Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRy

macrumors 601
Apr 2, 2004
4,351
6,278
England
21346083443_3ccdbf2520_h.jpg
 

monokakata

macrumors 68020
Original poster
May 8, 2008
2,063
605
Ithaca, NY
It's not quite 7 AM in Hilo. on 2 January 2016. I'd like the contest to run all day here (here).

I'll announce the results either late this evening (my time) or early tomorrow morning (the 3rd) my time.

I'm going to seem very late to you photographers over near the Prime Meridian.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kenoh and AlexH

monokakata

macrumors 68020
Original poster
May 8, 2008
2,063
605
Ithaca, NY
Here are my comments. You UK photographers seemed to like this contest. Surprise!

@glenthompson: Great moody sky, and I liked the foreground’s straight line.

@anotherscotsman: Fine tonal range, and I especially liked the way the first light is blown out, and the others are not. Counter-intuitively, the closer lights are more indistinct.

@Miltz: the subtle colors with white fog worked very well for me. The tree branches with the odd leaf remaining are perfect, as is the single figure.

@Alexander.Of.Oz: great use of color, and the light on the slope is very nice.

@someoldguy: reflections can be tricky, but here they are effective.

@kenoh: the subtle colors on the trunks out in the water add a lot, and I liked the shadows in the foreground as well.

@The Bad Guy: this is The Bad Rain, well-rendered. This is a picture I don’t want to be in, and I admire its style.

@AlexH: very nice work, but as in The Bad Guy’s rain image, this is a road I’d rather not be on. You caught that very nicely.

@pmxperience: I very much like the straight lines and geometry here, and that the wharf simply disappears. Featureless sky.

@oblomow: the blue-green bag is a nice little surprise among the earth tones.

@stillcrazyman: certainly a crazy tree and, like glenthompson’s, a nice straight line to set it off.

@E3BK: something’s getting ready to happen here – nice capture.

@butch10x: I particularly like the striated clouds setting off the rounded, puffy clouds. And, of course, the top of the bridge and the city.

@Indydenny: you nailed that pre- or post-storm yellowish light.

@mfldmike: is there a little ice with that rain? The golden light goes well with the blues.

@Hughmac: I can almost feel the trees dripping on me.

@applefanboy: the sun is nicely captured, and the glow behind the trees is very nice. The ducks are a bonus.

@MacRy: the image in the drops is well-done, as is the color gradation.


Well. This wasn’t easy for me. There were a good half-dozen that I liked very much.

In the end, though:

3rd: anotherscotsman

2nd: pmxperience

1st: Miltz


Honorable Mentions go to Alexander.Of.Oz, someoldguy, and stillcrazyman.

For the “I don’t want to be in this picture” award (my category), it’s a tie between The Bad Guy and AlexH, with maybe a little edge to The Bad Guy's urban slant.

Thank you to everyone who entered.

So, Miltz, you get to choose the next contest -- you have 48 hours. There are stickies that will tell you the routine.
 

kenoh

macrumors 604
Jul 18, 2008
6,507
10,850
Glasgow, UK
Here are my comments. You UK photographers seemed to like this contest. Surprise!

@glenthompson: Great moody sky, and I liked the foreground’s straight line.

@anotherscotsman: Fine tonal range, and I especially liked the way the first light is blown out, and the others are not. Counter-intuitively, the closer lights are more indistinct.

@Miltz: the subtle colors with white fog worked very well for me. The tree branches with the odd leaf remaining are perfect, as is the single figure.

@Alexander.Of.Oz: great use of color, and the light on the slope is very nice.

@someoldguy: reflections can be tricky, but here they are effective.

@kenoh: the subtle colors on the trunks out in the water add a lot, and I liked the shadows in the foreground as well.

@The Bad Guy: this is The Bad Rain, well-rendered. This is a picture I don’t want to be in, and I admire its style.

@AlexH: very nice work, but as in The Bad Guy’s rain image, this is a road I’d rather not be on. You caught that very nicely.

@pmxperience: I very much like the straight lines and geometry here, and that the wharf simply disappears. Featureless sky.

