Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
56,994
56,019
Behind the Lens, UK
Okey dokey, stepping in for macmgg, here are my thoughts on the winter theme!

@Darmok N Jalad, a lovely woodpecker image, fantastic focus and good composition. On a technical basis, I think it's slightly underexposed, as I'd like to see the snow "snowier" and there is plenty of room for brightening, but snowy days often feel very gray, so this is a minor complaint.

@deep diver, this is my kind of winter image, as I am not a snow lover! ? A lovely image, it needs just the slightest bit of straighening, but I love the warm feel to it.

@cdcastillo, a clever repurposing for hospital decorations! ? Not being the contest originator, take my comment with a grain of salt, but this doens't really feel wintery, but more Christmassy, and to me there is a distinct difference between the two. That said, as deep diver shows, winter is different for everyone, and I realize this might be as close as you get to anything wintery where you live.

@Clix Pix, yes, a familiar sight to those of us with so far mild winters. Again, it feels more post holiday than actual winter, but I appreciate the effort of shooting something new for the challenge. ?

@StrollerEd, a ha! At last a real winter feeling image. I now know you are an iphone only shooter at present, but I'd encourage you to explore some of the editing apps; this image is too blue and a bit underexposed; shooting snow takes some technical know-how that you have to over-ride or edit default camera settings. That said, I like the composition of the lone tree and the bit of grass left safe by the tree branches.

@Apple fanboy, I have really enjoyed seeing your pastoral images lately. The sheep series are some of my favorite by you. Again, I see this as slightly underexposed, but I adore the subject matter and the capture of the falling snow.

@koolmagicguy, such a similar image to AFB's, other than the swap of animals. ? And your snow is white! It looks very peaceful there; I'd like to see a slight raise of the black point to bring in some detail to your subject, but a tricky overall exposure balance in this image for sure.

@OldMacs4Me, what a view! I love the light hitting the side of the mountain and that cloud cover is pretty fantastic. A nit picky comment would be that I'd like to see the bottom right of the image warmed up so it isn't blue snow, but again, snow is so hard for exposure and white balance.

@anotherscotsman, well a singular/macro type of image is right up my alley. Fantastic detail in the frost. Nicely balanced exposure and composition.

@someoldguy, a classic NYC view in the park. Winters in Manhattan can be brutal, and you make me wish I'd been a photographer when I lived there for two years. Just watch your white balance. ?

@Laird Knox, a lovely nighttime capture. I like the moon peeking out through the clouds. Nicely balanced exposure. For a winter image, I do wish just a bit more foregroud.

@tizeye, a good reminder that winters are different all over the world. I appreciate that you shared an image with winter birds since you live in a warmer climate, and that you explained the difference!

@oblomow, so not being a winter lover, I admit that this is what I feel when it reaches about 28*. Which is really not even that cold, but I don't tolerate cold well. ? I love that we can feel the whipping wind, and your wb and exposure are spot on.

@themumu, so you lost me at camping in the snow (see my comment above), but this looks like a lovely and peaceful spot. A bit underexposed again, and your subject gets a bit lost with the trees. I do love the leading line of the ski track though and it really helps guide your eye right to your subject.

@Janichsan, that is definitely not somewhere you should lose your footing! I would love to see just a bit of a wider view for some context of where you are, but great detail in the pieces of ice.


Okay, so since this was not really my competition to judge, I probably went a bit more technical on my comments than people are used to, as I wasn't really emotionally attached to this week's theme. My podium is as follows:

3. anotherscotsman and AFB

2. oblomow

1. StrollerEd...I love that you are working with the gear you have and asking questions on the POTD thread. ? Would love to see you lead next week's thread.

Cheers to all! ?
Thanks for the podium and thanks for stepping up for the judging. I liked the way all the sheep (well almost!) were looking at me. I think they were waiting for someone to rescue them. They didn’t look keen on the snow!
 

oblomow

macrumors 601
Apr 14, 2005
4,508
18,899
Netherlands
Thanks for stepping up, Molly! Your comments are useful and helpful, which can benefit all of us even if it is not our image being discussed. You're so right that when shooting snow scenes, correct exposure can be so tricky!

Congratulations, StrollerEd, Oblomow, AnotherScotsman and AFB! Well done, all of you!
Thanks you stepping up Molly! Congratulations @StrollerEd Can't wait for next weeks challenge.
The wind was 50mph and it was below zero (celsius). I ended of with some frostbite on my cheeks. Stupid amateur.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mollyc

tizeye

macrumors 68040
Jul 17, 2013
3,241
35,935
Orlando, FL
Okey dokey, stepping in for macmgg, here are my thoughts on the winter theme!

