Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

What did you think of Samsung's presentation? (Multi-choice)

  • Awkward

    Votes: 26 42.6%
  • Hard to watch

    Votes: 20 32.8%
  • Horrible

    Votes: 14 23.0%
  • Average

    Votes: 4 6.6%
  • Informative

    Votes: 4 6.6%
  • Good

    Votes: 6 9.8%
  • Entertaining

    Votes: 10 16.4%
  • Better than Apple's keynotes

    Votes: 7 11.5%
  • Complete disaster

    Votes: 21 34.4%
  • What the **** just happened?

    Votes: 26 42.6%

  • Total voters
    61

cynics

macrumors G4
Jan 8, 2012
11,959
2,156
Ugh, I hated the presentation. Those women at the end just made me mad for some reason.

I would have rather watched some nerdy engineer talk about the features and how they work then all that noise. I had to fast forward through a lot of it.

S Health is something I think I would find very useful to track how far I walk throughout the day.
 

daveathall

macrumors 68020
Aug 6, 2010
2,379
1,410
North Yorkshire
IMHO, very few people can give a presentation as engaging as Steve Jobs, I think that Tim Cook has fell foul of the "hard act to follow" that was Steve. I am left wondering if Samsung picked up on this and have tried to do something different to sort of break the mould perhaps. While it was live I had half an eye on the cricket but found the presentation a bit cringe worthy, looking again later, it didn't look as bad. Still not brilliant, but after seeing Jobs in full flow, what is?

I agree with the above, the women were particularly annoying.
 

WhiteIphone5

macrumors 65816
May 27, 2011
1,182
2
Lima, Peru
Give them credit for trying something different. Unlike HTC and LG where they just stand there and talk. I miss how Steve jobs presented with the whole "one more thing". Tim Cook is boring :/.
I say the presentation was cheesy lol

The only reason I watch the apple videos is because of Johnny Ive :p
 
Last edited:

tech4all

macrumors 68040
Jun 13, 2004
3,399
489
NorCal
I liked how Samsung showed features of the S4 in real life situations rather than just telling you. Some of the scenes were a bit odd, in particular the last one. But it got the point across.
 

marc11

macrumors 68000
Mar 30, 2011
1,618
4
NY USA
I liked how Samsung showed features of the S4 in real life situations rather than just telling you. Some of the scenes were a bit odd, in particular the last one. But it got the point across.

Agreed. And the scenes weren't so far off from how many plays are; it was just a bit over scripted IMHO a bit stiff, but job done.
 

MRU

macrumors Penryn
Aug 23, 2005
25,370
8,952
a better place
I liked how Samsung showed features of the S4 in real life situations rather than just telling you. Some of the scenes were a bit odd, in particular the last one. But it got the point across.

Real life situations? So you live in a bizarre Disney parallel universe from the 1950's? ;)

----------

Agreed. And the scenes weren't so far off from how many plays are; i.

Oh god you really need to see some better plays or at least ask for your money back at the box office foyer :p
 

marc11

macrumors 68000
Mar 30, 2011
1,618
4
NY USA
Real life situations? So you live in a bizarre Disney parallel universe from the 1950's? ;)

----------



Oh god you really need to see some better plays or at least ask for your money back at the box office foyer :p

I said some plays. A play or skit with live actors is far from a movie and sometimes some plays and some actors seem over scripted and stiff. And the skits with the small and sparse sets are far different from a movie. Most people never see a play and expect it to be like a polished movie most are not. Some plays are top notch many more are not. Again they were skits not to tell a story in detail but to demonstrate a real life situation where you could use the phones features. Yes I can see myself in a situation where I could use a translator. Yes I can we myself taking pictures and wanting to put myself in them. Yes I can see myself not wanting to touch my phone to answer it. Yes I can see myself wanting a group video chat and screen sharing. So yes the skits worked.
 

MRU

macrumors Penryn
Aug 23, 2005
25,370
8,952
a better place
I said some plays.

. Yes I can see myself in a situation where I could use a translator. Yes I can we myself taking pictures and wanting to put myself in them. Yes I can see myself not wanting to touch my phone to answer it. Yes I can see myself wanting a group video chat and screen sharing. So yes the skits worked.

I was only being light hearted with you hence the :p



Also you could have seen that from a better produced video footage of real folks using the phone in those real situations...

You really didn't need to see that from some very racially stereotypical individuals prancing around the stage and some rather misogynistic portrait of women in particular, coupled with terrible scripted dialogue.

If anything for me - the skits detracted from the features of the phone they were trying to demonstrate as they were just so abhorrent to me.



http://news.cnet.com/8301-31322_3-57574466-256/samsung-gs4-launch-tone-deaf-and-shockingly-sexist/

Everyone is talking about Samsung’s much-anticipated Galaxy S4 launch at Radio City Music Hall in New York last night (March 14) — but not in a good way.

Bizarre, sexist, tasteless and embarrassing are just a few of the adjectives being bandied about following Samsung’s off-off-Broadway like presentation of a Smartphone the company has described as the ‘next big thing.’

All the hype, however, has left some wondering if the Smartphone maker put more effort into its advertising campaign than it did in producing its new device which seemed to be lost in an event full of corny skits, dancing children and obnoxious, stereotyped actors.

"If you're going to launch your biggest tech product ever...don't portray women as technologically illiterate," wrote CNN Money's Adrian Covert. "Yes, it's OK to acknowledge that there's a growing segment of smartphone users who happen to be female. It's not OK to suggest that the main reason they'd want Samsung's latest and greatest technology is to keep their nails dry and prevent their hair from getting messed up."

