of highly directional antennas and narrow antenna bandwidths), or near field systems (smart phone induction charging). This is part of the reason why wireless charging IS induction charging and why whole room wireless charging hasn’t become a thing (it’s subject to the same issues as far-field wireless power transmission, smart antenna arrays in both the power source and device to charge could address this, but that approach likely only allows for the phone to be charged while it’s relatively stationary).
Musk, well, I’ve never been particularly fond of him because he sets himself up as some sort of face of the free market while none or almost none of his business ventures are free market, per se (Tesla is dependent on government electric car purchase subsidies, SpaceX is dependent on government contracts, The Boring Company’s technology is mostly useful for large government public works projects [hence, more government contracts], PayPal might be the one exception, and he hasn’t been involved in it in years). Then things like the hype concerning hyperloop made me even less inclined to like him. And I think buying Twitter is just money down the drain, I doubt Twitter will ever be truly profitable. But, I think a lot of Internet geeks/nerds see something of themselves in Musk, given his social awkwardness and his involvement in commercialized science. (Plus, a lot of crypto fans like his positions on cryptocurrencies, fwiw, which probably motivates the largest chunk of his fandom today.) I think Musk is being genuine when he states his goal of fostering interplanetary travel, so I don’t think everything he does is for show, but there’s enough about him that I dislike that I occasionally have to hold my nose and agree with him when he’s actually right about something.
This phone seems like a dumb idea, to be honest. It’s the first time Musk will compete in a market relatively free of active government intervention, and he’ll have to justify its existence despite the iPhone (which is probably the best selling consumer luxury phone) and all the flagship Android headsets. And, for over 15 years now (even before the public unveiling of the iPhone), we’ve heard so many phones hyped up as iPhone killers, yet the iPhone remains. So I tend to be jaded when it comes to supposed iPhone killers. But I’m hard pressed to think of any advantage Tesla could have as a new entrant in the saturated smartphone market, besides deep integration with Tesla cars. Starlink does appear to be higher bandwidth, yet cheaper, than existing satellite phone technologies, but it’s still lower bandwidth and slower than mmWave 5G or top of the line WiFi, not to mention the latency issue inherent to satellite communications (even low earth orbit satellites have higher latency than the cell phone tower likely less than a mile away, likely less than 10 miles away in rural areas).
Bear in mind, I think the Internet’s obsession with Elon Musk is similar to its obsession with Nikola Tesla. Tesla was an early innovator of a lot of electrical technologies, but not everything he worked on would have been all that effective.
One thing the internet cult of Tesla is in love with is the idea of wireless electricity, but I think they fundamentally misunderstand the issues associated with it, they just think “magical free electricity off of the air”. Some of the problems it has, though, are efficiency (you generally don’t lose that much power over wires, but nondirectional broadcasts [think radio stations or TV stations, which wireless power stations would most resemble] are subject to the inverse square law and would have to run at super high power outputs to provide adequate electricity for electrical urban lighting at modern levels of electrification, and that’s not getting into electrical uses of HVAC, consumer electronics, and industrial electronics, oh, and electric vehicles), RF safety, and energy sources (widespread use of wireless electricity would basically require nuclear or hydrocarbons, renewable energy would be an absolute non-starter). And, contrary to the cult of Tesla, said electricity would certainly be billed in some way. Generally, those places and applications where wireless power transfer get used today are point-to-point systems, where transmission losses can be minimized (due to the use of highly directional antennas and narrow antenna bandwidths), or near field systems (smart phone induction charging). This is part of the reason why wireless charging IS induction charging and why whole room wireless charging hasn’t become a thing (it’s subject to the same issues as far-field wireless power transmission, smart antenna arrays in both the power source and device to charge could address this, but that approach likely only allows for the phone to be charged while it’s relatively stationary).
Musk, well, I’ve never been particularly fond of him because he sets himself up as some sort of face of the free market while none or almost none of his business ventures are free market, per se (Tesla is dependent on government electric car purchase subsidies, SpaceX is dependent on government contracts, The Boring Company’s technology is mostly useful for large government public works projects [hence, more government contracts], PayPal might be the one exception, and he hasn’t been involved in it in years). Then things like the hype concerning hyperloop made me even less inclined to like him. And I think buying Twitter is just money down the drain, I doubt Twitter will ever be truly profitable. But, I think a lot of Internet geeks/nerds see something of themselves in Musk, given his social awkwardness and his involvement in commercialized science. (Plus, a lot of crypto fans like his positions on cryptocurrencies, fwiw, which probably motivates the largest chunk of his fandom today.) I think Musk is being genuine when he states his goal of fostering interplanetary travel, so I don’t think everything he does is for show, but there’s enough about him that I dislike that I occasionally have to hold my nose and agree with him when he’s actually right about something.