@tizeye, a good reminder that winters are different all over the world. I appreciate that you shared an image with winter birds since you live in a warmer climate, and that you explained the difference!

Okay, so since this was not really my competition to judge, I probably went a bit more technical on my comments than people are used to, as I wasn't really emotionally attached to this week's theme. My podium is as follows:

3. anotherscotsman and AFB

2. oblomow

1. StrollerEd...I love that you are working with the gear you have and asking questions on the POTD thread. ? Would love to see you lead next week's thread.

Cheers to all! ?
First, congratulations to those selected to the podium and @StrollerEd, look forward to the next topic. A job well done.

Molly, yes, being in a mild winter clime, it does create challenges and my other two possible entries were a snowman created out of beach sand with the surf in the background, or manatee who have a body temperature metabolism and tolerance similar to humans and need the 72 degree water from the springs to survive so they leave the colder river and primary food supply to cuddle up around the springs.

And then there is the other issue, held captive in the warm clime as COVID will not let me get to Switzerland to spoil my 4y/o (5 in March) grandson as Customs will not let us in the country. Thank goodness for Facebook and Facetime/Skype. Seeing him progress from prior year sled to skis, and spending weekends at the other grandparent's home - his father's childhood home. Ironically, the chalet has been in the family since the 1700's and the grandparents, who live on the upper floor, after a problem with a tenant, turned the lower floor over to their son and my daughter who converted it to an AirBnB...which can't be rented at this time anyway, so it becomes a well furnished weekend retreat with the separate living space.

It is difficult to see these, and videos, though as I can't enjoy the winter sports.
chalet.jpg
ski.jpg
 

anotherscotsman

macrumors 68020
Aug 2, 2014
2,369
16,735
UK
Okey dokey, stepping in for macmgg, here are my thoughts on the winter theme!

@Darmok N Jalad, a lovely woodpecker image, fantastic focus and good composition. On a technical basis, I think it's slightly underexposed, as I'd like to see the snow "snowier" and there is plenty of room for brightening, but snowy days often feel very gray, so this is a minor complaint.

@deep diver, this is my kind of winter image, as I am not a snow lover! ? A lovely image, it needs just the slightest bit of straighening, but I love the warm feel to it.

@cdcastillo, a clever repurposing for hospital decorations! ? Not being the contest originator, take my comment with a grain of salt, but this doens't really feel wintery, but more Christmassy, and to me there is a distinct difference between the two. That said, as deep diver shows, winter is different for everyone, and I realize this might be as close as you get to anything wintery where you live.

@Clix Pix, yes, a familiar sight to those of us with so far mild winters. Again, it feels more post holiday than actual winter, but I appreciate the effort of shooting something new for the challenge. ?

@StrollerEd, a ha! At last a real winter feeling image. I now know you are an iphone only shooter at present, but I'd encourage you to explore some of the editing apps; this image is too blue and a bit underexposed; shooting snow takes some technical know-how that you have to over-ride or edit default camera settings. That said, I like the composition of the lone tree and the bit of grass left safe by the tree branches.

@Apple fanboy, I have really enjoyed seeing your pastoral images lately. The sheep series are some of my favorite by you. Again, I see this as slightly underexposed, but I adore the subject matter and the capture of the falling snow.

@koolmagicguy, such a similar image to AFB's, other than the swap of animals. ? And your snow is white! It looks very peaceful there; I'd like to see a slight raise of the black point to bring in some detail to your subject, but a tricky overall exposure balance in this image for sure.

@OldMacs4Me, what a view! I love the light hitting the side of the mountain and that cloud cover is pretty fantastic. A nit picky comment would be that I'd like to see the bottom right of the image warmed up so it isn't blue snow, but again, snow is so hard for exposure and white balance.

@anotherscotsman, well a singular/macro type of image is right up my alley. Fantastic detail in the frost. Nicely balanced exposure and composition.

@someoldguy, a classic NYC view in the park. Winters in Manhattan can be brutal, and you make me wish I'd been a photographer when I lived there for two years. Just watch your white balance. ?

@Laird Knox, a lovely nighttime capture. I like the moon peeking out through the clouds. Nicely balanced exposure. For a winter image, I do wish just a bit more foregroud.

@tizeye, a good reminder that winters are different all over the world. I appreciate that you shared an image with winter birds since you live in a warmer climate, and that you explained the difference!

