Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

tornado99

macrumors 6502
Jul 28, 2013
454
445
The Pro Motion smoothness is unlike anything I've ever seen on a computer.

you do realise that "Pro Motion" is just FreeSync which has been on every cheap gaming monitor for the last 5 years. It's not even that useful on the desktop, more useful in games and movies.

seems some people can't separate Apple marketing from true innovation.
 

tornado99

macrumors 6502
Jul 28, 2013
454
445
Don't know why the angry faces. This is a quote from arstecnica who are very sharp on the technical aspects of OS X:

But luckily for the rest of us, the company implemented adaptive sync support in an un-Apple kind of way: by taking advantage of a widely available standard rather than doing its own thing.


Apple doesn't call Monterey's variable refresh rate implementation "FreeSync," but that's essentially what it is, and monitors marketed as having FreeSync support will support variable refresh rates when used with compatible Macs.


That's because FreeSync in its most basic form was incorporated into version 1.2a of the DisplayPort standard as an "optional feature" way back in 2014. Which means that anyone who wants to can incorporate adaptive sync support into their GPUs, monitors, and software without adding proprietary hardware or paying licensing fees. It's the main reason why FreeSync is nearly ubiquitous even in budget monitors and why Nvidia relented and added FreeSync support for its graphics cards a couple of years ago.

If I hook a 120Hz monitor up to Windows 10 I will also get that "smoothness". Also, on the desktop itself Monterey will just stick to the maximum refresh rate of your screen, so it's not even using ProMotion/Freesync there.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: the8thark

jmho

macrumors 6502a
Jun 11, 2021
502
996
Don't know why the angry faces. This is a quote from arstecnica who are very sharp on the technical aspects of OS X:

So everyone is essentially using the same open "adaptive sync" standard, but Apple calls it ProMotion in their marketing, AMD calls it FreeSync in their marketing, and nVIDIA calls it G-Sync in theirs.

Also the person you replied to said "Unlike anything I've seen" not "Unlike anything that exists" so I don't think they were claiming that ProMotion is better than FreeSync / GSync.
 
  • Like
Reactions: souko

jmho

macrumors 6502a
Jun 11, 2021
502
996
But what they are seeing is not ProMotion (FreeSync). It's just a 120Hz desktop.
From the arstecnica text you literally just posted:

"Apple doesn't call Monterey's variable refresh rate implementation "FreeSync," but that's essentially what it is, and monitors marketed as having FreeSync support will support variable refresh rates when used with compatible Macs."

But yes, it will run at 120 hz on the desktop because rendering a desktop takes less than 8.3 milliseconds.
 

tornado99

macrumors 6502
Jul 28, 2013
454
445
There seems to be a misunderstanding of what is ProMotion. It doesn't give you "smoothness". A 120Hz monitor with no variation in refresh rate is what gives you smoothness. ProMotion saves battery life by stepping down to synched 30Hz for videos, or alternatively you could choose to run your desktop at 60Hz, and then step up to 120Hz for gaming.

Another way of looking at it is a Mac Mini hooked up to a normal 60Hz monitor running Monterey won't be any smoother than Big Sur on the same monitor.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Pro Apple Silicon

tornado99

macrumors 6502
Jul 28, 2013
454
445
Sure, but that's not giving you the smoothness. It's the 120Hz display itself that does that. ProMotion is basically "energy-saving by stepping down the refresh rate when it's not needed". But doesn't sound as sexy when you describe it like that.

In fact, I imagine with your MBP plugged in, ProMotion would be disabled entirely.
 

joecomo

macrumors 6502a
Jul 10, 2010
933
1,174
Yes the display is incredible - for the first time ever, I am not sure whether my 5K LG Display or the built-in display is better for everyday usage
(should get the Apple 6K obviously :))
 

Pro Apple Silicon

Suspended
Original poster
Oct 1, 2021
361
426
you do realise that "Pro Motion" is just FreeSync which has been on every cheap gaming monitor for the last 5 years. It's not even that useful on the desktop, more useful in games and movies.

seems some people can't separate Apple marketing from true innovation.
Lol it is literally nothing even remotely close to FreeSync. Have had "FreeSync" displays for quite some time, thanks.
 

Pro Apple Silicon

Suspended
Original poster
Oct 1, 2021
361
426
There seems to be a misunderstanding of what is ProMotion. It doesn't give you "smoothness". A 120Hz monitor with no variation in refresh rate is what gives you smoothness. ProMotion saves battery life by stepping down to synched 30Hz for videos, or alternatively you could choose to run your desktop at 60Hz, and then step up to 120Hz for gaming.

Another way of looking at it is a Mac Mini hooked up to a normal 60Hz monitor running Monterey won't be any smoother than Big Sur on the same monitor.
There is no misunderstanding. But you seem to like to hear yourself talk.

ProMotion is what makes running a 120Hz display practical, especially on a laptop. Good luck finding another decent Mac display that is 4K@120 and can hit 218 PPI, or better.
 

tornado99

macrumors 6502
Jul 28, 2013
454
445
@Pro Apple Silicon From the OP:

"The Pro Motion smoothness is unlike anything I've ever seen on a computer."

Sorry, but that is a clear misunderstanding. ProMotion aka FreeSync does not make your desktop smooth any more than CPU idle states makes your desktop faster. A display that supports a higher framerate does.