@oblomow: the blue-green bag is a nice little surprise among the earth tones.

@stillcrazyman: certainly a crazy tree and, like glenthompson’s, a nice straight line to set it off.

@E3BK: something’s getting ready to happen here – nice capture.

@butch10x: I particularly like the striated clouds setting off the rounded, puffy clouds. And, of course, the top of the bridge and the city.

@Indydenny: you nailed that pre- or post-storm yellowish light.

@mfldmike: is there a little ice with that rain? The golden light goes well with the blues.

@Hughmac: I can almost feel the trees dripping on me.

@applefanboy: the sun is nicely captured, and the glow behind the trees is very nice. The ducks are a bonus.

@MacRy: the image in the drops is well-done, as is the color gradation.


Well. This wasn’t easy for me. There were a good half-dozen that I liked very much.

In the end, though:

3rd: anotherscotsman

2nd: pmxperience

1st: Miltz


Honorable Mentions go to Alexander.Of.Oz, someoldguy, and stillcrazyman.

For the “I don’t want to be in this picture” award (my category), it’s a tie between The Bad Guy and AlexH, with maybe a little edge to The Bad Guy's urban slant.

Thank you to everyone who entered.

So, Miltz, you get to choose the next contest -- you have 48 hours. There are stickies that will tell you the routine.


Great judging. Thanks.

Well done guys some absolute belters this week...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

anotherscotsman

macrumors 68020
Aug 2, 2014
2,369
16,735
UK
Here are my comments. You UK photographers seemed to like this contest. Surprise!

@glenthompson: Great moody sky, and I liked the foreground’s straight line.

@anotherscotsman: Fine tonal range, and I especially liked the way the first light is blown out, and the others are not. Counter-intuitively, the closer lights are more indistinct.

@Miltz: the subtle colors with white fog worked very well for me. The tree branches with the odd leaf remaining are perfect, as is the single figure.

@Alexander.Of.Oz: great use of color, and the light on the slope is very nice.

@someoldguy: reflections can be tricky, but here they are effective.

@kenoh: the subtle colors on the trunks out in the water add a lot, and I liked the shadows in the foreground as well.

@The Bad Guy: this is The Bad Rain, well-rendered. This is a picture I don’t want to be in, and I admire its style.

@AlexH: very nice work, but as in The Bad Guy’s rain image, this is a road I’d rather not be on. You caught that very nicely.

@pmxperience: I very much like the straight lines and geometry here, and that the wharf simply disappears. Featureless sky.

@oblomow: the blue-green bag is a nice little surprise among the earth tones.

@stillcrazyman: certainly a crazy tree and, like glenthompson’s, a nice straight line to set it off.

@E3BK: something’s getting ready to happen here – nice capture.

@butch10x: I particularly like the striated clouds setting off the rounded, puffy clouds. And, of course, the top of the bridge and the city.

@Indydenny: you nailed that pre- or post-storm yellowish light.

@mfldmike: is there a little ice with that rain? The golden light goes well with the blues.

@Hughmac: I can almost feel the trees dripping on me.

@applefanboy: the sun is nicely captured, and the glow behind the trees is very nice. The ducks are a bonus.

@MacRy: the image in the drops is well-done, as is the color gradation.


Well. This wasn’t easy for me. There were a good half-dozen that I liked very much.

In the end, though:

3rd: anotherscotsman

2nd: pmxperience

1st: Miltz


Honorable Mentions go to Alexander.Of.Oz, someoldguy, and stillcrazyman.

For the “I don’t want to be in this picture” award (my category), it’s a tie between The Bad Guy and AlexH, with maybe a little edge to The Bad Guy's urban slant.

Thank you to everyone who entered.

So, Miltz, you get to choose the next contest -- you have 48 hours. There are stickies that will tell you the routine.

Thanks for the great feedback monokakata and thanks for the podium placement - a surprise given the quality of all of the entries. For what it's worth, I was particularly taken by the @The Bad Guy shot even if it didn't have people as the focus!

Cheers and congratulations to Miltz.
 

tomnavratil

macrumors 6502a
Oct 2, 2013
876
1,588
Well done everyone, a lot of great photos! :) I haven't been able to post for a while due to work commitments lately unfortunately, but will try my best in the next ones!
 