This phone seems like a dumb idea, to be honest. It’s the first time Musk will compete in a market relatively free of active government intervention, and he’ll have to justify its existence despite the iPhone (which is probably the best selling consumer luxury phone) and all the flagship Android headsets. And, for over 15 years now (even before the public unveiling of the iPhone), we’ve heard so many phones hyped up as iPhone killers, yet the iPhone remains. So I tend to be jaded when it comes to supposed iPhone killers. But I’m hard pressed to think of any advantage Tesla could have as a new entrant in the saturated smartphone market, besides deep integration with Tesla cars. Starlink does appear to be higher bandwidth, yet cheaper, than existing satellite phone technologies, but it’s still lower bandwidth and slower than mmWave 5G or top of the line WiFi, not to mention the latency issue inherent to satellite communications (even low earth orbit satellites have higher latency than the cell phone tower likely less than a mile away, likely less than 10 miles away in rural areas).
The concept sure looks better than Apples tired rounded design.
Last edited:
I am struggling to figure out how you got to the "RIP Apple" part. I am not saying I will be an apple person for life, but as of now, I will take an iPhone X over that tesla phone, personally.
The “RIP Apple” came from the OP’s desire to increase the engagement on this post
It’s allllllll about engagement regardless of whether or not the assertion is based in truth five articles that can be summed up: Why I'm jealous of the most successful and richest (or 2nd or 3rd) human on planet earth
Elon Musk’s ex described ‘alpha’ behaviour ‘rendering her disposable’ in essay
WriterJustine Musk, 49, met the South African-born billionaire while they were both university students in Canadawww.independent.co.uk
'I Am the Alpha': Elon Musk Ex-Wife's Essay Resurfaces Amid Allegations
Justine Musk wrote in the 2010 essay for Marie Claire that Elon treated her like an employee he would threaten to "fire."www.newsweek.com
Elon Musk Accused Of Pushing, Verbally Abusing Senior Tesla Employee
A day after handing in his resignation from Tesla Inc., a senior leader returned to work last September to tie up loose ends and say goodbye to his colleagues. Word spread that the employee had resigned, leading Tesla Chief Executive Officer Elon Musk to accost the worker, swearing at him and...www.ndtv.com
Elon Musk ruthlessly cleaned house of any Tesla workers who disagreed or got in his way, a new book says
Elon Musk says he doesn't rage-fire people, but a new book on Tesla tells a different story, detailing moments when the CEO erupted at employees.www.businessinsider.com
Former Tesla executive: “Everyone in Tesla is in an abusive relationship with Elon.”
Elon Musk has never hidden the fact it isn't easy being a Tesla employee.qz.com
become insufferable = I hate his stupid face for not thinking exactly like meI'm happy he's making things happen that normally wouldn't get done via usual business channels (electric cars) and is innovating in the market. These were things that Steve Jobs did to shake things up and I respect that. But otherwise he's become insufferable.
Tesla's Insane New Phone Is A Game Changer (RIP Apple)
A new low for clickbaity thread headlines? Or just a new low for today?
Steve and bill are on another level.
Their companies literally changed the world (first with personal computers and then with smartphones). The lives of billions of people around the world are different thanks to them.
This musk guy just created a car company, wow. Not comparable.
What for? It takes up a lot of space.
If Tesla makes a phone the only thing that should happen is that they should be sued for anti trust for not allowing car play on teslas
You said you were contesting an earlier poster's descriptions of Elon's character, yet you won't accept it when people provide several pieces of evidence? Sounds like you're a bit more biased towards Elon then you think you are.
And when you look at the comments, Elon haters (who pretend half the country doesn’t exist), end up spending more time and energy typing about him then the Elon lovers themselves.
He is a responsible father who has not abandoned his children. That is pretty awesome in my book. 😎
Will never understand the defenders of Musky. He's not your friend, he doesn't think about you - rabid worship of a cult of personality will net you nothing from them.
Can't wait to see how easily the screen cracks on these; also, don't mind that CO2 the battery puts out, it'll be fine.
Can't wait to see how easily the screen cracks on these; also, don't mind that CO2 the battery puts out, it'll be fine.
I also like how Tesla is involved in the ‘seats’ sector within the auto industry - because… their cars… have seats in them?
Just saying there is a correlation between ‘newly minted’ Elon haters, and people who jump onto every media bandwagon.