@oblomow, so not being a winter lover, I admit that this is what I feel when it reaches about 28*. Which is really not even that cold, but I don't tolerate cold well. ? I love that we can feel the whipping wind, and your wb and exposure are spot on.

@themumu, so you lost me at camping in the snow (see my comment above), but this looks like a lovely and peaceful spot. A bit underexposed again, and your subject gets a bit lost with the trees. I do love the leading line of the ski track though and it really helps guide your eye right to your subject.

@Janichsan, that is definitely not somewhere you should lose your footing! I would love to see just a bit of a wider view for some context of where you are, but great detail in the pieces of ice.


Okay, so since this was not really my competition to judge, I probably went a bit more technical on my comments than people are used to, as I wasn't really emotionally attached to this week's theme. My podium is as follows:

3. anotherscotsman and AFB

2. oblomow

1. StrollerEd...I love that you are working with the gear you have and asking questions on the POTD thread. ? Would love to see you lead next week's thread.

Cheers to all! ?
Thanks for stepping in @mollyc and congratulations to @StrollerEd. My entry was also an iPhone job so the close focus sort of came out of the box.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mollyc

mackmgg

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Nov 2, 2007
1,670
582
Gah! Forgot to finish that up before heading offline for the weekend! Thanks @mollyc for stepping in! Sorry for not posting sooner and making you do the extra work. As a bonus this means everyone who entered this contest gets double the feedback! I always keep my laptop and iPad on “Night Shift” at night, so I don’t think I would have noticed any blueness that was pointed out! Nice to look at, but not great for editing photos...

@Darmok N Jalad Nice shot! I’ve been enjoying watching the flickers that have taken to the tree outside my window recently. The nice thing about winter is you can watch the woodpeckers without the leaves in the way!

@deep diver Ah, the nice winter vacation! Looks warm and probably is warm as well! I’m sure a lot of people this year especially are wishing they could get to Mau.

@cdcastillo That’s a good use of discarded PPE! Saved it from the trash and also made a decoration out of it!

@Clix Pix Looked pretty similar here! Though despite a mild winter it did snow the day of compost pickup so the trees got covered.

@StrollerEd Green grass under snow! The only place you can usually find that is early/late season snow or golf courses! Everywhere else the grass tends to be dead by the time it snows. Certainly looks like nice weather for a walk!

@Apple fanboy That’s a nice winter shot! It always looks so nice in person, then it’s so hard to actually capture the falling snow in a shot while also capturing the background.

@koolmagicguy I like the contrast with the black cows and white snow! And a similar comment as above, I like that you can see the falling snow pretty well even compared to the background.

@OldMacs4Me I’m always a fan of mountains with snow! Unfortunately this year ours have been pretty bare so far, but it seems like that may be changing soon! I like the lighting there too, with just the side of a few peaks getting that last (or first?) bit of sunshine.

@anotherscotsman Now that’s sure got the feeling of winter! The nice look where the vegetation starts to frost but there isn’t quite much snow. Nice macro!

@someoldguy Central Park in the snow! That’s always a nice view from there, especially while it’s still snowy and not yet slushy!

@Laird Knox That’s a nice shot! The church stands out so nicely in the snow, especially with the light. And it looks like the moon is just peaking out from behind the clouds! It’s a bit close to the edge of the frame, but it’s always so hard to balance fitting everything in! And if the moon were further down I think the church wouldn’t look as good, so that’s a good composition!

@tizeye As @mollyc pointed out, it’s always interesting hearing the different winters everywhere. White pelicans here are a summer bird, and have gone south by now. South to you apparently! That’s a nice shot of a bunch of them in the water!

@oblomow That definitely captures winter to me! Snowy, windy, and going for a hike! I think I would have cropped that one in a bit more, but it’s otherwise a pretty nice shot!

@themumu Tahoe I assume? It would certainly be nice if we could get some of that powder this year! On the other hand, all winter camping this year has been on dry ground! Looks pretty peaceful there in that shot! Although I know the feeling of realizing at 2am that the gear you brought isn’t quite sufficient, and that’s never fun...

@Janichsan Even without the snow, the ice always feels like winter! I’m assuming that’s a creek or river? Seems a bit rough to be a lake. It’s always fun when they’re frozen enough walk over, but it doesn’t look like that one is there yet.