  • Like
Reactions: kenoh

someoldguy

macrumors 68030
Aug 2, 2009
2,807
13,993
usa
Congrats MILTZ . And many thanks to MONOKAKATA for taking the time to provide individual commentary for each entry !
 
  • Like
Reactions: oblomow

pmxperience

macrumors regular
Aug 12, 2011
241
456
United States
Here are my comments. You UK photographers seemed to like this contest. Surprise!

@glenthompson: Great moody sky, and I liked the foreground’s straight line.

@anotherscotsman: Fine tonal range, and I especially liked the way the first light is blown out, and the others are not. Counter-intuitively, the closer lights are more indistinct.

@Miltz: the subtle colors with white fog worked very well for me. The tree branches with the odd leaf remaining are perfect, as is the single figure.

@Alexander.Of.Oz: great use of color, and the light on the slope is very nice.

@someoldguy: reflections can be tricky, but here they are effective.

@kenoh: the subtle colors on the trunks out in the water add a lot, and I liked the shadows in the foreground as well.

@The Bad Guy: this is The Bad Rain, well-rendered. This is a picture I don’t want to be in, and I admire its style.

@AlexH: very nice work, but as in The Bad Guy’s rain image, this is a road I’d rather not be on. You caught that very nicely.

@pmxperience: I very much like the straight lines and geometry here, and that the wharf simply disappears. Featureless sky.

@oblomow: the blue-green bag is a nice little surprise among the earth tones.

@stillcrazyman: certainly a crazy tree and, like glenthompson’s, a nice straight line to set it off.

@E3BK: something’s getting ready to happen here – nice capture.

@butch10x: I particularly like the striated clouds setting off the rounded, puffy clouds. And, of course, the top of the bridge and the city.

@Indydenny: you nailed that pre- or post-storm yellowish light.

@mfldmike: is there a little ice with that rain? The golden light goes well with the blues.

@Hughmac: I can almost feel the trees dripping on me.

@applefanboy: the sun is nicely captured, and the glow behind the trees is very nice. The ducks are a bonus.

@MacRy: the image in the drops is well-done, as is the color gradation.


Well. This wasn’t easy for me. There were a good half-dozen that I liked very much.

In the end, though:

3rd: anotherscotsman

2nd: pmxperience

1st: Miltz


Honorable Mentions go to Alexander.Of.Oz, someoldguy, and stillcrazyman.

For the “I don’t want to be in this picture” award (my category), it’s a tie between The Bad Guy and AlexH, with maybe a little edge to The Bad Guy's urban slant.

Thank you to everyone who entered.

So, Miltz, you get to choose the next contest -- you have 48 hours. There are stickies that will tell you the routine.

wow I never thought I'd ever place in this thread. You are all such awesome photogs, I've learned a lot from you all. Thanks so much to @monokakata for the great judging and kind words.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,198
47,581
In a coffee shop.
Great contest, and yes, @monokakata it did seem to strike a familiar note for those of us in these wet windswept and storm tossed isles at the north west of Europe. Generous judging and many thanks for the thoughtful feedback, @monokakata.

For obvious reasons, I really liked the contest this week - this is a climate and a look that I can relate to, and some of the shots were terrific.

Loved the chilling fog by @anotherscotsman - I have been out in these sort of bleak, cold and damp fogs; and @Miltz's bleak fog was a deserving winner, not a trace of welcoming warmth anywhere. Others that appealed to me included @Apple fanboy's moody lake, and @Hughmac's dripping night leaves, and the threatening sky submitted by @Indydenny. And the really gloomy and atmospheric piece submitted by @someoldguy was great, too. As was @AlexH's challenging road - not at all nice to navigate and negotiate.

Once again, an excellent contest with some terrific entries.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AlexH

Alexander.Of.Oz

macrumors 68040
Oct 29, 2013
3,200
12,501
Thanks @Monokatata for the critiques and the mention. Some very worthy winners this week and a high level across the board really. Congrats @Miltz !
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.