Have you seen it in person?
After years of silver and space grey, I sprung a year and a half ago for the Starlight. I had seen the photos — some of which made it look silver — others made it look a garish gold. I visited a local store and discovered it wasn't a garish gold at all, but a subdued almost grayish gold and the color varied greatly depending on the light — daylight, incandescent, LED, etc. it even looks silver in many conditions.
N.B. Under those harsh fluorescent lights in computer stores, it's hard to tell the actual color it will appear at home!
We were surprised at how much we like the color…
Yes. It is really nice - just not for me. I'm just all in with the Silver/Grey aesthetic with 2 x Apple studio display, Caldigit dock - Steel/Glass office desk etc. The 'off-silver' hues of Starlight and Sky Blue offer pops of color that don't go with my home/office.