Okay. I am awake and ready to go. First, the usual caveat – I am an amateur and I make it up as I go along. All of the opinions are strictly my own. MR bears no responsibility for my thoughts, lapses in artistic judgment, nor spelling errors. Some might disagree with my comments, but that is part of this process. Be assured I offer them in a spirit of good will.
Judging this was rather easy because no one sent any bribes. Therefore, you all get 1st place.
My work here is done.
Actually, as usual, judging was hard. Here we go:
@AllergyDoc – I do not get frustration from this image. To the contrary, I get eager anticipation when I see the concentration on the faces of the family members. The orange shirt immediately caught my eye and I had to intentionally break away from that to look at the rest of the image.
@gaswerks – I generally do not like posed images for this challenge. There’s no particular reason for that. It’s just the way I am. Having said that, I think this is one of the best portraits I’ve seen in a long time. You have captured the frustration beautifully. The monochromatic treatment allows my eye to go to the two faces without any distraction. The shared postures of the two men create a connection that is immediately broken when looking at their faces. The man to our right is clearly frustrated an/or bored and/or annoyed and/or agitated and/or …….. The smirk on the face of the photographer (you?) tells us about his ill-spirited intentionality and elevates the tension in this image. My only complaint about this image is that the bottom of the mirror’s frame cuts off the feet in an awkward way. I will not deduct points because that is not something you can control.
@StrollerEd – What a sad state of affairs. I love how the scarf and carrot give pops of color in a scene that is otherwise very drab. It can be very frustrating to spend the time it takes to build a snow person just to see it melt into nothing. I image the snow person is not very happy about it either. That the arms are still pointing upward adds a bit of comic relief. It is almost as if the snow person is throwing up its arms in exasperation or surrender or a finally yell for help.
@Dockland – I can see possibilities for frustration but I’m not quite sure what is going on here. There is a shadow inside the leaf in front of the bird. Is that a morsel that is just beyond its reach? Is the frustration yours and how hard it is to get a good BIF image? It’s hard for me to comment when I don’t know what I’m looking at.
@Buck987 – What a sad looking tree! We have a nice sunny day with a perfect tree behind. The tree in front looks like it’s been windblown for a long time and then just could not hold up. This one touches on my own frustration on account of some of my trees being damaged during the storms we had this winter.
@oblomow – Every parent in the world can relate to this. Mine are all out of the house, but I still remember those moments of interminable frustration. The framing of this is simple and well executed. I would have liked to see you lighten the shadows or bring up the tones a little to give the image a little more life.
@mollyc – There is no mistaking your son’s frustration/emotional pain. His face is a little washed out which makes my eye go to that very sad frown. My kids used to joke that they never knew what my father looked like because he was always behind the camera. I wonder what your son was thinking when you were shooting this.
After careful consideration and a good cup of coffee:
3rd goes to
@Buck987
2nd goes to
@mollyc
1st goes to
@gaswerks