And as for your "lol" I'll take the words of ArsTecnica over yours:
Apple doesn't call Monterey's variable refresh rate implementation "FreeSync," but that's essentially what it is
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: the8thark

Kpjoslee

macrumors 6502
Sep 11, 2007
417
269
It's hard to show the difference via an iPhone camera, but the new MacBook Pro screen is definitely better than my Pro Display XDR at HDR content imo. Especially if you look at the 3rd image you can see how the image is blooming into the borders on the Pro Display XDR, while the MBP screen's borders are still very black, and the contrast is just all around stronger.

View attachment 1882228 View attachment 1882229 View attachment 1882230

I couldn't capture darker scenes without the phone going into night mode and blurring everything, but on really dark space scenes black levels are incredible on the MacBook Pro.

Pro Display XDR has 576 local dimming zones while MacBook Pro's screen has over 10,000. Not surprising Macbook Pro's screen is showing better contrast.
 

Krevnik

macrumors 601
Sep 8, 2003
4,101
1,312
Sorry, but that is a clear misunderstanding. ProMotion aka FreeSync does not make your desktop smooth any more than CPU idle states makes your desktop faster. A display that supports a higher framerate does.

Apple is using the same branding for both features under a single umbrella. ProMotion is Adaptive Sync and the 120Hz max refresh rate. They like to harp on the battery savings that not having to drive the display at 120hz 100% of the time brings, but all 3 devices with ProMotion have both variable refresh and 120Hz max refresh (iPhone 13 Pro, iPad Pro, Mac Book Pro).

The nice thing about bundling them both is that you don't have to deal with resyncing the display signal, which means you can jump to whatever makes the most sense at the time, driven by the frame timings of your display engine at the low level (Metal, etc). Oh, a window is now moving? Ramp up the refresh rate. It's static? Drop the refresh rate back down.

It does get complicated as Apple does do some display sync fun with draw loops in apps that requires apps opt-in with the higher refresh rate, and hasn't adequately documented how to do it yet. I suspect someone was responsible for porting CADisplayLink and friends to macOS and didn't hit the right deadlines. :|
 

NdTonks

macrumors regular
Oct 25, 2021
107
156
Holy smokes! Just got my 16” unit. Absolutely amazing image! I’m still stunned people complain this is too hard to use as a portable laptop, it’s virtually identical in footprint and weight to my 2013 pro I’ve been carting around the world for the last 8 years or so! You won’t be disappointed with the 16.
 

Pro Apple Silicon

Suspended
Original poster
Oct 1, 2021
361
426
@Pro Apple Silicon From the OP:



Sorry, but that is a clear misunderstanding. ProMotion aka FreeSync does not make your desktop smooth any more than CPU idle states makes your desktop faster. A display that supports a higher framerate does.

And as for your "lol" I'll take the words of ArsTecnica over yours:
Stop selling FreeSync. AMD labels displays with 75 Hz refresh as FreeSync.

While ProMotion actually refers to the technology used to do variable refresh rate, it is synonymous with 120Hz displays at Apple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: souko and 3Rock

tornado99

macrumors 6502
Jul 28, 2013
454
445
Most FreeSync monitors are 144Hz, and have been available for years.

Of course, I would take OS X at any refresh rate over the ugly abomination that is Windows 10. It's great that Apple has implemented this, but let's not get carried away and pretend that Apple has revolutionised displays here.

It's possible to be an Apple fan without believing everything their marketing department puts out.
 

Pro Apple Silicon

Suspended
Original poster
Oct 1, 2021
361
426
Most FreeSync monitors are 144Hz, and have been available for years.

Of course, I would take OS X at any refresh rate over the ugly abomination that is Windows 10. It's great that Apple has implemented this, but let's not get carried away and pretend that Apple has revolutionised displays here.

It's possible to be an Apple fan without believing everything their marketing department puts out.
I really, really don't think you get it. FreeSync means NOTHING to me. I'm aware of it. Have been for a long, long time. I own FreeSync capable displays. Again, it means nothing to me. Because it's not showing me macOS, and certainly was not built in to my laptop.

Now that ProMotion is built into my laptop, it has revolutionized the experience of using a MacBook Pro with macOS, which is what actually matters.
 

TrueBlou

macrumors 601
Sep 16, 2014
4,531
3,619
Scotland
The display melted my optic nerves and the speakers ruptured my intestines.

I wondered why I’ve been running to the loo all day today, guess I’d better drop the volume a few notches :D

The display is astounding, absolutely loving it. Nothing that I’d read about it really prepared me for just what an improvement it is.

Also, what’s with everyone getting bent out of shape over people using the term ProMotion when they describe the smoothness of the display? It’s a marketing term to lump together variable refresh rates and the 120Hz max refresh rate.

Do we get all worked up because AMD uses Freesync to describe matching the display refresh rate to what is being pushed to the panel, when all it actually is, is a VRR? No, it’s a word, get over it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: souko and 3Rock

tornado99

macrumors 6502
Jul 28, 2013
454
445
Now that ProMotion is built into my laptop, it has revolutionized the experience of using a MacBook Pro with macOS, which is what actually matters.

I don't think there has ever been a point where I've wished my 60Hz OS X destop was less flickery. Apple built in double buffered windows into OS X from version 1.0, and that pretty much eliminates perceptible flickr.

You just sound like someone who soaks up Apple's marketing speek. If they brought out 240Hz in a few years time you'd say it revolutionises your experience too.

It's like those who claim that "High Res" audio is so much better, and yet >90% of people can't tell the difference in a blind test between 320 kbps mp3 and uncompressed audio.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.