There was a lack of focus on product. Key features (eg: CPU) weren’t announced at all while the ones which actually did, were presented in a truly ambiguous fashion. It was all a big performance (tap dancing kid, really?)—only without substance. In certain parts it looked like the whole show was taken directly from the Jersey Shore series. Ouch.

It was cringeworthy. Sexist. Engorged with social stereotypes, bad humour and offbeat cues.

https://plus.google.com/app/basic/stream/z12wxvsaioetgjp0h22iiz3pjrnws3lle

http://hellobeautiful.com/2627980/samsung-galaxy-s-iv-launch-parodies-women/

The shlocky sketches at Samsung’s Galaxy S4 launch event, which featured women extolling the virtues of the phone’s gesture control because “my nails are drying,” made many of my colleagues do more than just cringe. Molly Wood of CNET wrote that the Radio City Music hall event “served up more ’50s-era stereotypes about women than I can count, and packaged them all as campy Broadway caricatures of the most, yes, offensive variety.”

Mobile Geeks’ Nicole Scott posted a video about the controversy, saying “they presented us with stereotype after stereotype, basically demeaning women” and the Atlantic’s Rebecca Greenfield wrote a story titled “Samsung Puts Women in Their Place During Galaxy S IV Launch.”

The video above is filled with cringe-worthy moments from start to finish. However, I think the “bachelorette” party skit was particularly horrifying.

Samsung really screwed up with its Galaxy S4 presentation. Whoever planned it should be fired.
So, here’s some rules.


First Your presentation should NEVER take away from the product.
Second Your presentation should NEVER alienate some of your customers (the presentation was extremely sexist and tone deaf and that’s not me saying that, it was Leo Laporte. I agree, BTW).
Third You should make it easy to understand the next features. Samsung made it hard to really get what’s new here.

On the one hand there is certainly laudable attempt Samsung to bring us the new features somehow playful detail. Makes sense, too basically because Specs boring grind down is just not abendfüllend. On the other hand, however, the implementation of this story. Sasha also has in his commentary up this topic:
Broadway disaster … full of sexist innuendo, which was discussed in the social media-intensive than the actual actor, namely the S4 …

I usually do not even give the “Frauenversteher” and even with the outcry debate has recently become me queasy in the stomach, but the representation of women from Samsung’s point of view last night was already suspected in one direction with Herman’schen dimensions .

If I have understood correctly as Samsung in the presentation, and the typical woman’s smartphone -Benutzerin just the cricket in colorful dresses, which – as the man deserves the coal, of course – to do a lot of great things is: Dealing with the other women with colorful dresses make, Nail polish, the gardener staring at the backside and sometimes liked one over the thirst.


Personally, I have it sometimes perceived as stereotypical, sexist and little modern image, which was drawn here. Maybe I understand the musical story about the Broadway not only correct but also – perhaps must be such that in the context of these shows an American ideal world is outlined in the Fifties, which is not much less creepy than the German folk music shows are where the sun, good spirits and heal the world on a mountain is mentioned.

Now I have somehow just talking about how this event has occurred to me, here is how it should rather be about how my dear and esteemed colleague Nicole Scott has seen the theater. If I already felt sick at times of the execution of the event, so Nicole has in the 50 minutes about a dozen times your jaw is dropped. She then made a curved front of the camera and even summarized in a few minutes what was your impression of the Galaxy S4 presentation.

We both agree that this is a great smartphone was sold entirely in value, simply because it has played a much too small a role in the whole event. Quite rightly, they questioned the logic of Samsungs, after you use a touch screen can not, if you have fingernails, where the nail polish is still wet. Tapping actually in South Korea with his fingernails? In addition, I was over the whole period the impression not go like trying to explain its features to a not quite clever toddler – even Nicole feels as rightly fooled. Unfortunately, Nicole express their displeasure only in English, but she speaks plainly and clearly so that even a zero-English as I understand, I am confident that I present you can also play this clip here. I would appreciate if you please leave us feedback with your impressions of the event. That you can do like it here in the comments, but I’m sure that Nicole and Feedback on the YouTube page would look.
 
Last edited:

cnev3

macrumors 6502
Sep 13, 2012
462
56
The commercials showing the kid peeking into the magical box from pulp fiction, knowing something magical was inside, waiting weeks for the unveiling, and then he finally takes the phone out of the box, and it looks nearly identical to the S3...anti-climatic is not a strong enough word to describe it.

I haven't seen anything so overhyped since Odd Future in 2010.

----------

EVERYBODY, WELCOME TO THE STAGE....MR. JK SHIN!

*Orchestra score builds dramatically*

"err herro everybody!". *pauses for nonexistant applause*

umm who the hell is JK Shin?
 

maxosx

macrumors 68020
Dec 13, 2012
2,385
1
Southern California
I view all presentations, keynotes, et al, as informative. I don't attend to be entertained. Some are simply a bit more well done than others. Once it's over I see no reason to rehash it.
 

tjl3

macrumors 6502a
Mar 8, 2012
595
4
Tossing in my 2 cents, Will Chase was annoying. I didn't even know who the guy was until 2 seconds ago when I Googled "GS4 event host." What felt the most 'unprofessional' for an unveiling of their flagship device was every time he would interject during Ryan Bidan's unveiling of various specs. It was kind of just a mockery of the device.
 

Mrg02d

macrumors 65816
Jan 27, 2012
1,102
2
You could give your poll some kind of order, from bad to good or the other way round. But as it is, it's quite hard to interpret. First it says Awkward, Hard to watch, and Horrible, then follow some positive adjectives like good and entertaining and then it says Complete disaster ans WTF just happened?.

Really, bring some kind of order in there, so one can actually interpret the poll without being some sort of super brain :)

edit:

well, alright, it's bad at the top and bottom of the list, but still...

Your'e reading it wrong.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.