There is no 'Devastating Review' in that video.
First, an Outright Lie - Dynamic Island is not a bust and THE REVIEWER SAYS THAT SPECIFICALLY!
For batteries, he's a heavy user and has 10% left at EOD, so I'm not worried about battery in my life. ESPECIALLY as he's 'been running iOS 17 BETA from the beginning'. He also notes he has well above 90% battery health left, too.
His review is for an iPhone14, comparing it to what he expects from an iPhone15. Your comments concerning all the issues and asserting the review shows somehow shows the iPhone15 is 'substandard' as an upgrade when YOU are actually in the market for an iPhone11 to iPhone15 upgrade is disingenuous.
Or, didn't you expect people to watch the video?
If heavier and clumsier is ALL you have to actually complain about, I can't see why people wouldn't want to upgrade the VASTLY better iPhone15 or Pro version when THEY ARE COMING FROM AN IPHONE11. Also, heavier and clumsier seem to be VERY personal issues, not a fault in the iPhone.
I'm talking from an iPhone Xr perspective, and there is really NOTHING that would keep me from updating unless the economy collapses, in which case WHAT ELSE DOES MATTER?
Let me explain, why I‘m calling it a bust. From the video:
- I hardly pay attention to it … except for one specific thing
- The reviewer says explicitly „I wouldn‘t call it a bust“ but than he explains why he is disappointed
- „DI has been ignored by this year“ - well maybe if the feature trickles down, we will see
Additionally you have to take into account, that the reviewer is a hardcore Apple fan and makes money by promoting Apple. He praised the new feature in the beginning, but it didn’t turn out as successful as he thought.
- So it is a feature that adds complexity
- There is no real benefit, at least at the moment
- This feature is ignored mostly
- Maybe we will see more functionality in iOS18?
From other reports it is expected that DI will vanish as soon as FaceId starts to work beneath the display. Also lots of users complain about the cutout in videos and claim that the notch wasn‘t as annoying.
So, yeah - you may call my claim over-emphasized. But is is a bust - from my point of view. Or you may call it lipstick on the pig.
And for the battery life, just read the forums - I won‘t go into detail here.
Long story short:
Exactly in the moment the reviewer tells you “I wouldn’t call it a bust” he does exactly this - he calls it a bust …