Anyway, here’s a bonus pic from the weekend’s adventure:
1610994502309.jpeg

Snow in places, but mostly dry. By January there should definitely be more snow though! On the other hand, our snowiest months aren’t until February and March, so it could still be coming
 

Ish

macrumors 68020
Nov 30, 2004
2,241
795
UK
Thanks for the feedback @mollyc I'm not a winter lover either and I don't do cold, despite the fact that I once went to Iceland for 15 months! :) I live in one of the dryer parts of the UK so winters here don't tend to see snow, and only a few frosty nights, everything just gets rather grey.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mollyc

Laird Knox

macrumors 68000
Jun 18, 2010
1,958
1,346
@Laird Knox, a lovely nighttime capture. I like the moon peeking out through the clouds. Nicely balanced exposure. For a winter image, I do wish just a bit more foregroud.

Thanks for stepping up. There was a rare snow in Las Vegas so I drove up to Mt Charleston to play with some long exposures in the falling snow. When we got to the location there wasn't a cloud in the sky. About 20 minutes later the clouds filled in.

It it weren't for the clouds the moon would have been blown out. It was just the right amount of coverage to give that nice exposure. I was shooting with a tungsten white balance and that's why the sky is so blue. Across the street there is a lodge with a lot of incandescent lighting and that is what is lighting up the foreground in the picture.

As for the foreground I brought the image right up to the edge of the roadway. Any lower and it would have been ugly brown slush. I probably could have dropped the tripod down a foot or two to exaggerate the foreground but I didn't think of that at the time as I was standing in a snowbank on the other side of the road. ;)

For a quick, unplanned run up the mountain I'm happy with it but agree with your critique. The more we talk about those things the more they get stuck in our mental checklist while shooting.

@Laird Knox That’s a nice shot! The church stands out so nicely in the snow, especially with the light. And it looks like the moon is just peaking out from behind the clouds! It’s a bit close to the edge of the frame, but it’s always so hard to balance fitting everything in! And if the moon were further down I think the church wouldn’t look as good, so that’s a good composition!

Thanks! The steeple is a bit blown out. As I recall this was a quick edit when I got home that night. I did more work on it later before printing. If it weren't for the moon I would have likely shot the church in landscape orientation. Now that I look at it I might go back and try cropping it in landscape. It is a 32 MP image so there is room to play.

Thanks for the feedback.
 

StrollerEd

macrumors 6502a
Aug 13, 2011
995
6,938
Scotland
@StrollerEd Green grass under snow! The only place you can usually find that is early/late season snow or golf courses! Everywhere else the grass tends to be dead by the time it snows. Certainly looks like nice weather for a walk!

It is indeed on a golf course, one of several in our area with lots of rough upon which to walk whilst them with sticks were elsewhere ;)
 

Janichsan

macrumors 68040
Oct 23, 2006
3,126
11,922
@Janichsan, that is definitely not somewhere you should lose your footing! I would love to see just a bit of a wider view for some context of where you are, but great detail in the pieces of ice.
@Janichsan Even without the snow, the ice always feels like winter! I’m assuming that’s a creek or river? Seems a bit rough to be a lake. It’s always fun when they’re frozen enough walk over, but it doesn’t look like that one is there yet.
Close. It's the canal habour in my hometown. The ice was already melting that day.
eo1qx6D.jpg
 

OldMacs4Me

macrumors 68020
May 4, 2018
2,327
29,968
Wild Rose And Wind Belt
Thanks for the feedback guys.
Okey dokey, stepping in for macmgg, here are my thoughts on the winter theme!
...

@OldMacs4Me, what a view! I love the light hitting the side of the mountain and that cloud cover is pretty fantastic. A nit picky comment would be that I'd like to see the bottom right of the image warmed up so it isn't blue snow, but again, snow is so hard for exposure and white balance.
...
Cheers to all! ?
Yes and morning or evening lighting exaggerates the colour shift between shade and sunshine as does altitude, though we are really not all that high here in Southern Alberta. A couple of different workings, shifted everything to the red to make it look more like a sunset, then reduced saturation level in the shaded area.

Also makes a good B&W.

BTW Original was maybe 15 minutes shy of being a sunset.

SevenSistersC.jpg


SevenSistersE.jpg
 

Apple fanboy

macrumors Ivy Bridge
Feb 21, 2012
56,994
56,019
Behind the Lens, UK
Thanks for the feedback guys.

Yes and morning or evening lighting exaggerates the colour shift between shade and sunshine as does altitude, though we are really not all that high here in Southern Alberta. A couple of different workings, shifted everything to the red to make it look more like a sunset, then reduced saturation level in the shaded area.

Also makes a good B&W.

BTW Original was maybe 15 minutes shy of being a sunset.

View attachment 1716929

View attachment 1716931
Both beautiful, but the colour for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StrollerEd
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.