Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

oblomow

macrumors 601
Original poster
Apr 14, 2005
4,508
18,899
Netherlands
Here is my verdict. Remember it's the personal opinion of an amateur, so don't take it too serious.

@gaswerks I like how they are skating into the image. The photo looks timeless. I can't tell whether you shot it this year or 100 years ago (apart from the clothing and skates of course). Skating like this requires true mastery.

@deep diver You really followed this weeks theme. In multiple dimensions. Lovely image

@akash.nu I like your interpretation of the theme. I have difficulty judging this type of photography: is it streetphotography or a snapshot. That is something that I have to work on.

@mollyc Now that's a true master. Maori? Beautiful. Athough I would like to see his whole head

@tizeye Ah! The conductor. A fast moving species. Hard to shoot. But definitely a master at his game.

@Somepix This made me smile. You nailed it.

@Darmok N Jalad I like how this master managed to capture the mothers gaze at the son. I am not fond of the lighting, but I guess that wasn't under your control.

@triptolemus Another wood master. Lovely. I would like the a tighter crop, or longer focal length, of the master.

@inkmich The image had me puzzled when I opened it on the telephone. I understand that it's hard to get the right shot when you're in the audience. The angle works but the shiny floor is distracting.

@someoldguy First place for you! That'll teach you slipping it in after closing. :) No, sorry. What's his mastery? Fishing of selling? I would like to see some cropping or editing to remove the distracting elements.


3rd place: somepix. Your image made me smile
2nd place: mollyc and deep diver
1st place: gaswerks. Your image made me come back to look.
 
Last edited:

mollyc

macrumors G3
Aug 18, 2016
8,065
50,756
Excellent judging! Thanks for the mention. :) my photo was taken at the old International Market at Oahu, Hawaii. It is long gone none now, rebuilt to a mall. :( We had him carve our kids’ names on the bottom of a carved turtle and it now lives in our living room bookcase.

Congrats to @gaswerks. :)
 

someoldguy

macrumors 68030
Aug 2, 2009
2,806
13,993
usa
Congrats to all . The guy in my pic certainly wasn't selling fish , but along with the 2 others in the canoe , sure was good at catching them . Don't know if I would have been too happy in that canoe seeing the lack of freeboard , but they didn't seem to care . Taken in Belize a few years back .
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
56,996
56,021
Behind the Lens, UK
Excellent capture and processing. Well deserved winner.
[doublepost=1567799289][/doublepost]
This photo makes me uneasy. I just keep thinking, one slip and his feet are going to hurt!
[doublepost=1567799370][/doublepost]
Here is my verdict. Remember it's the personal opinion of an amateur, so don't take it too serious.

@gaswerks I like how they are skating into the image. The photo looks timeless. I can't tell whether you shot it this year or 100 years ago (apart from the clothing and skates of course). Skating like this requires true mastery.

@deep diver You really followed this weeks theme. In multiple dimensions. Lovely image

@akash.nu I like your interpretation of the theme. I have difficulty judging this type of photography: is it streetphotography or a snapshot. That is something that I have to work on.

@mollyc Now that's a true master. Maori? Beautiful. Athough I would like to see his whole head

@tizeye Ah! The conductor. A fast moving species. Hard to shoot. But definitely a master at his game.

@Somepix This made me smile. You nailed it.

@Darmok N Jalad I like how this master managed to capture the mothers gaze at the son. I am not fond of the lighting, but I guess that wasn't under your control.

@triptolemus Another wood master. Lovely. I would like the a tighter crop, or longer focal length, of the master.

@inkmich The image had me puzzled when I opened it on the telephone. I understand that it's hard to get the right shot when you're in the audience. The angle works but the shiny floor is distracting.

@someoldguy First place for you! That'll teach you slipping it in after closing. :) No, sorry. What's his mastery? Fishing of selling? I would like to see some cropping or editing to remove the distracting elements.


3rd place: somepix. Your image made me smile
2nd place: mollyc and deep diver
1st place: gaswerks. Your image made me come back to look.
Well done on the judging. I’m afraid I was too busy to enter this one, but will try for the next.
 

Scepticalscribe

macrumors Haswell
Jul 29, 2008
65,187
47,572
In a coffee shop.
Great judging, and challenging topic, @oblomow.

I thought the shot by @gaswerks absolutely brilliant - really well composed and conceived; I also loved @mollyc's atmospheric shot of the mastery an exceptionally gifted artist has over his medium, while @deep diver's timeless shot of a timepiece using an antique method of capturing the shot is excellent.

Some great pictures.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.